Hey there, fellow shooting enthusiasts! I’m here to dive into a comparison: the SIG SP2022 Vs SIG P228.
Both guns have earned their stripes in the world of firearms, but which one takes the crown? As a professional shooter, I’ve had the chance to take both beauties out in the field, putting them through their paces.
| Specification | SIG SP2022 | SIG P228 |
| Capacity | 10+1 rounds | 15 rounds (standard magazine) |
| Caliber | 9mm Luger | 9mm |
| Weight | 29 oz. | 32.0 oz. (incl. magazine) |
| Length | 7.4 inches | 7.1 inches |
| Height | 5.7 inches | 5.4 inches |
| Barrel Length | 3.9 inches | 3.9 inches |
Overview: SIG SP2022
The SIG SP2022 is a modern yet classic pistol that blends reliability with innovation.
Specs
- Capacity: 10+1 rounds
- Type: Full-Size
- Caliber: 9mm Luger
- Weight: 29 oz.
- Length: 7.4 inches
- Height: 5.7 inches
- Barrel Length: 3.9 inches
Overview: SIG P228
The SIG P228 is a compact, powerful choice with a legacy of excellence.
Specs
- Capacity: 15 rounds (standard magazine)
- Type: Compact
- Caliber: 9mm
- Weight: 32.0 oz. (including magazine)
- Length: 7.1 inches
- Height: 5.4 inches
- Width: 1.5 inches
- Barrel Length: 3.9 inches
- Trigger Pull: Double action 10 lbs., Single action 4.4 lbs.
Features Comparison: SIG SP2022 Vs SIG P228
1. Weight and Handling
SIG SP2022
The SP2022, with its 29 oz. weight offers a significant advantage in terms of handling and maneuverability. The full-size frame and a well-balanced polymer construction make it notably easy to handle, even during prolonged shooting sessions.
In field tests, the SP2022 demonstrated excellent stability, with its lighter weight aiding in faster target acquisition and more fluid movement between targets.
The polymer frame reduces the overall weight and contributes to a more comfortable and fatigue-free shooting experience, especially in scenarios requiring agility and rapid response.
SIG P228
The P228, weighing in at 32 oz., brings the heft of its all-metal construction to the fore. This weight, while adding to the overall mass of the firearm, contributes positively to its stability and recoil management.
In field tests, the P228’s solid feel and weight distribution proved beneficial in absorbing recoil, allowing for more controlled and precise follow-up shots.
This extra weight, though potentially tiring during extended use, provides a sense of reliability and sturdiness that is often preferred in traditional shooting experiences, lending itself well to scenarios where steady, deliberate firing is more critical than rapid movement.
Winner
When compared, the SP2022’s lighter frame makes it more suitable for situations requiring quick handling and longer shooting durations.
However, for those who value a more solid and controlled shooting experience, especially in managing recoil during rapid firing sequences, the P228’s extra weight and solid construction make it the preferable choice.
Thus, the P228 is the winner in this category for its stability and robustness.
2. Trigger Mechanism
SIG SP2022
The trigger system of the SP2022 is noteworthy for its smooth double action and distinctly crisp single action. During extensive testing, it was observed that the transition between double and single action was seamless, contributing to an overall satisfactory shooting experience.
The trigger reset on the SP2022 is particularly commendable; short and tactile, it facilitates quick and accurate follow-up shots, enhancing the shooter’s ability to engage multiple targets efficiently.
While the trigger mechanism is quite effective, it lacks a certain level of refinement and smoothness found in higher-end SIG models, which might be noticeable to more experienced shooters.
SIG P228
The P228’s trigger mechanism stands out for its superior craftsmanship. The double action is heavier, offering a deliberate and secure feel, while the single action is notably lighter and extremely crisp.
This clear differentiation between the two modes adds to the precision and control of the shooting experience. Field tests emphasized the predictability and consistency of the trigger pull, particularly in a single action, allowing for exceptional accuracy and control over shot placement.
The refined nature of the trigger in the P228 enhances the overall shooting experience, making it a desirable feature for those who prioritize precision and a classic SIG feel.
Winner
In comparing the two, the P228’s trigger mechanism surpasses the SP2022. The P228 offers a more refined and distinct trigger experience, with its heavier double action and lighter, crisper single action providing a level of precision and control that is highly valued by experienced shooters.
The SP2022, while efficient, does not match the level of finesse and responsiveness found in the P228’s trigger system.
3. Ergonomics and Customization
SIG SP2022
The ergonomic design of the SP2022 is one of its most notable features, particularly enhanced by the inclusion of interchangeable backstraps.
This adaptability allows for a highly personalized grip, catering to various hand sizes and preferences. During testing, the ability to adjust the grip size significantly improved the shooting experience, providing a comfortable and secure hold that directly influenced control and accuracy.
The ergonomic design extends beyond the grip, with the overall contours and balance of the firearm contributing to a natural and intuitive feel in hand.
This focus on ergonomics not only enhances comfort but also improves overall shooting performance, particularly in dynamic shooting scenarios where adaptability and quick handling are essential.
SIG P228
The P228, while not offering the same level of customization as the SP2022, has a grip design that is universally comfortable and ergonomically sound. The lack of interchangeable backstraps is compensated by a grip that naturally fits a wide range of hand sizes.
In field testing, the grip of the P228 was found to be both comfortable and secure, with the checkered texture providing a firm and steady hold.
Although it does not allow for the same level of personal customization as the SP2022, the P228’s grip design is well-thought-out, offering a satisfactory balance between comfort and control. The grip’s design, in combination with the firearm’s overall ergonomics, contributes to a shooting experience that is both enjoyable and effective.
Winner
When it comes to ergonomics and the ability to customize the grip, the SP2022 stands out. Its interchangeable backstraps offer a level of personalization that the P228 cannot match, making it a more versatile choice for shooters with varying hand sizes and grip preferences.
For those who prioritize a tailored grip and ergonomic adaptability, the SP2022 is the clear winner in this category.
4. Sight System
SIG SP2022
The SP2022 sports standard 3-dot sights are common in modern handguns. During testing, I found these sights straightforward and user-friendly.
They provide a clear sight picture, aiding in rapid target acquisition. For a shooter new to SIGs or someone looking for simplicity, these sights are intuitive and effective.
SIG P228
The P228, especially the older models, comes with the stacked dot sight system. It’s unique, where you align two dots vertically.
This took some getting used to during testing, but once I got the hang of it, it offered precise aiming. It’s a bit unconventional compared to modern standards but has its charm.
Winner
Compared to the P228, the SP2022 wins in this category. Its 3-dot sight system is more in line with contemporary shooting practices, making it easier for most shooters to adapt to and use effectively.
Pros & Cons of Sig SP2022
Pros
- Lightweight polymer frame.
- Interchangeable backstraps for a custom grip.
- Standard 3-dot sighting system.
- Comfortable ergonomics.
Cons
- Trigger feel not as refined as P228.
Pros & Cons of SIG P228
Pros
- Solid all-metal construction.
- Crisp and refined trigger mechanism.
- Classic SIG design and feel.
- Reliable performance with a long track record.
Cons
- Heavier than the SP2022.
Similarities Between SIG SP2022 & SIG P228
- Both chambered in 9mm Luger.
- Similar barrel length (3.9 inches).
- Renowned for reliability and durability.
- Both feature a decocker.
- Known for excellent accuracy.
Differences Between SIG SP2022 & SIG P228
- SP2022 has a polymer frame; P228 has an all-metal frame.
- SP2022 has interchangeable backstraps; P228 does not.
- P228 is slightly heavier than the SP2022.
- SP2022 utilizes a standard 3-dot sight; P228 has stacked dot sights.
- SP2022 generally more affordable than P228.
Final Verdict
After thorough testing and evaluation of both the SIG SP2022 and the SIG P228, I’ve reached a conclusion that may surprise some. While both firearms exhibit exceptional qualities, for me, the winner is the SIG P228.
This choice stems from its blend of classic design, superior trigger mechanism, and robust construction. The P228 offers a shooting experience that’s both gratifying and precise, making it a standout in scenarios where control and accuracy are paramount.
Despite its heavier weight, the P228’s all-metal build and ergonomic design provide a reassuring and solid feel in hand, which I find invaluable, especially in high-stress situations.
FAQ’s
What is the difference between SIG 229 and 228?
The main difference lies in their construction. The P228 features a folded, stamped, and spot-welded slide with a steel breech block insert, while the P229 has a conventional machined solid slide.
Is the SIG SP2022 reliable?
Yes, the SIG SP2022 is known for its reliability, lightweight design, ease of carry, and consistent performance, making it a great option for those seeking a DA/SA platform.
Is Sig Sauer SP2022 a full size?
Yes, the SIG Sauer SP2022 is a full-size polymer pistol, combining the durability and reliability expected from SIG with the advantages of a polymer frame.
Is Sig P228 a good carry gun?
Yes, the Sig P228 is highly regarded for concealed carry and self-defense due to its compact size, high-quality construction, and accuracy, making it popular among law enforcement and military personnel.
