I’m here to dive into a detailed comparison between two heavy hitters in the 10mm auto world: the SIG P320 X-Ten Vs Springfield XD-M Elite.
As a professional shooter, I’ve had the unique opportunity to test these guns out in the field, giving me a firsthand experience of their capabilities.
This article aims to shed light on the key features, strengths, and potential drawbacks of each model. So, let’s get started and find out which one stands out as the winner in my book!
| Feature | SIG P320 X-Ten | Springfield XD-M Elite |
| Caliber | 10mm Auto | 10mm |
| Overall Length | 8.5 inches | 8.6 inches |
| Barrel Length | 5 inches | 5.28 inches (threaded .5×28) |
| Weight | 33 ounces (incl. magazine) | 30 ounces |
| Magazine Capacity | Three 15-round steel mags | 22+1 rounds |
| Trigger Type | X-Series Flat Trigger | Striker-fired |
Overview: SIG P320 X-Ten
The SIG P320 X-Ten is a robust and reliable choice for enthusiasts who demand precision and power.
Specs
- Caliber: 10mm Auto
- Overall Length: 8.5 inches
- Barrel Length: 5 inches
- Overall Width: 1.3 inches
- Weight: 33 ounces (including magazine)
- Magazines Included: Three 15-round steel mags
- Sights: XRAY3 day/night sights
- Trigger Type: X-Series Flat Trigger
- Frame Material: Stainless Steel (FCU)
Overview: Springfield XD-M Elite
The Springfield XD-M Elite stands as a formidable competitor, boasting advanced features for the modern shooter.
Specs
- Chambering: 10mm
- Barrel: 5.28 inches, threaded .5×28, Melonite finish
- Overall Length: 8.6 inches
- Weight: 30 ounces
- Sights: Suppressor height front and rear, optics ready
- Grips: Integral polymer
- Action: Striker-fired
- Capacity: 22+1 rounds
Features Comparison: SIG P320 X-Ten VS Springfield XD-M Elite
1. Ergonomics and Comfort
SIG P320 X-Ten
The SIG P320 X-Ten excels in ergonomics, offering a grip that feels almost tailor-made. The way it sits in the hand is incredibly natural, making it comfortable for long shooting sessions.
This comfort is enhanced by well-designed stippling, providing a secure grip even in challenging conditions.
The pistol’s balance is noteworthy, with a weight distribution that feels intuitive and contributes to an overall sense of control. This ergonomic design is particularly beneficial when precision and stability are paramount in field use.
Springfield XD-M Elite
The Springfield XD-M Elite, while competent in its ergonomic design, doesn’t quite reach the heights of the SIG. Its grip has a more plasticky feel, which might be less appealing to some shooters.
The stippling, though functional, lacks the finesse and effectiveness of the SIG, resulting in a grip that doesn’t feel as secure. The polymer used and the design of the grip safety, while functional, don’t provide the same confidence-inspiring feel as the SIG’s well-crafted handle.
Winner
When it comes to ergonomics and comfort, the SIG P320 X-Ten clearly outperforms the Springfield XD-M Elite. Its superior grip design and thoughtful ergonomics make it the more comfortable and secure choice.
2. Trigger Quality
SIG P320 X-Ten
The trigger system in the SIG P320 X-Ten is a standout feature. It offers a crisp, clean break that is both satisfying and precise, making it a delight for any shooter.
The consistency in the trigger pull is remarkable, providing a reliable and predictable shooting experience. This consistency aids significantly in maintaining accuracy, especially in scenarios requiring rapid firing.
The quality of the trigger contributes to the overall shooting experience, making each shot feel controlled and deliberate.
Springfield XD-M Elite
The Springfield XD-M Elite also boasts a commendable trigger. It delivers a smooth pull with a decent break, closely rivaling the quality of the SIG’s trigger.
However, it falls slightly short in achieving the same level of crispness and refinement. While it is more than adequate for most shooting situations, enthusiasts might notice the subtle differences in smoothness and consistency compared to the SIG.
Winner
The SIG P320 X-Ten takes the lead in trigger quality. Its exceptional crispness and consistent performance give it a slight edge over the Springfield XD-M Elite, making it the preferred choice for shooters who prioritize trigger feel and precision.
3. Shooting Experience
SIG P320 X-Ten
Firing the SIG P320 X-Ten is a thoroughly enjoyable experience. The gun demonstrates excellent stability and balance during shooting, contributing to its impressive performance. It operates smoothly, with no malfunctions noted during testing.
The well-designed ergonomics play a significant role in the shooting experience, as the gun feels stable and well-balanced in hand. This stability is crucial for achieving consistent accuracy, especially under rapid fire conditions.
Springfield XD-M Elite
The Springfield XD-M Elite offers a shooting experience that, somewhat unexpectedly, surpasses that of the SIG in certain aspects.
Its ease of operation, notably in racking and magazine seating, makes it a more user-friendly option. Despite its ergonomic shortcomings, the gun handles well and provides a satisfying shooting experience. Its smooth operation and reliability during firing, even in fast-paced scenarios, are commendable.
Winner
In a surprising turn, the Springfield XD-M Elite edges out as the winner in the shooting experience category. Its user-friendly operation and reliable performance, especially in the ease of racking and magazine management, make it a slightly more preferable option for a seamless shooting experience compared to the SIG P320 X-Ten.
4. Durability and Reliability
SIG P320 X-Ten
The SIG P320 X-Ten’s durability is a bit of an unknown, as it hasn’t been extensively torture tested yet. However, its build quality and materials suggest a robust design.
The stainless steel frame adds to its sturdiness, and initial impressions indicate that it could hold up well under extensive use.
Springfield XD-M Elite
In contrast, the Springfield XD-M Elite’s durability is well-proven. It’s been through extensive testing, including tens of thousands of rounds, indicating a high level of reliability and toughness. Its track record, especially in harsh conditions, gives it an edge in this aspect.
Winner
Based on available data, the Springfield XD-M Elite comes out ahead in durability and reliability. Its proven track record provides a level of assurance that the SIG P320 X-Ten hasn’t matched yet.
Pros & Cons: SIG P320 X-Ten
Pros
- Excellent ergonomics and comfortable grip.
- Crisp and consistent trigger.
- High-quality build with a stainless steel frame.
Cons
- Some issues with magazine seating.
Pros & Cons: Springfield XD-M Elite
Pros
- Proven durability and reliability.
- Better overall shooting experience.
- Easier magazine seating and operation.
Cons
- Ergonomics and grip comfort not as good as the SIG.
Similarities Between SIG P320 X-Ten & Springfield XD-M Elite
- Both chambered in 10mm.
- Similar barrel lengths.
- High-quality sight systems.
- Modern, striker-fired action.
- Both have integral polymer grips.
- Designed for high-capacity magazines.
Differences Between SIG P320 X-Ten & Springfield XD-M Elite
- SIG has X-Series Flat Trigger, Springfield has a different trigger feel.
- SIG’s overall width is 1.3 inches, Springfield’s width varies slightly.
- SIG weighs 33 ounces, Springfield is lighter at 30 ounces.
- SIG’s frame is stainless steel, Springfield uses a different material.
- Springfield has a Melonite finish, SIG’s finish differs.
- Springfield’s grip safety design differs from SIG’s.
- Springfield proven in durability tests, SIG’s testing less extensive.
- Springfield has suppressor-height sights, SIG uses XRAY3 sights.
Final Verdict
After an extensive field test and comparison of the SIG P320 X-Ten and the Springfield XD-M Elite, it’s time to conclude which of these 10mm powerhouses reigns supreme.
While both guns have their merits, one has edged out slightly ahead in my evaluation. In most of the comparisons, from ergonomics to trigger quality and shooting experience, there was a tight race. However, considering all factors, my best choice is the Springfield XD-M Elite.
The Springfield XD-M Elite stood out for its exceptional shooting experience, ease of operation, and proven durability.
FAQ’s
What is the difference between a Springfield XD-M and XD-M Elite?
The primary difference is the barrel length. The frames of both guns are identical and interchangeable, with the Elite models varying mainly in barrel length.
Is the Springfield XDM Elite Compact a good gun?
Yes, the Springfield XD-M Elite Compact is a great compact, optics-ready CCW pistol, offering big-bore options in .45 ACP, 9mm, and 10mm.
Is XDM Elite good for concealed carry?
Absolutely, the XD-M Elite, especially the 3.8″ Compact model, is well-suited for concealed carry, offering a 14+1 capacity in 9mm, a short frame, and performance enhancements.
Where are Springfield XDM Elite made?
The Springfield XD-M Elite, part of the XD series, is manufactured by HS Produkt in Karlovac, Croatia.
