I’ve been on a mission to determine which pistol reigns supreme: the Springfield XDM Elite Vs Glock 17.
Both of these guns have a strong following, but I wanted to see how they stack up in real-world conditions.
So, I took both out to the field for a thorough comparison. This article is all about my findings and experiences. I’ll break down each gun’s specs, share my hands-on experience, and maybe, just maybe, we’ll crown a winner by the end of this.
| Feature | Springfield XDM Elite | Glock 17 |
| Type | Semi-Auto Pistol | Semi-Auto Pistol |
| Action | Double Action Only | Safe Action |
| Caliber/Gauge | 9mm | 9mm |
| Finish | Black Melonite | nDLC Finish |
| Frame | Polymer | Polymer |
| Barrel Length | 4.5 inches | 4.49 inches |
| Overall Length | 7.6 inches | 7.95 inches |
| Capacity | 20 + 1 rounds | 17 + 1 rounds |
| Number of Magazines | 2 | 3 |
| Magazine Description | 20 rd. | 17 rd. |
| Weight | 29 oz. | 24.97 oz. |
Springfield XDM Elite
The Springfield XDM Elite is a sleek, modern pistol that’s grabbed the attention of many shooters. It’s part of the renowned XD(M) series by Springfield Armory.
Spec
- Type: Semi-Auto Pistol
- Action: Double Action Only
- Caliber/Gauge: 9mm
- Finish: Black Melonite
- Frame: Polymer
- Stock/Grips: Black Polymer
- Barrel Length: 4.5 inches
- Overall Length: 7.6 inches
- Capacity: 20 + 1 rounds
- Number of Magazines: 2
- Magazine Description: 20 rd.
- Weight: 29 oz.
Glock 17
The Glock 17, a member of the renowned G17 series, is a classic that has been the go-to choice for many shooters and law enforcement agencies worldwide.
Specs
- Type: Semi-Auto Pistol
- Action: Safe Action
- Caliber/Gauge: 9mm
- Finish: nDLC Finish
- Frame: Polymer
- Barrel Length: 4.49 inches
- Overall Length: 7.95 inches
- Capacity: 17 + 1 rounds
- Number of Magazines: 3
- Magazine Description: 17 rd.
- Sights: Glock Fixed Sights
- Weight: 24.97 oz.
Features Comparison of Springfield XDM Elite VS Glock 17
1. Ergonomics and Grip
Springfield XDM Elite
The Springfield XDM Elite’s grip design showcases a less aggressive yet highly effective texturing, offering a comfortable and secure handling experience.
The ergonomics of this model are particularly impressive, with a grip size that accommodates a wide range of hand sizes, ensuring stability and control during shooting. Notably, both the magazine and slide releases are authentically ambidextrous, making the XDM Elite an excellent option for left-handed shooters.
This thoughtful design choice highlights Springfield’s commitment to versatility and inclusivity in their firearms.
Glock 17
The Glock 17, particularly in its Gen 5 iteration, has undergone significant ergonomic enhancements.
The key change has been the removal of finger grooves, providing a more universally accommodating grip that suits a diverse array of hand sizes. This model features a more pronounced grip texture, which may be preferable for those seeking a firmer grip.
The magazine release, while not ambidextrous out of the box, is reversible, catering to left-handed users. Additionally, the slide release is ambidextrous, a feature that further enhances its user-friendliness.
Winner
The Springfield XDM Elite narrowly edges out the Glock 17 in this category. Its combination of less aggressive texturing with ample grip space makes it a versatile choice for various hand types.
Moreover, the genuinely ambidextrous controls of the XDM Elite offer a significant advantage, particularly for left-handed shooters, ensuring a more inclusive and adaptable user experience.
2. Safety Features
Springfield XDM Elite
The XDM Elite stands out with its comprehensive safety system, which includes multiple features to ensure secure handling. The beavertail grip safety is a standout component, requiring engagement for the pistol to fire, thus adding an extra layer of safety.
Furthermore, the pistol is equipped with a striker status indicator and a loaded chamber indicator, both of which provide visual and tactile confirmation of the gun’s status.
Glock 17
The Glock 17 maintains a more streamlined approach to safety with its ‘Safe Action’ trigger system. This system, while simplistic, offers effective safety through a trigger-based mechanism, which acts as both a psychological reassurance and a practical safety feature.
Although it lacks some of the external safety features present in Springfield, the Glock’s minimalistic safety design appeals to many experienced shooters who prefer a more straightforward, no-frills approach to firearm safety.
Winner
In terms of safety features, the Springfield XDM Elite takes the lead. Its extensive safety system, including active and passive elements like the grip safety and visual indicators, provides a higher level of safety assurance.
This makes Springfield particularly appealing for those who prioritize comprehensive safety features in their firearms.
3. Slide Operation and Magwell Design
Springfield XDM Elite
The XDM Elite excels in slide operation, featuring rear and front serrations that are significantly more aggressive than those of its counterpart.
This design ensures a better grip and more controlled slide manipulation. The pistol also boasts a flared magwell and a tapered magazine, a combination that significantly enhances the speed and ease of magazine changes.
This is a notable advantage in competitive shooting or high-stress scenarios where quick reloading is critical.
Glock 17
Glock 17’s slide operation is efficient and reliable, though it may feel slightly less smooth in comparison to the Springfield. The slide features both rear and front serrations, but they are not as pronounced as those on the Springfield.
The magwell of the Glock 17 is less flared, which might impact the speed of magazine changes to a small degree. However, it still maintains a high level of performance and reliability. The magazine design is straightforward and functional, though it lacks the tapered design seen in the Springfield.
Winner
In this area, the Springfield XDM Elite emerges as the superior choice. Its smoother slide operation, coupled with more pronounced serrations, offers enhanced control and ease of use.
Additionally, the flared magwell and tapered magazine design make magazine changes faster and more efficient, giving the Springfield an edge in situations where quick action is necessary.
4. Trigger Mechanism
Springfield XDM Elite
The Springfield XDM Elite features a flat trigger, which provides a crisp, clean break. The pre-trigger is more extended and defined, offering a noticeable travel before the actual trigger pull.
This feature enhances control and predictability, which is crucial for precise shooting. The tactile feedback is clear, aiding in consistent firing.
Glock 17
The Glock 17 sports its classic ‘Safe Action’ trigger, which is more rounded compared to the Springfield’s flat design. The trigger has a distinct pre-travel, followed by a consistent and predictable break. The simplicity of the Glock’s trigger is its strength, providing reliability and a familiar feel for many shooters.
Winner
The winner here is subjective and depends on personal preference. However, the Springfield XDM Elite’s flat trigger provides a slightly more refined shooting experience, especially for those who value a defined trigger pull and reset. The extended pre-trigger offers an added layer of control compared to the Glock 17.
Pros & Cons of Springfield XDM Elite
Pros
- Ambidextrous controls
- Enhanced safety features
- Flat, responsive trigger
- Flared magwell for faster reloads
Cons
- Slightly heavier than Glock 17
Pros & Cons of Glock 17
Pros
- Lightweight and reliable
- Simple and effective safety mechanism
- Wide aftermarket support
- Universal grip design without finger grooves
Cons
- Less advanced safety features
Similarities Between Springfield XDM Elite & Glock 17
- Both are semi-auto, polymer frame pistols.
- Both models chambered in 9mm.
- Similar overall lengths and barrel sizes.
- Both have fixed sight types.
- Renowned for their reliability and durability.
Differences Between Springfield XDM Elite & Glock 17
- Springfield has a double action only mechanism, Glock has a safe action.
- Springfield has a black melonite finish, Glock has an nDLC finish.
- Springfield’s magazine capacity is 20+1, Glock’s is 17+1.
- Springfield weighs 29 oz, Glock weighs 24.97 oz.
- Springfield has more advanced safety features.
- Glock has a wider range of aftermarket accessories.
- Springfield’s trigger is flat, Glock’s is rounded.
- Springfield has a flared magwell, Glock does not.
Final Verdict
As a shooter who has rigorously tested both the Springfield XDM Elite and the Glock 17, making a final decision isn’t straightforward, given the impressive qualities of both pistols.
However, after extensive consideration and evaluation, the Springfield XDM Elite stands out as my preferred choice.
This preference stems from the overall experience during testing, where the Springfield consistently demonstrated superior performance in crucial areas.
FAQ’s
Is the Springfield XDM Elite a good carry gun?
Yes, the Springfield XDM Elite is a fantastic choice for a carry gun, offering reliability, a comfortable shooting experience, and competitive pricing, making it suitable for both competition and concealed carry.
Which Springfield is comparable to Glock 19?
The Springfield XD9 is comparable to the Glock 19. It’s more concealable and a better choice if you need a gun for concealed carry, especially in situations where concealment is a priority.
Why is Glock 17 better than 19?
The Glock 17 may offer slightly better accuracy at longer ranges due to its size and barrel length, while the Glock 19 is more maneuverable and easier to handle in close quarters.
Is Springfield XD a Glock clone?
The Springfield XD, while influenced by Glock’s design, is not a direct clone. It has its own unique features that set it apart.
