I’m here to dive into an exciting comparison between two popular firearms: the Springfield XDM Elite Compact Vs Glock 19.
As a professional shooter, I’ve had the chance to test these guns out in the field, pushing them to their limits.
In this article, I’ll be sharing my firsthand experience, helping you determine which one might be the winner for your needs.
| Feature | Springfield XDM Elite Compact | Glock 19 |
| Type | Striker-fired semi-automatic | Striker-fired semi-automatic |
| Caliber | 10mm | 9x19mm |
| Capacity | 14+1 rounds | Standard: 15 |
| Barrel Length | 3.8 inches | 4.02 inches |
| Overall Length/Height/Width | 6.9/4.6/1.2 inches | Length: 7.36 inches, Height: 5.04 inches, Width: 1.26 inches |
| Weight (Empty) | 27.4 oz. | 23.63 oz |
| Construction | Melonite-finished carbon-steel slide, polymer frame | Polymer frame |
| Sights | Red fiber-optic front, white outline U-notch rear | Standard Glock sights |
| Trigger | META, pull of 4.75 lbs | Safe Action, pull of 28 N |
Overview: Springfield XDM Elite Compact
The Springfield XDM Elite Compact is a powerhouse in a small package, known for its advanced features and ergonomic design.
Specs
- Type: Striker-fired semi-automatic
- Caliber: 10mm
- Capacity: 14+1 rounds
- Barrel Length: 3.8 inches
- Overall Length/Height/Width: 6.9/4.6/1.2 inches
- Weight: 27.4 oz.
- Construction: Melonite-finished carbon-steel slide, polymer frame
- Sights: Red fiber-optic front, white outline U-notch rear
- Trigger: META, with a measured pull of 4.75 lbs.
Overview: Glock 19
The Glock 19 is a versatile and reliable firearm, favored by many for its simplicity and proven track record.
Specs
- Caliber: 9x19mm
- System: Safe Action®
- Mag. Capacity: Standard: 15
- Barrel Length: 4.02 inches
- Weight with empty magazine: 23.63 oz
- Trigger Pull: 28 N
Features Comaprison: Springfield XDM Elite Compact VS Glock 19
1. Trigger Quality
Springfield XDM Elite Compact
The Springfield XDM Elite Compact’s META trigger is a standout feature. A 4.75 lbs pull strikes an exceptional balance between responsiveness and control.
This trigger transforms the shooting experience, offering precision that enhances both rapid and deliberate firing.
Its smooth, crisp break and well-calibrated resistance make it a joy to use, especially in scenarios where accuracy and quick response are key. It significantly outperforms many in its class, making shooting not just effective but also a genuinely enjoyable experience.
Glock 19
The Glock 19, with its Safe Action trigger system, delivers a consistent and reliable performance. The trigger pull of 28 N feels slightly heavier and less refined, especially when compared to the Springfield’s polished experience.
While it ensures dependable firing and has a proven track record, it lacks the finesse that enhances shooting precision and enjoyment.
Its functionality is solid but doesn’t offer the same level of satisfaction or crispness, which can be particularly noticeable in situations requiring quick and precise shooting.
Winner
The Springfield XDM Elite Compact clearly excels over the Glock 19 in trigger quality. Its META trigger provides a superior shooting experience characterized by smoothness, precision, and an ideal balance in pull weight.
This excellence in trigger quality adds a significant edge in both recreational and tactical shooting scenarios.
2. Ergonomics and Handling
Springfield XDM Elite Compact
The ergonomics of the Springfield XDM Elite Compact are superb. It features a comfortable and secure grip thanks to its polymer frame and melonite-finished carbon steel slide.
The slightly top-heavy design, rather than being a drawback, surprisingly aids in recoil management, enhancing stability during rapid firing.
This ergonomic advantage is evident during extended shooting sessions, where the Springfield’s design ensures comfort and accuracy.
Glock 19
The Glock 19 boasts a solid ergonomic design with a thicker grip and straightforward handling. Its balanced weight distribution is notable, providing good control during shooting.
However, in comparison to the Springfield, it falls a bit short in terms of recoil management and overall comfort, especially for concealed carry due to its bulkier grip.
Winner
In terms of ergonomics and handling, the Springfield XDM Elite Compact outperforms the Glock 19. Its design contributes significantly to better recoil management and a more comfortable shooting experience, especially over prolonged periods.
The Springfield’s ergonomic superiority makes it a more user-friendly and efficient choice in this aspect.
3. Sights and Accuracy
Springfield XDM Elite Compact
The Springfield is equipped with high-quality sights, featuring a red fiber-optic front and a white outline U-notch rear. These sights are not only visually appealing but extremely functional, offering clear and rapid target acquisition.
They significantly enhance accuracy, particularly in fast-paced shooting scenarios. The clear sight picture they provide makes precision shooting more intuitive and effective, contributing to the shooter’s confidence and capability.
Glock 19
The Glock 19 comes with standard Glock sights, which are robust and functional. However, they don’t offer the same level of quick target alignment as the Springfield’s.
In testing, these sights were adequate but did not facilitate as rapid or as precise targeting as the Springfield’s.
They are reliable for general use but lack the enhanced visibility and quick sighting capabilities that can be crucial in more dynamic shooting environments.
Winner
Compared to the Glock 19, the Springfield XDM Elite Compact is the superior choice in sights and accuracy. Its fiber-optic front and U-notch rear sights provide a distinct advantage in target acquisition and overall shooting accuracy.
This makes the Springfield particularly well-suited for scenarios where speed and precision are essential.
4. Sights and Visibility
Springfield XDM Elite Compact
The Springfield XDM Elite Compact comes with a fixed red fiber-optic front sight and a white outline U-notch rear sight. These sights are exceptional for quick target acquisition and provide excellent visibility in different lighting conditions.
During my field tests, I found these sights to be highly effective for rapid aiming and precision shooting.
Glock 19
The Glock 19 features standard Glock sights, which are durable and reliable. However, they are not as advanced as those in Springfield.
In my testing, I found that while they are adequate for general use, they don’t offer the same level of quick and easy targeting as Springfield’s sights.
Winner
The Springfield XDM Elite Compact excels in this feature compared to the Glock 19. Its sight system offers superior visibility and faster target acquisition, making it more suitable for situations where quick reflexes are necessary.
Pros & Cons: Springfield XDM Elite Compact:
Pros
- Superior trigger quality.
- Better recoil management.
- Excellent sight system for quick target acquisition.
Cons
- Top-heavy, which might affect carrying comfort.
- Controversial grip safety feature.
Pros & Cons: Glock 19
Pros
- Proven reliability and durability.
- Widespread availability of aftermarket parts.
- Balanced weight distribution.
Cons
- Less advanced trigger compared to Springfield.
- Standard sights not as quick for targeting.
Similarities between Springfield XDM Elite Compact & Glock 19
- Both are striker-fired semi-automatic handguns.
- Each comes with standard accessory rail options.
- Both are highly regarded in the firearms community.
- Each offers a polymer frame construction.
Differences between Springfield XDM Elite Compact & Glock 19
- Springfield has a red fiber-optic front sight; Glock has standard Glock sights.
- Springfield features a META trigger; Glock has a Safe Action trigger system.
- Springfield is slightly top-heavy; Glock has a more balanced weight.
- Springfield’s overall size is marginally smaller than Glock’s.
- Springfield’s barrel length is 3.8 inches, while Glock’s is 4.02 inches.
- Springfield’s trigger pull is 4.75 lbs, compared to Glock’s 28 N trigger pull.
Final Verdict
After thoroughly testing and comparing the Springfield XDM Elite Compact and the Glock 19, I’ve reached a conclusive verdict. Both firearms have their unique strengths, and choosing a winner wasn’t easy.
However, the Springfield XDM Elite Compact slightly edges out as my top choice. This preference isn’t based on any single overwhelming feature, but rather on a combination of elements that, when put together, create a more satisfying and effective shooting experience.
The Springfield’s superior trigger quality, advanced ergonomic design, and better sight system collectively contribute to its winning position.
FAQ’s
Which Springfield is comparable to Glock 19?
The Springfield XD9 is comparable to the Glock 19, offering more concealability which can be crucial for concealed carry.
What gun is better than the Glock 19?
The M&P 2.0 Compact is often considered a strong Glock 19 alternative, with many shooters preferring its grip angle and natural point of aim.
Is the Springfield XDM Elite a good carry gun?
Yes, the Springfield XDM Elite is a terrific choice for a carry gun, offering reliability, enjoyable shooting experience, and competitive pricing.
Is the Glock 19 the best all-around handgun?
The Glock 19 is highly recommended as an all-around handgun, suitable for various purposes from CCW to home defense, and trusted by military and law enforcement agencies.
