Hey there, fellow shooting enthusiasts! I’ve had the unique opportunity to test out two of the most talked-about guns in the field: the SIG M11 A1 Vs Glock 19.
These pistols are not just tools for me; they’re like constant companions, each with their own story and character.
I’m diving into a head-to-head comparison in this article to determine which one comes out on top. But remember, it’s not just about specs and numbers; it’s about how these guns feel in the hand, perform in various conditions, and meet the needs of a shooter like me.
| Specification | SIG M11 A1 | Glock 19 |
| Caliber | 9mm | 9x19mm |
| Action | Single/Double | Safe Action® |
| Weight | 32 oz. | 21.16 oz. (without magazine) |
| Barrel Length | 3.9 inches | 4.02 inches |
| Overall Length | 7.1 inches | 7.36 inches |
| Magazine Capacity | 15+ | 15 (Standard); Options up to 33 |
| Trigger Pull | 4½ lbs (SA); ~11 lbs (DA) | 5.5 lbs (standard connector) |
Overview of SIG M11 A1
The SIG M11 A1 is a robust and reliable choice known for its precision and durability. It’s a classic blend of military-grade toughness and modern shooting comfort.
Specs
- Caliber: 9mm
- Action: Single/Double
- Weight: 32 oz.
- Barrel Length: 3.9 inches
- Overall Length: 7.1 inches
- Magazine Capacity: 15+
- Frame: Hard-coat anodized aluminum
Overview of Glock 19
The Glock 19 is a staple in compact firearms, renowned for its simplicity, efficiency, and unwavering performance under pressure.
Specs
- Caliber: 9x19mm
- Action: Safe Action®
- Weight (without magazine): 21.16 oz.
- Barrel Length: 4.02 inches
- Overall Length: 7.36 inches
- Magazine Capacity: Standard: 15 (Optional: 17 / 19 / 24 / 31 / 33 / 10)
- Width (Overall): 1.26 inches
Features Comparison: SIG M11 A1 VS Glock 19
1. Trigger Mechanism
SIG M11 A1
The SIG M11 A1 presents a fascinating double/single action trigger mechanism. Initially, the trigger pull is relatively heavy and lengthy, around 10 pounds, demanding more deliberate effort for the first shot.
This hefty pull transitions smoothly to a lighter, 4.5-pound single-action pull for subsequent shots. This mechanism offers a unique shooting experience, where quicker, lighter subsequent shots follow the initial deliberate pull.
It’s particularly advantageous in scenarios requiring careful shot placement.
Glock 19
The Glock 19, with its striker-fired system, provides a consistently smooth and predictable 5.5-pound trigger pull.
The uniformity of the trigger pull means that shooters can expect the same response each time they squeeze the trigger, reducing the need for adjustment between shots and allowing for more instinctive, reflexive shooting.
Winner
The Glock 19 stands out for its consistent trigger pull. For shooters who prioritize a uniform shooting experience and rapid shot delivery under stress, the Glock 19’s trigger offers an undeniable advantage.
The lack of variability between pulls makes it ideal for those who may not have the time or inclination to adapt to the SIG M11 A1’s more nuanced trigger system.
2. Size and Handling
SIG M11 A1
The SIG M11 A1 is slightly more compact, measuring 7.1 inches in overall length, which could be a crucial factor in concealed carry scenarios.
However, this compactness comes with a trade-off in weight and thickness. Weighing 32 oz, it is notably heavier, and its bulkier frame might not be as comfortable for all shooters, especially over prolonged periods or for those with smaller hands.
Glock 19
The Glock 19, with a length of 7.36 inches, is slightly longer than the SIG M11 A1. However, its slimmer width of 1.26 inches and lighter weight (21.16 oz without magazine) contribute to a more comfortable and manageable handling experience.
This ergonomic advantage becomes more apparent during extended use, with the reduced weight and slimmer profile aiding in maneuverability and ease of concealment.
Winner
The Glock 19 takes the upper hand in terms of size and handling. Its slimmer and lighter design accommodates a wider range of users and scenarios, especially for those needing quick handling and ease of carry.
The Glock’s design caters to both comfort and practicality, making it the preferred choice.
3. Durability and Finish
SIG M11 A1
The durability of the SIG M11 A1 is impressive, thanks to its hard-coat anodized aluminum frame. This robust construction makes it resistant to wear and tear and capable of enduring tough conditions without compromising on performance.
The ruggedness of the SIG M11 A1 is a testament to its reliability, especially in scenarios that demand a tough, enduring firearm.
Glock 19
The Glock 19, coated with a nib-X finish, is notable for its corrosion resistance and durability. This innovative finish not only protects the Glock from harsh elements but also adds self-lubricating properties, enhancing the longevity and reliability of the firearm.
The finish ensures the Glock remains dependable and functional, even in adverse conditions.
Winner
When assessing durability and finish, the SIG M11 A1 has a slight edge over the Glock 19. Its hard-coat anodized frame provides exceptional resilience and longevity, making it slightly more suited for enduring harsher environments and more rugged use.
The robust construction of the SIG M11 A1 edges it ahead in this category, although the Glock 19’s finish is also highly commendable.
4. Ergonomics and Comfort
SIG M11 A1
The SIG M11 A1, with its hard-coat anodized aluminum frame, provides a solid and durable grip. Its design is a bit bulkier, which might suit shooters with larger hands.
The double/single action requires a learning curve but offers versatility. Its weight and balance, while heavier, give a sense of sturdiness and control during shooting.
Glock 19
The Glock 19, renowned for its ergonomic design, is built for comfort and ease of use. Its slimmer profile and lighter weight make it more manageable, especially for extended periods or for shooters with smaller hands. The consistent trigger pull and smooth contours of the frame make it a joy to handle and shoot.
Winner
In terms of ergonomics and comfort, the Glock 19 excels compared to the SIG M11 A1. Its lighter, more streamlined design and consistent trigger pull make it more user-friendly, especially for those who value comfort and ease of handling.
Pros & Cons of SIG M11 A1
Pros
- Durable anodized aluminum frame
- Versatile double/single action trigger
- Compact design suitable for concealed carry
- Higher weight adds stability
Cons
- Bulkier design may not suit all hands
Pros & Cons of Glock 19
Pros
- Lightweight and slim profile
- Consistent trigger pull
- Ergonomic design
- Good for a wide range of hand sizes
Cons
- Striker-fired system may not suit all preferences
Similarities Between SIG M11 A1 & Glock 19
- Both are 9mm caliber
- Standard magazine capacity of 15 rounds
- Popular choices for concealed carry
- Renowned for reliability and durability
- Used extensively by law enforcement and military
- Both have options for night sights
Differences Between SIG M11 A1 & Glock 19
- SIG M11 A1 has a double/single action trigger; Glock 19 is striker-fired
- SIG M11 A1 is heavier at 32 oz.; Glock 19 lighter at 21.16 oz.
- SIG M11 A1 has a barrel length of 3.9 inches; Glock 19’s barrel is 4.02 inches
- SIG M11 A1 is slightly shorter in length at 7.1 inches; Glock 19 is 7.36 inches
- SIG M11 A1 has a thicker and bulkier frame
- Glock 19 has a more consistent trigger pull
- Different ergonomics: SIG M11 A1 suits larger hands, Glock 19 is more universal
- Price difference, with SIG M11 A1 generally being more expensive
Final Verdict
After thoroughly testing both the SIG M11 A1 and the Glock 19, it’s time to draw a conclusion. As a shooter who has spent considerable time with both firearms, I’ve come to appreciate their unique qualities.
However, when it comes down to choosing a winner, the Glock 19 has emerged as my top pick. This choice isn’t based on specs alone but on the overall experience and adaptability it offers.
The Glock 19’s blend of consistent performance, user-friendly design, and versatility makes it stand out. It caters to a wide range of scenarios, from professional use to personal defense, without compromising on reliability or comfort.
FAQ’s
How heavy is a Glock 19 trigger?
The Glock 19 typically has a 5.5 lbs trigger pull, but it can vary with different connectors and trigger springs.
How much does a SIG M11 A1 trigger pull weight?
The SIG M11 A1 has a trigger pull of approximately 4½ pounds in single action and around 11 pounds in double-action mode.
Does a SIG M11 A1 have a safety?
The SIG M11 A1 features a built-in firing pin safety but does not have manual safeties.
What is the barrel length of the SIG M11 A1?
The barrel length of the SIG M11 A1 is 3.90 inches.
