I’m bringing you a head-to-head comparison of two top contenders in the world of compact handguns: the SIG P365 Vs S&W Shield Plus.
Based on my extensive field testing, I aim to break down each gun’s features, performance, and overall feel. As someone who’s spent much time with both these firearms, I’m excited to share my insights. Let’s dive right in.
| Feature | SIG P365 | Shield Plus |
| Caliber | 9mm | 9mm |
| Length | 5.8 inches | 6.1 inches |
| Height | 4.3 inches | 4.6 inches |
| Width | 1 inch | 1.1 inches |
| Barrel Length | 3.1 inches | 3.1 inches |
| Trigger Pull Weight | 6 pounds | 5 lbs., 6 oz. |
| Sights | XRAY3 Day/Night Sights | Steel; three white dots |
| Weight | 17.8 ounces | 1 lb., 3.7 oz. |
| Magazine Capacity | 10+1, 12 rounds optional | 10+1, 13+1 rds. |
| Slide Material | Stainless Steel | Stainless Steel |
| Finish | Nitron | Armornite, black |
Overview: SIG P365
The SIG P365 burst onto the scene as a game-changer in the micro-compact 9mm category. It’s known for its innovative design that packs a surprising amount of firepower into a tiny frame.
Specs
- Caliber: 9mm
- Length: 5.8 inches
- Height: 4.3 inches
- Width: 1 inch
- Barrel Length: 3.1 inches
- Trigger Pull Weight: 6 pounds
- Sights: XRAY3 Day/Night Sights
- Weight: 17.8 ounces (with empty magazine)
- Slide Material: Stainless Steel
- Slide Finish: Nitron
- Magazine Capacity: Standard: 10+1, Optional: 12-round magazine available
Overview: Shield Plus
Now, let’s talk about the Smith & Wesson M&P9 Shield Plus. This firearm is a direct response to the growing demand for high-capacity, yet compact, handguns. Like the P365, it’s a 9mm, but with its unique attributes.
Specs
- Cartridge: 9mm
- Capacity: 10+1 rds., 13+1 rds.
- Barrel: 3.1 inches, stainless steel
- Overall Length: 6.1 inches
- Width: 1.1 inches
- Height: 4.6 inches
- Weight: 1 lb., 3.7 oz.
- Finish: Armornite, black (stainless steel)
- Sights: Steel; three white dots
- Trigger: 5 lbs., 6 oz. (tested)
Features Comparison: SIG P365 VS Shield Plus
1. Trigger Quality
SIG P365
The trigger on the SIG P365 is quite a performer. During my tests, I found it to be responsive and crisp, with a decent pull weight that feels just right for a compact handgun.
Though a tad longer than some competitors, the reset is still precise, making follow-up shots manageable. When firing rapidly at the range, this trigger allowed for quick, accurate shot placement, enhancing the shooting experience, especially considering the P365’s compact size.
Shield Plus
The Shield Plus steps up the game in the trigger department. Its trigger is noticeably smoother and lighter compared to the SIG P365.
During my testing, the shorter and faster reset really stood out, allowing for quicker follow-up shots. This quality was especially apparent in rapid-fire scenarios, where I could maintain control and accuracy more efficiently. The overall feel of the trigger is less mushy and more tactile, providing a more satisfying shooting experience.
Winner
The winner for me in the trigger quality department is the Shield Plus. It’s just hard to overlook the improved shooting experience it offers with its smoother, lighter trigger and faster reset.
These features give it a noticeable edge in rapid-fire situations, making it more user-friendly, especially for those who prioritize speed and accuracy. The Shield Plus’s trigger feels more refined compared to the P365, enhancing overall shootability, particularly in more demanding shooting scenarios.
2. Ergonomics and Handling
SIG P365
Ergonomics on the SIG P365 are tailored for concealability and comfort. Its compact frame makes it exceptionally easy to handle and conceal, even for shooters with smaller hands.
During my tests, the P365 felt natural and unobtrusive, offering a firm grip despite its smaller size. The balance of the firearm is spot-on, making it easy to draw, aim, and shoot. Its lightweight nature didn’t impede the accuracy, even when shooting with one hand, a testament to its ergonomic design.
Shield Plus
The Shield Plus offers a slightly larger frame than the P365, which translates to better grip and control, especially for shooters with larger hands.
In my field tests, the additional weight and larger grip surface of the Shield Plus provided a more stable shooting platform. This was particularly noticeable during extended shooting sessions, where the additional grip area reduced hand fatigue.
The ergonomics are well thought out, ensuring that controls are easily accessible and that the handgun feels balanced and comfortable in hand.
Winner
Choosing a winner in ergonomics and handling is a bit subjective, but for me, it’s the Shield Plus. Its slightly larger frame offers a more comfortable grip and better control, especially under rapid-fire conditions.
While the SIG P365 is excellent for concealability and ease of carrying, the Shield Plus wins out overall
3. Concealability
SIG P365
The SIG P365 is a marvel when it comes to concealability. Its compact size, with a slim profile, makes it an ideal choice for concealed carry.
In my field tests, it was remarkably easy to conceal under various clothing styles without printing. The small footprint of the P365 provides a significant advantage for discreet carry, especially in settings where discretion is paramount.
Shield Plus
The Shield Plus, while still compact, is a tad larger than the P365. During testing, I noticed it’s slightly more challenging to conceal, especially under lighter clothing.
The slightly increased dimensions and weight make it a bit more noticeable compared to the P365. However, it still remains a viable option for concealed carry, particularly for those who prefer a slightly larger grip.
Winner
The clear winner in terms of concealability is the SIG P365. Its smaller frame and lighter weight give it a distinct advantage.
In practical scenarios, the difference in concealability can be significant, making the P365 a better choice for those prioritizing stealth and comfort in their concealed carry firearm.
Pros & Cons: SIG P365
Pros
- Exceptional concealability due to compact size.
- Lightweight, enhancing ease of carry.
- Good trigger quality offering crisp and responsive action.
- XRAY3 Day/Night Sights for improved visibility.
- Versatile magazine capacity options.
Cons
- The trigger reset is slightly longer compared to some competitors.
Pros & Cons: Shield Plus
Pros
- Improved trigger quality with smoother, lighter pull and faster reset.
- Larger frame provides better grip and control.
- High capacity without significantly increasing size.
- Durable Armornite finish.
- Versatile with multiple variant options.
Cons
- Slightly more challenging to conceal than the P365.
Similarities between SIG P365 & Shield Plus
- Both are 9mm caliber compact handguns.
- Similar barrel length of 3.1 inches.
- Both designed for concealed carry.
- Striker-fired operation.
- Offer options for extended magazine capacities.
Differences between SIG P365 & Shield Plus
- SIG P365 is smaller and lighter than the Shield Plus.
- Shield Plus has a smoother and lighter trigger compared to the P365.
- P365 offers XRAY3 Day/Night Sights, while Shield Plus has standard three-dot sights.
- Shield Plus has a slightly wider and taller frame than the P365.
- P365 had initial reliability challenges, Shield Plus known for consistent reliability.
- SIG P365 offers more variants and customization options.
Final Verdict
After thoroughly testing both the SIG P365 and the Smith & Wesson M&P9 Shield Plus, I’ve arrived at a conclusion that reflects the overall performance, ergonomics, and suitability for concealed carry.
In most comparisons, the Smith & Wesson M&P9 Shield Plus emerged as my preferred choice. The Shield Plus offers a slightly better shooting experience, particularly in terms of trigger quality and ergonomics.
Its more substantial frame and superior grip, combined with a smoother trigger, contribute to better control and comfort, especially in rapid-fire scenarios.
FAQ’s
What is the difference between P365 and SAS?
The main difference between the P365 and the SAS is that the SAS model is designed for a snag-free profile with a unique sighting system, while the standard P365 has standard sights and controls.
Why is the P365 considered one of the best?
The P365 is highly regarded for its excellent balance of capacity, manageability, reliability, and modularity, making it an outstanding choice for concealed carry.
What gun is comparable to the SIG P365?
A comparable gun to the SIG P365 is the Taurus GX4, which shares similar dimensions and ergonomic features, although each has its own unique characteristics.
Is the M&P Shield better than Glock?
Comparing the M&P Shield to a Glock, like the Glock 19, depends on personal preference. The Glock 19 is larger and absorbs recoil better, while the M&P Shield is more compact but with more noticeable recoil.
How accurate is the P365?
The P365 is known for its practical accuracy, being quick into action and easy to handle, with good performance in various shooting drills from short to moderate distances.
I agree fully with your review. After comparing both the 365 and the Shield, I also opted for the S&W. The balance was further in the Shield’s favor because of the trigger safety. It’s small and unobtrusive but provides me with additional confidence while concealed in a pocket.
Really appreciate your input! It’s great to hear the Shield’s trigger safety adds that extra layer of confidence for you, especially for pocket carry. It’s those little details that can make a big difference. Thanks for sharing your experience!