4 Taurus Judge Problems You Must Be Aware of

Last Update:

I have extensively tested the Taurus Judge Problems in the field. Having spent considerable time with it, I’ve recognised a few common problems that may affect users.

I encountered recurring issues, such as problems with the ejection process, cylinder malfunctions, trigger and hammer locking, and jamming issues. 

These concerns are not just mere observations; I faced them in real scenarios. Now, I feel compelled to share my findings and tried-and-true solutions I’ve developed to overcome these issues.

Overview of the Problems & their Solutions

Problems with EjectionClean the gun thoroughly; avoid using oil in the cylinder.
Cylinder Problems Inspect and replace weak springs, sharpen locking bolts or consult a gunsmith.
Trigger & Hammer Locking IssueBrush out the gunpowder buildup under the shell remover.
Jamming Issues Change the ammunition brand to one that is compatible with the Taurus Judge Polymer.

Top 4 Taurus Judge Problems & Solutions

1. Problems with the Ejection 

One of the first issues I ran into was the problem of used shells getting stuck in the cylinder. 

This was baffling initially, and I noticed it with newly purchased Judge revolvers. Upon investigation, I discovered two possible causes. 

First, packing grease inside the cylinder, used by manufacturers to prevent rust, was one culprit. 

Second, I found some bullets had slightly larger shells than others – an unusual and unpredictable anomaly that wasn’t the fault of any particular brand or Taurus itself.


Our fix for this issue was quite straightforward. I realized that cleaning the gun thoroughly right after unboxing it was essential. 

Ensuring that no packing grease was left in the cylinder solved my problem. I also learned not to use oil in the cylinder, as it tends to bind the used shells. 

I found This simple yet effective solution after hands-on testing, and I believe it will work for others facing the same problem. 

Proper cleaning took care of the issue, whether it was the packing grease or the anomalous larger shells.

2. Cylinder Problems

During my field tests, I were startled to find that the Taurus Judge Polymer revolver cylinder could rotate slightly in either direction, even when locked. 

This issue appeared even when the gun was loaded. The problem was perplexing, and I attributed it to various factors like rough handling, weak locking springs, improper locking bolt size, or rounded locking bolts. 

Additionally, I faced another cylinder problem where it got stuck and wouldn’t release, possibly due to a faulty front detent ball, dirt buildup, or a bent extractor rod.


The fix I implemented started with taking off the cylinder for a careful inspection. I looked at the possible reasons and checked them one by one. 

When I found a weak spring, I replaced it, following an easy online tutorial. I also examined the locking bolt size and its edge, involving an expert. Sharpening the rounded edge of the bolt proved effective. 

All else failed; my last resort was to send the gun to Taurus for fixing. Regarding the stuck cylinder, proper lubrication or a trip to the gunsmith resolved the problem, along with cleaning debris or replacing a bent rod. 

These hands-on experiences helped me grasp these problems and find practical solutions.

3. Trigger & Hammer Locking Issue

While out testing the Taurus Judge, I ran into a disconcerting problem with the trigger and hammer locking, even though the cylinder was still rotating. 

This occurred as I were shooting 410 shells, and it took me a bit of investigative work to figure out what was going on. 

I found that a buildup of gunpowder under the shell remover was the root cause. It was hindering the cylinder from fitting flush as it should.


The fix for this issue was surprisingly simple but required careful observation. I needed to brush out the gunpowder that had built up in the troublesome spot. 

After a thorough cleaning, the gun was back to working fine. This solution worked for us, but I recognize that it might not be the solution for everyone. 

Nevertheless, I believe that meticulous cleaning and attention to detail can prevent or solve such unexpected malfunctions.

4. Jamming Issues

In my series of field tests with the Taurus Judge, I encountered a specific jamming issue that also seemed quite common among other users. 

The revolver jammed while using Winchester .45 Colt Long bullets, leaving me puzzled. It became clear that Judge Polymer was selective about the ammunition, especially in the newly manufactured units. 

I spent some time analyzing this issue, and it was evident that this was not an isolated occurrence but something that needed addressing.


The solution to this problem turned out to be as straightforward as it gets. I found that changing the ammunition brand did the trick. 

Unlike other revolvers of a similar kind, like Ruger, which didn’t have this issue, the Judge Polymer seemed to prefer certain brands over others.

Our experience taught me that being aware of this peculiarity and choosing the right brand of ammunition could avoid this jamming problem altogether.


Despite its challenges, the Taurus Judge proved to be a fascinating firearm to test and review in the field. 

Its various issues, such as problems with ejection, cylinder malfunctions, and jamming, presented me with opportunities to delve deeper and find pragmatic solutions. 

While some may see these issues as significant weaknesses, my hands-on experience revealed that the problems were largely solvable with proper maintenance, care, and an understanding of the gun’s particular preferences. 

The Taurus Judge may not be the right fit for everyone, particularly novices who may struggle with certain aspects like recoil. Still, for those willing to engage with its intricacies, it offers an appealing combination of versatility and power.


Does the Taurus Judge kick hard? 

Yes, especially for revolver newbies.

What is the point of the Taurus Judge? 

It is designed for self-defense and home protection.

Is a Taurus Judge loud? 

No, it’s relatively quiet.

Is there safety on a Taurus Judge? 

Yes, it includes transfer-bar safety.

Is it OK to dry fire a Taurus Judge? 

Yes, except for .22 caliber models.

One Request?

I worked hard on this post to help the shooters community. it would help me a lot if you consider sharing it on social media network

BecauseSharing Is Caring..

Because Sharing Is Caring..

Photo of author


I'm Micheal, an avid shooter and hunting enthusiast from Texas. I'm a recreational shooter who loves to spend time at the range and enjoy learning about new firearms and gears. I love to write about guns and share my passion for shooting with others.

Leave a Comment