I’m taking you on a journey through my experience with two of Glock’s popular models: the Glock 44 Vs Glock 17.
You know, it’s not every day you get to compare two guns that have such a reputation in the shooting world. So, I rolled up my sleeves and took these beauties to the field. Here’s the scoop on how they stack up against each other.
| Feature | Glock 44 | Glock 17 |
| Caliber | .22 LR | 9x19mm |
| Magazine Capacity | Standard: 10 rounds | Standard: 17 rounds |
| Barrel Length | 4.02 inches | 4.49 inches |
| Weight (Empty Mag) | 14.64 oz | 24.87 oz |
| Trigger Pull | 26 N | 28 N |
| Overall Length | 7.28 inches | 8.03 inches |
| Slide Length | 6.85 inches | 7.32 inches |
| Height with Mag | 5.04 inches | 5.47 inches |
Overview Glock 44
The Glock 44, a .22 LR caliber marvel, is all about combining the classic Glock reliability with the affordability and low recoil of the .22 round. It’s the go-to for consistent practice without breaking the bank.
Specs
- Caliber: 22 LR
- System: Safe Action®
- Magazine Capacity: Standard: 10 rounds
- Barrel Length: 4.02 inches
- Weight with Empty Magazine: 14.64 oz
- Trigger Pull: 26 N
- Overall Length: 7.28 inches
- Slide Length: 6.85 inches
- Overall Width: 1.26 inches
- Slide Width: 1.00 inch
- Height with Magazine: 5.04 inches
Overview Glock 17
The Glock 17, a legend in its own right, is the 9mm powerhouse known for its versatility and dependability. It’s a staple in the world of law enforcement and among enthusiasts.
Specs
- Caliber: 9mm
- System: Safe Action®
- Magazine Capacity: Standard: 10 rounds
- Barrel Length: 4.02 inches
- Weight with Empty Magazine: 14.64 oz
- Trigger Pull: 26 N
- Overall Length: 7.28 inches
- Slide Length: 6.85 inches
- Overall Width: 1.26 inches
- Slide Width: 1.00 inch
- Height with Magazine: 5.04 inches
Features Comparison: Glock 44 VS Glock 17
1. Recoil and Handling
Glock 44
The Glock 44, with its .22 LR caliber, offers a noticeably softer recoil compared to higher calibers.
The handling is quite smooth, and the lightweight design makes it easy to keep the sights on target. For new shooters or those looking to improve their skills without the stress of heavier recoil, the G44 is a dream to handle.
Glock 17
The Glock 17, chambered in 9x19mm, presents a significant step up in recoil compared to the G44. However, it’s worth noting that the G17’s design efficiently manages this increased recoil.
The handling is robust and reliable, providing a sense of control and power that’s expected from a 9mm. For shooters accustomed to higher calibers, the G17’s recoil is manageable and even satisfying, contributing to a feeling of real firepower in your hands.
Winner
When it comes to recoil and handling, the Glock 44 takes the lead, but only when compared to the Glock 17. The G44’s low recoil and lightweight design make it more user-friendly, especially for extended practice sessions or for shooters sensitive to recoil.
However, for those who prefer the feel and challenge of a higher caliber, the G17’s robust handling and manageable recoil offer a more exhilarating shooting experience. It’s a matter of personal preference, but for ease and comfort, the G44 edges out.
2. Ergonomics and Grip
Glock 44
The Glock 44’s ergonomics are well-thought-out, especially with its Gen 5 no-grooves front strap. This feature provides a smooth and comfortable grip, allowing for a more natural hand placement.
The grip size is similar to the Glock 19, which is often preferred for its balance between control and comfort. This makes the G44 an excellent choice for shooters who value a grip that’s easy to manage and doesn’t cause strain over long shooting sessions.
Glock 17
The Glock 17, particularly the Generation 3 model, features distinct finger grooves on the front strap. These grooves can offer a more secure grip for some shooters, especially in rapid-fire scenarios or under stress.
However, this can also be a downside for those with different hand sizes, as the fixed grooves might not align perfectly for everyone. The grip length is longer than the G44, providing more surface area but potentially feeling oversized for shooters with smaller hands.
Winner
In terms of ergonomics and grip, the Glock 44 stands out compared to the Glock 17. The smoother, groove-less design of the G44 provides a more versatile and comfortable grip for a wider range of hand sizes.
While the G17’s finger grooves may offer more grip security for some, they can be limiting for others. The G44 strikes a better balance, making it a more universally comfortable option. This feature is particularly crucial for those who need a grip that accommodates various hand sizes and shooting styles.
3. Accuracy and Sight Alignment
Glock 44
The Glock 44, in my hands, has demonstrated remarkable accuracy, especially for a .22 LR. The factory settings seem to have it zeroed at a longer range, as I’ve noticed it shoots about 4 inches high at 7 yards.
This requires some adjustment in the point of aim for closer targets. The sight alignment feels intuitive, though the need for adjustment at closer ranges can be a bit of a challenge initially. However, once you get used to it, hitting your mark becomes quite straightforward.
Glock 17
With the Glock 17, I found the accuracy to be reliable and consistent. The sight alignment on the G17 feels spot-on, and I didn’t need much adjustment, even at varying distances.
The higher caliber and increased power of the 9mm round make it a bit more challenging to maintain accuracy, especially for shooters not used to the recoil. But, with practice, the G17 proves to be a highly accurate firearm, especially in skilled hands.
Winner
In terms of accuracy and sight alignment, it’s a close call, but the Glock 17 edges out slightly compared to the Glock 44.
The G17’s inherent accuracy, coupled with less need for adjustment in sight alignment across different ranges, makes it a bit more versatile. While the G44 is highly accurate in its own right, the initial need for adjustment at closer ranges can be a minor inconvenience.
So, for shooters looking for out-of-the-box accuracy across various distances, the G17 takes the lead.
4. Overall Shooting Experience
Glock 44
Shooting the Glock 44 has been a joy, mainly due to the low recoil and affordability of .22 LR rounds. The experience is particularly gratifying for extended practice sessions, where the low cost and minimal recoil allow for more focus on technique rather than managing power.
Glock 17
The Glock 17 offers a robust shooting experience characterized by the power and reliability of the 9mm round. The feeling of shooting the G17 is more intense compared to the G44, with a noticeable recoil that might take some getting used to.
However, this also adds to the sense of handling a more powerful firearm, which can be quite satisfying. The G17’s reliability and performance in various conditions make it a top choice for many shooters, especially those who appreciate the versatility and power of a 9mm pistol.
Winner
When it comes to the overall shooting experience, the choice between the Glock 44 and Glock 17 depends on what the shooter values. For those who prioritize a gentle, cost-effective, and extended training experience, the G44 is the winner.
Pros & Cons of Glock 44
Pros
- Exceptionally light recoil, great for beginners and extended practice.
- Economical ammo, allowing for high-volume shooting.
- Lightweight and easy to manage, enhancing comfort during use.
- Suitable for a variety of hand sizes due to its ergonomic design.
- Good accuracy at longer ranges.
Cons
- Shoots slightly high at close ranges, requiring sight adjustments.
Pros & Cons of Glock 17
Pros
- Powerful 9mm caliber provides a more intense shooting experience.
- Higher magazine capacity, with options for further expansion.
- Reliable and consistent accuracy.
- Robust build suited for a range of conditions.
- Extensive aftermarket support due to its popularity.
Cons
- The larger size may not suit shooters with smaller hands.
Similarities Between Glock 44 & Glock 17
- Both use Glock’s Safe Action system.
- It has a similar overall width of 1.26 inches.
- Similar slide width of 1.00 inch.
- Both have a reputation for reliability and durability.
Differences Between Glock 44 & Glock 17
- Glock 44 is a .22 LR caliber, while Glock 17 is 9x19mm.
- Glock 44 has a standard 10-round mag, compared to Glock 17’s 17-rounds.
- Glock 44 is lighter, with an empty mag weight of 14.64 oz, against Glock 17’s 24.87 oz.
- Glock 44 has a trigger pull of 26 N, slightly lighter than Glock 17’s 28 N.
- Glock 44 has a shorter overall length (7.28 inches) compared to Glock 17’s 8.03 inches.
- Glock 17 offers optional higher mag capacities (up to 33 rounds), which are not available for Glock 44.
- Glock 44’s barrel length is 4.02 inches, shorter than Glock 17’s 4.49 inches.
- Glock 17 is taller, with a height including a magazine of 5.47 inches versus Glock 44’s 5.04 inches.
Final Verdict
After rigorously testing both the Glock 44 and Glock 17, I’ve reached a conclusion that reflects a blend of personal preference and practicality. Both firearms exhibit Glock’s renowned reliability and quality, but they cater to different needs and shooting styles.
My choice leans towards the Glock 17. It emerges as the winner in most comparisons, primarily due to its versatility, higher capacity, and the satisfaction that comes with shooting a 9mm.
The Glock 17’s ability to balance power, accuracy, and comfort makes it an all-rounder, suitable for both personal defense and professional use. It stands out as the best choice for those seeking a reliable and powerful handgun.
FAQ’s
Why choose Glock 45 over Glock 17?
The choice between Glock 45 and Glock 17 depends on personal preference; the Glock 45 is slightly better for concealed carry due to its smaller profile, while the Glock 17 might be more accurate and suitable for duty carry.
Is the Glock 44 and Glock 19 the same?
The Glock 44 and Glock 19 are similar in fit and feel, but the Glock 44 is in a smaller .22 LR caliber.
Why is the Glock 17 so popular?
The Glock 17 is popular for its reliability, capable of firing tens of thousands of shots with minimal jams and enduring harsh conditions.
What is good about Glock 44?
The Glock 44 is an excellent, cheaper training option, allowing practice of various shooting skills except recoil management, saving money on ammunition.
