I’ve had the unique opportunity to test two of the most talked-about guns in the competitive shooting world: the SIG P320 X5 Legion Vs CZ Shadow 2.
In this article, I’ll share my firsthand experience with both firearms, delving into their specs, performance, and how they stack up against each other.
| Specification | SIG P320 X-5 Legion | CZ Shadow 2 |
| Caliber | 9mm Luger | 9×19 (9mm Luger) |
| Magazine Capacity | 17 rounds | 19/10 rounds |
| Length | 8.46 inches | 8.54 inches |
| Width | 1.38 inches | 1.34 inches |
| Height | 5.91 inches | 6.18 inches |
| Barrel Length | 5 inches | 4.72 inches |
| Weight (Empty Mag) | 43.5 ounces | 46.91 ounces |
SIG P320 X-5 Legion
The SIG P320 X-5 Legion is a powerhouse in the competitive shooting world, known for its innovative design and superior performance.
Specs
- Caliber: 9mm Luger
- Magazine Capacity: 17 rounds
- Length: 8.46 inches
- Width: 1.38 inches
- Height: 5.91 inches
- Slide Material: Steel
- Safety Mechanism: Trigger-controlled firing pin safety
- Action Type: Single Action (SA)
- Total Weight (incl. Magazine): 43.5 ounces
CZ Shadow 2
Enter the CZ Shadow 2, a remarkable firearm that blends precision engineering with exceptional handling, making it a favorite among competitive shooters.
Specs
- Caliber: 9×19 (9mm Luger)
- Magazine Capacity: 19/10 rounds
- Length: 8.54 inches
- Width: 1.34 inches
- Height: 6.18 inches
- Barrel Length: 4.72 inches
- Weight (with empty magazine): 46.91 ounces
- Sights: Fiber optic front sight | Checkered rear sight
- Trigger Mechanism: SA/DA (Single Action/Double Action)
Features Comparison Sig P320 X-5 Legion VS CZ Shadow 2
1. Ergonomics
SIG P320 X-5 Legion
The SIG P320 X-5 Legion boasts a unique blend of a polymer frame with tungsten infusion, providing a balanced weight that’s slightly lighter than the Shadow 2.
However, the ergonomics might not be perfect for all shooters.
The grip’s fat section towards the back can be awkward for some hand sizes, and the lack of interchangeable backstraps limits its adaptability to different shooters.
CZ Shadow 2
The CZ Shadow 2, with its steel frame, classic CZ-75 ergonomics, and heavily textured grips, provides a comfortable and stable handling experience.
It’s slightly heavier, which aids in recoil management. The design allows for a snug, high grip, reducing slide bite risk.
Additionally, while it lacks interchangeable backstraps, the ability to change grip panels offers some customization for different hand sizes, enhancing its ergonomic versatility compared to the SIG.
Winner
In terms of ergonomics, the CZ Shadow 2 takes the lead. Its classic design, combined with the ability to change grip panels, makes it more versatile and comfortable for a broader range of shooters compared to the SIG.
The heavier frame of the Shadow 2 also contributes to better recoil management, making it more pleasant to shoot over extended periods. The SIG’s ergonomics, while solid, fall slightly short due to its less adaptable grip design and awkward back section.
2. Trigger Mechanism
SIG P320 X-5 Legion
The trigger of the SIG P320 X-5 Legion is where it notably lags. The stock trigger feels long, smooshy, and has a lengthy reset, leading to a less than ideal shooting experience.
Many shooters find themselves short-stroking it. While the trigger weight is acceptable, the overall feel and function are not on par with what one would expect from a competition-ready firearm. Most shooters would find it necessary to upgrade the trigger for serious competitive shooting.
CZ Shadow 2
The CZ Shadow 2 shines in the trigger department. Out of the box, it offers a smoother, more refined trigger experience compared to the SIG.
The double action is lighter than standard CZ models, and the single action pull is crisp with a short reset. This leads to a more intuitive shooting experience, allowing for quicker follow-up shots and better control.
The trigger’s performance is significantly superior, enhancing the overall shooting experience.
Winner
When comparing triggers, the CZ Shadow 2 undoubtedly comes out on top. Its factory trigger is exceptionally smooth and
3. Optics Compatibility
SIG P320 X-5 Legion
The SIG P320 X-5 Legion is designed with a direct mount system for the Delta Point Pro bases, including the Romeo 1 Pro.
This system simplifies the mounting of compatible optics but limits versatility. Aftermarket plate conversion systems are available, allowing the use of different optic types.
However, adding these plates can slightly affect the sight picture and overall height of the optic, altering the shooting experience compared to a native mount.
CZ Shadow 2
The CZ Shadow 2 offers an optics-ready platform but requires an adapter plate to mount most optics, which is not included.
This design is compatible with the CZ P10 series plates, increasing versatility for shooters who might already own compatible accessories.
The need for an adapter can be a minor inconvenience but allows for a wider range of optics choices. However, the removal of the rear sight when installing optics can be a drawback for some shooters.
Winner
In terms of optics compatibility, the CZ Shadow 2 edges out slightly over the SIG P320 X-5 Legion.
Despite the need for an adapter plate, the Shadow 2 offers greater versatility with a wider range of compatible optics.
The SIG’s direct mount system is convenient but more limiting in options. The ability to use CZ P10 series plates on the Shadow 2 adds value for those already invested in the CZ ecosystem, making it a more adaptable choice for optics.
Pros & Cons of SIG P320 X-5 Legion
Pros
- Tungsten-infused polymer frame adds weight for stability.
- Direct mount system for Delta Point Pro optics.
- Comes with two recoil springs for ammunition flexibility.
- Semi-ambidextrous design.
Cons
- Stock trigger is not competition-ready; feels long and smooshy.
Pros & Cons of CZ Shadow 2
Pros
- Superior ergonomics with classic CZ-75 design.
- Exceptional stock trigger, smoother than SIG’s.
- Heavier steel frame aids in recoil management.
- Greater versatility in optics mounting with adapter plates.
Cons
- Adapter plate required for optics, not included.
- Rear sight removed when installing optics.
Similarities between SIG P320 X-5 Legion & CZ Shadow 2
- Both designed for competition shooting.
- Chambered in 9mm caliber.
- Offer optics-ready models.
- Aimed at a similar market segment, albeit at different price points.
- Both have a reputation for reliability and performance in competitive environments.
Differences between SIG P320 X-5 Legion & CZ Shadow 2
- SIG has a polymer frame with tungsten infusion, CZ has a steel frame.
- SIG uses a striker-fired action, CZ employs a hammer-fired action.
- SIG’s ergonomics are less adaptable compared to CZ’s customizable grip panels.
- SIG’s trigger requires upgrading for competition, CZ’s is excellent out of the box.
- SIG is semi-ambidextrous, CZ has limited ambidextrous features.
- SIG’s recoil is more pronounced, CZ’s is smoother due to heavier frame.
Final Verdict
After thoroughly testing both the SIG P320 X-5 Legion and the CZ Shadow 2, it’s time to conclude this deep dive.
While both firearms exhibit exceptional qualities and cater to the competitive shooting world, one has edged out as my preferred choice. In this rigorous comparison, the CZ Shadow 2 emerged as the winner in most aspects.
This choice is rooted not in the specific features or specifications, which both guns have in abundance, but in the overall shooting experience and adaptability to various shooting conditions.
FAQ’s
Why is the CZ Shadow 2 so good?
The CZ Shadow 2 excels due to its heavier weight and inside-the-frame slide design, both of which contribute to a stable, flat shooting experience.
Is CZ Shadow 2 a competition gun?
Yes, the CZ Shadow 2 is designed for competition, with features like aggressive checkering for grip, a longer barrel and slide, and a design that absorbs recoil effectively.
What category is CZ Shadow 2?
The CZ Shadow 2 is categorized as an all-steel, large-capacity SA/DA (Single Action/Double Action) pistol, highly regarded in dynamic sport shooting disciplines.
Is the SIG P320 X5 Legion Optics Ready?
Yes, the SIG P320 X5 Legion is optics-ready, featuring a Romeo1 PRO optic-ready slide, 5” bull barrel, and Dawson Precision® fiber optic adjustable sights, making it highly competitive.
