I’m diving into the world of compact firearms to bring you the lowdown on two popular choices: the Taurus G2S Vs M&P Shield.
I’ve had the chance to take both of these guns out for a spin, putting them through their paces to see which one truly stands out.
My aim here is to help you understand the details of each model, comparing their features, feel, and performance in real-world scenarios.
| Feature | Taurus G2S | M&P Shield |
| Caliber | 9mm | 9mm |
| Capacity | 7+1 | 7+1 (+8 variant) |
| Barrel Length | 3.25″ | 3.1″ |
| Overall Length | 6.25″ | 6.1″ |
| Width | 1.10″ | 0.99″ |
| Height | 4.8″ | 4.5″ |
| Weight | 19.85 oz. | 18.3 oz. |
Overview of Taurus G2S
The Taurus G2S is a slim and compact 9mm pistol designed for those who prioritize ease of carry without sacrificing performance. It’s a versatile choice for both concealed carry and casual range shooting.
Specs
- Caliber: 9mm
- Round capacity: 7+1
- Barrel length: 3.25 inches
- Overall length: 6.25 inches
- Overall width: 1.10 inches
- Overall height: 4.8 inches
- Overall weight: 19.85 oz.
Overview of M&P Shield
The M&P Shield by Smith & Wesson is a highly regarded 9mm pistol that combines reliability and ergonomics into a sleek, concealable package, making it a top choice for personal defense.
Specs
- Caliber: 9mm
- Barrel length: 3.1 inches
- Overall length: 6.1 inches
- Overall width: 0.99 inches
- Overall height: 4.5 inches
- Weight: 18.3 oz.
Features Comparison of Taurus G2S VS M&P Shield
1. Ergonomics and Grip Texture
Taurus G2S
The Taurus G2S’s grip texture is akin to a meticulously executed stipple job. This enhanced texture envelops the front, back, and sides of the grip, ensuring a steadfast hold even when your palms are slick with sweat.
My hands-on experience underscored how this superior grip texture not only boosts comfort but also significantly elevates control during dynamic shooting exercises.
Its assertive grip is particularly advantageous in stress-induced scenarios, providing a tactile advantage that’s both felt and appreciated.
M&P Shield
Conversely, the M&P Shield adopts a more restrained approach to grip texture. Its subtlety is designed to prevent abrasion during concealed carry, a thoughtful consideration for everyday comfort.
However, during rigorous testing at the range, this subdued texture sometimes fell short in providing the necessary grip under moist conditions or when executing rapid-fire sequences.
This led to moments where a firmer grip would have been preferred, highlighting a trade-off between comfort and control.
Winner
When juxtaposed, the Taurus G2S distinctly outperforms the M&P Shield in the realm of ergonomics and grip texture.
Its aggressive, yet comfortable stippling offers a level of assurance and stability that is indispensable for precise and controlled shooting, marking it as the superior choice for those prioritizing grip efficacy.
2. Accessory Compatibility
Taurus G2S
A defining characteristic of the Taurus G2S is its integrated accessory rail, a feature that significantly augments its adaptability and functionality.
This addition allows for the straightforward attachment of a myriad of accessories, including tactical lights and laser sights, enhancing the pistol’s utility across various operational contexts.
My testing demonstrated the ease with which accessories could be mounted, transforming the G2S into a versatile tool for both defensive scenarios and target engagement in diminished light conditions.
M&P Shield
The M&P Shield, in this regard, takes a more reserved stance, lacking an inherent accessory rail. This omission restricts its immediate compatibility with a range of tactical enhancements directly out of the box.
Despite the availability of aftermarket solutions for attaching accessories, these alternatives do not match the convenience or stability provided by a dedicated rail system.
This limitation was evident during nocturnal shooting exercises, where the addition of auxiliary lighting would have been advantageous.
Winner
In the arena of accessory compatibility, the Taurus G2S clearly distinguishes itself as the superior platform. Its provision of an accessory rail opens up extensive customization possibilities, allowing shooters to tailor the firearm to their specific needs and preferences.
This level of versatility is invaluable, particularly in environments where adaptability can mean the difference between success and failure, securing the G2S’s position as the top contender compared to the M&P Shield.
3. Overall Concealability
Taurus G2S
The Taurus G2S, with its overall width of 1.10 inches, offers a slightly bulkier profile, which may be noticeable depending on your preferred method of carry.
In my field tests, the G2S’s size was not a hindrance, but it did require careful selection of clothing to ensure optimal concealment.
M&P Shield
The M&P Shield shines in the concealability department, thanks to its slim profile of just 0.99 inches in width.
During my testing, this made the Shield remarkably easier to conceal under a wider range of clothing without printing, providing a more versatile carry option.
Winner
For overall concealability, the M&P Shield takes the lead. Its slimmer profile offers more discreet carry options compared to the Taurus G2S, making it the better choice for those prioritizing concealment.
Pros & Cons of Taurus G2S
Pros
- More affordable price point.
- Aggressive grip texture enhances control.
- Equipped with an accessory rail for attachments.
Cons
- Trigger isn’t crisp.
Pros & Cons of M&P Shield
Pros
- Slimmer profile for superior concealability.
- Proven reliability with a strong track record.
- Subtle safety lever minimizes accidental engagement.
Cons
- Higher price point.
Similarities between Taurus G2S & M&P Shield
- Both chambered in 9mm.
- Designed for concealed carry with compact dimensions.
- Polymer frames with stainless-steel slides.
- Feature loaded chamber indicators.
Differences between Taurus G2S & M&P Shield
- Taurus G2S has a slightly longer overall length and is wider.
- M&P Shield offers a slimmer profile for enhanced concealability.
- Grip texture on the G2S is more aggressive than on the Shield.
Final Verdict
After rigorous testing and thorough comparison of the Taurus G2S and the M&P Shield, I’ve reached a verdict.
Each firearm has its strengths and caters to different preferences and needs. However, the M&P Shield emerges as the overall winner in most comparisons.
Its superior concealability, refined safety features, and proven reliability make it an exceptional choice for everyday carry.
FAQ’s
Is the Taurus G2S a good gun?
Yes, the Taurus G2S has shown excellent reliability in tests, firing 300 rounds without any issues, indicating Taurus’s commitment to improving their firearms’ reliability.
Is M&P Shield better than Glock?
Comparatively, the M&P Shield is considered more challenging to shoot than the Glock 19 due to its smaller size and recoil, but it is highly subjective and depends on the shooter’s preference.
Is G2C or G2S Taurus better?
The choice between Taurus G2C and G2S depends on the individual’s needs; the G2C offers a slightly larger size with more capacity, while the G2S is smaller for those prioritizing compactness.
Are M&P Shields good guns to carry?
Yes, the M&P Shield is an excellent choice for concealed carry, offering lightness, compactness, and reliability from a trusted manufacturer.
