I’ve been out in the field putting two impressive guns through their paces: the Sig P320 Vs Springfield Echelon.
Being a professional shooter, I get to test a lot of firearms, but these two have caused quite a stir in the shooting community. The big question is: which one comes out on top? Well, I’ve taken both for a spin and let’s just say the results were pretty interesting.
| Specification | SIG P320 | Springfield Echelon |
| Caliber | 9mm | 9mm |
| Action Type | Striker Fired DAO | Recoil operated, striker fired, semiautomatic |
| Trigger Pull DA | 5.5 – 7.5 lbs | Approx. 4.5 – 5 lbs |
| Overall Length | 7.2 in | 8 in |
| Overall Height | 5.3 in | 5.5 in |
| Overall Width | 1.4 in | 1.2 in |
| Barrel Length | 3.9 in | 4.5 in |
| Magazine Capacity | 15 Rounds | 10+1, 17+1, or 20+1 rounds |
| Sights | SIGLITE Night Sights | Tritium/luminescent (front), Tactical Rack U-Dot (rear), optic ready |
Overview: Sig P320
The SIG P320, a striker-fired wonder, has been a solid choice for shooters for years, known for its reliability and adaptability.
Specs
- Caliber: 9mm
- Action Type: Striker Fired DAO
- Trigger Pull D5.5 – 7.5 lbs
- Overall Length: 7.2 in
- Overall Height: 5.3 in
- Overall Width: 1.4 in
- Barrel Length: 3.9 in
- Sight Radius: 5.8 in
- Weight with Magazine: 26.0 oz
- Magazine Capacity: 15 Rounds
- Sights: SIGLITE Night Sights
- Grips: Interchangeable Polymer
- Frame Finish: Black Polymer
- Slide Finish: Nitron
Overview: Springfield Echelon
The Springfield Armory Echelon is a newcomer quickly turning heads with its innovative design and features.
Specs
- Type: Recoil operated, striker-fired, semiautomatic
- Cartridge: 9mm
- Capacity: 10+1, 17+1, or 20+1 rds.
- Barrel: 4.5 in., hammer forged, 1:10-in. twist; 5.28 in., threaded (optional)
- Overall Length: 8 in.
- Width: 1.2 in.
- Height: 5.5 in.
- Finish: Melonite (steel)
- Trigger: 4 lbs., 15 oz. (tested)
Features Comparison: SIG P320 VS Springfield Echelon
1. Controls
SIG P320
The SIG P320 brings to the table a user-friendly experience with its controls. The ambidextrous slide stop is thoughtful, accommodating both right and left-handed users.
However, the magazine release is only reversible, not ambidextrous. In my hands-on testing, I found that the slide stop was a bit of a mixed bag. My thumbs tended to rest on it, often preventing it from locking back on an empty mag.
Springfield Echelon
The Springfield Echelon steps it up with fully ambidextrous controls for the slide lock and magazine release. In the field, this made a noticeable difference.
The ambi magazine release was particularly smooth, a relief compared to the stiffer options I’ve experienced on other pistols. This feature came in handy during rapid magazine changes, offering a seamless transition without any fumbling.
Winner
Compared to the SIG P320, the Springfield Echelon takes the crown in the controls department. The fully ambidextrous design not only provides more versatility but also shows a thoughtful consideration for all shooters.
Plus, the smoother operation of the magazine release gives it an edge in high-stress or rapid shooting scenarios.
2. Trigger Mechanism
SIG P320
The SIG P320 offers both curved and straight trigger designs, but it lacks a trigger safety. From my experience at the range, the trigger pull was consistent, and the lack of a trigger safety wasn’t a significant drawback.
The Custom Works trigger on my SIG P320 FCU was a standout, offering a crisp and clean break.
Springfield Echelon
The Springfield Echelon comes with a flat-faced trigger design, incorporating a trigger safety, which I appreciate for an added layer of security.
During testing, the trigger performed exceptionally well, with a clean break and reset. The stock trigger on the Echelon felt as good as the custom trigger on my SIG.
Winner
In this case, compared to the SIG P320, the Springfield Echelon edges out as the winner. The added trigger safety and the overall quality of the trigger mechanism provide a more secure and enjoyable shooting experience.
3. Optics Ready
SIG P320
The SIG P320 models are largely optics-ready. Older models use a Leupold DPP footprint, while newer versions utilize the SIG PRO footprint, compatible with a range of optics like the SIG ROMEO1PRO and ROMEO2, along with RMR footprints using a sealing plate.
In my field tests, swapping optics was straightforward, though the requirement for different plates for different optics was a bit limiting.
Springfield Echelon
The Echelon introduces an innovative VIS system, making it compatible with a wide array of optics without needing additional plates.
The removal of the cover plate reveals multiple mounting holes, accommodating various optics brands. In practice, this system was a game-changer, offering unparalleled versatility and ease of switching optics.
Winner
Compared to the SIG P320, the Springfield Echelon stands out as the clear winner in the optics-ready feature. Its versatile and user-friendly VIS system offers greater compatibility and ease of use, making it a more adaptable choice for shooters who frequently switch optics.
4. Grip Design and Texture
SIG P320
The SIG P320 offers a variety of grip textures and designs, catering to different preferences. You have the X Series, the AXG, and the Legion designs, each offering a unique feel.
In my hands-on experience, these grip options provided a decent level of control and comfort. Especially the AXG metal grip stood out, offering a premium feel.
Springfield Echelon
The Echelon uses the adaptive grip texture found on the Hellcat, which I found to be quite effective. It’s a nice balance between aggressiveness and comfort.
During my range tests, especially in sweaty conditions, this grip texture provided a better hold, reducing the need for frequent readjustments.
Winner
Compared to the SIG P320, the Springfield Echelon wins in the grip design and texture category. The adaptive texture on the Echelon offers a superior grip, particularly in challenging conditions, and the overall ergonomics feel more natural in hand.
Pros & Cons: Sig P320
Pros
- Wide variety of models and customizations.
- Proven reliability and durability.
- Comfortable ergonomics and grip options.
Cons
- Magazine release is not ambidextrous.
Pros & Cons: Springfield Echelon
Pros
- Innovative VIS system for optic mounting.
- Ambidextrous controls enhance usability.
- Adaptive grip texture provides excellent hold.
Cons
- Slightly heavier than the SIG P320.
Similarities Between SIG P320 Vs Springfield Echelon
- Both are 9mm, striker-fired, semi-automatic pistols.
- Each features a modular design with removable chassis systems.
- Double stack magazine configurations.
- Polymer frame construction.
- Optics-ready models available in both lines.
Differences Between SIG P320 Vs Springfield Echelon
- SIG P320 has more model variety and aftermarket support.
- Echelon’s ambidextrous controls vs. P320’s reversible magazine release.
- Echelon uses a flat-faced trigger with a safety; P320 offers curved and straight triggers without a safety.
- P320 offers various grip textures; Echelon uses adaptive grip texture.
- Echelon’s VIS system for optics is more versatile compared to P320’s two footprint options.
Final Verdict
After thoroughly testing and comparing the SIG P320 and the Springfield Echelon, I’ve reached a conclusion. Both guns are impressive in their own rights, offering unique features that cater to different preferences.
However, in most of my comparisons, the Springfield Echelon emerged as the winner. Its innovative design, particularly in terms of control and optics readiness, set it apart. The added security of ambidextrous controls and the versatile VIS system for optics really stood out during testing.
FAQ’s
Is the Springfield Echelon good?
Yes, the Springfield Echelon is a high-quality firearm with a clean trigger takeup, crisp wall, and short, well-defined reset.
What problems did the P320 have?
The P320 faced issues with accidental discharges, including instances of shooting oneself while holstering, raising concerns about its safety.
What is the trigger pull weight for the Springfield Echelon?
The trigger pull weight for the Springfield Echelon is approximately 5.0 pounds, offering a crisp feel with a short reset.
How does the SIG P320 safety work?
The SIG P320 has two internal safeties; one catches the striker in case of malfunction, and the other prevents discharge when the slide is drawn backward.
