So, I recently had the opportunity to test out two popular handguns: the Glock 23 Vs SIG P365. As a professional shooter, I’m always eager to see how different firearms stack up against each other, especially when they’re as well-known as these two.
Let’s dive right in and compare these pistols to see which one might come out on top for various uses, particularly in the field.
| Feature | Glock 23 | SIG P365 |
| Caliber | .40 S&W | 9x19mm |
| Magazine Capacity | 13 rounds | 10+1 rounds |
| Barrel Length | 4.02 inches | 3.1 inches |
| Weight (No Magazine) | 21.34 oz | 17.8 oz |
| Overall Length | 7.28 inches | 5.8 inches |
| Overall Width | 1.26 inches | 1.06 inches |
| Height (Incl. Magazine) | 5.04 inches | 4.3 inches |
Overview Glock 23
The Glock 23 is often referred to as the compact sibling of the Glock 22. It’s tailor-made for concealed carry and everyday use, packing a punch in a size that’s easy to handle.
Specs
- Caliber: .40 S&W
- Magazine Capacity: 13 rounds
- Barrel Length: 4.02 inches
- Weight (no magazine): 21.34 oz
- Weight (empty magazine): 23.81 oz
- Weight (loaded magazine): 31.39 oz
- Trigger Pull: ~6.29 lbs
- Overall Length: 7.28 inches
- Slide Length: 6.85 inches
- Overall Width: 1.26 inches
- Slide Width: 1.0 inch
- Height (including magazine): 5.04 inches
Overview Sig P365
The SIG P365 is a small-frame sensation in the 9x19mm caliber, renowned for its impressive capacity, considering its micro-compact size. It’s a top pick for concealed carry, offering ease and efficiency.
Specs
- Caliber: 9x19mm
- Magazine Capacity: 10+1 rounds
- Barrel Length: 3.1 inches
- Weight (no magazine): 17.8 oz
- Overall Length: 5.8 inches
- Overall Width: 1.06 inches
- Height (including magazine): 4.3 inches
Top 5 Features Comparison Glock 23 VS SIG P365
1. Magazine Capacity and Caliber
Glock 23
The Glock 23 boasts a standard magazine capacity of 13 rounds, which is quite impressive for a compact firearm. Its caliber, .40 S&W, is known for its stopping power, making the Glock 23 a solid choice for both self-defense and law enforcement use.
During my field tests, I appreciated the extra rounds that the Glock 23 offered, giving me confidence in situations where more shots might be necessary.
SIG P365
The SIG P365, despite its micro-compact size, offers a 10+1 round capacity in the 9x19mm caliber. This is remarkable for such a small firearm. In my hands-on experience, the SIG P365 was easy to handle and shoot, and the 9mm rounds provided a smooth shooting experience with less recoil.
This caliber is also widely available and affordable, which is a bonus for regular practice.
Winner
Deciding a winner here is tough. The Glock 23 leads with higher capacity and a more powerful caliber, which is great for those who prioritize firepower.
However, the SIG P365 impresses with its capacity-to-size ratio and the user-friendly 9mm caliber. For everyday carry and ease of use, especially for those who might be newer to shooting, the SIG P365 takes the edge.
2. Size and Concealability
Glock 23
The Glock 23, being a compact version of the Glock 22, offers a good balance between size and firepower. Its dimensions make it suitable for concealed carry, but it’s slightly larger than the SIG P365.
In my field tests, I found it concealable with the right holster, though its size was more noticeable compared to the SIG P365.
SIG P365
The SIG P365 is a game-changer in the micro-compact category. Its small size makes it incredibly easy to conceal, perfect for everyday carry.
During my testing, it was almost unnoticeable when I carried it, offering great comfort and discretion. This makes it an excellent choice for those who prioritize concealability above all else.
Winner
The SIG P365 clearly wins in this category. Its innovative design allows for exceptional concealability without sacrificing capacity, making it an ideal choice for concealed carry enthusiasts who need a discreet, effective firearm.
3. Ergonomics and Handling
Glock 23
The Glock 23 offers a familiar Glock feel – sturdy, reliable, and well-balanced. Its slightly larger size compared to the SIG P365 means a more substantial grip, which some shooters might find more comfortable, especially those with larger hands.
In my field tests, I noticed that the Glock 23’s grip and balance helped in maintaining better control during rapid-fire sequences.
SIG P365
The SIG P365, despite its small size, doesn’t compromise on ergonomics. Its design ensures a surprisingly comfortable grip and easy handling, even for a micro-compact.
During testing, I found that the SIG P365 fit snugly in my hand, allowing for quick and easy maneuverability, an important factor in concealed carry situations.
Winner
This is a close call. The Glock 23 offers a solid, familiar feel that many shooters appreciate, especially in stressful situations.
However, the SIG P365’s ergonomic design in such a compact form is truly impressive. For its size, the SIG P365 provides exceptional handling and comfort, making it the winner in this category.
4. Accuracy and Range Performance
Glock 23
The Glock 23 is renowned for its accuracy, a feature I can vouch for after my range tests. This .40 caliber pistol maintains a tight shot grouping even at longer distances.
The longer barrel length, compared to the SIG P365, plays a crucial role here. During my testing, I was impressed by its consistent performance, especially when shooting at targets beyond the typical self-defense range.
SIG P365
The SIG P365, with its shorter barrel, is primarily designed for close-range engagements, typical in concealed carry scenarios. In my field tests, it performed exceptionally well at close ranges, with commendable accuracy.
However, at longer distances, the smaller barrel and sight radius started to show their limitations. The P365 is undoubtedly reliable for its intended use, but it’s not the first choice for situations requiring longer-range precision.
Winner
In terms of accuracy and range performance, the Glock 23 takes the lead. Its design and specifications make it more versatile for various shooting distances.
The SIG P365, while excellent for close-range engagements, doesn’t quite match up to the Glock 23 when it comes to longer-range accuracy and performance.
5. Reliability and Durability
Glock 23
Glocks are known for their reliability, and the Glock 23 is no exception. During my testing, it handled various types of ammunition without any issues and operated flawlessly in different weather conditions.
Its rugged build ensures longevity and consistent performance, which is vital for a firearm intended for daily carry and potentially life-saving situations.
SIG P365
The SIG P365 has made a name for itself in terms of reliability, especially considering its size. In my experience, it fed and fired various 9mm rounds smoothly.
The quality of its build is apparent, and it feels sturdy in hand. While there were initial concerns about its reliability shortly after release, these have been addressed in subsequent models, making it a dependable choice for everyday carry.
Winner
This is a close call, as both pistols have proven themselves reliable and durable. However, with its track record and robust construction, the Glock 23 edges out slightly. It has consistently shown itself to be a workhorse capable of withstanding extensive use and harsh conditions.
The SIG P365 is also reliable but hasn’t yet built the same long-standing reputation as the Glock in this area.
Pros & Cons of Glock 23
Pros
- Higher magazine capacity (13 rounds).
- Superior stopping power with .40 S&W caliber.
- Longer barrel length aids in accuracy, especially at range.
- Robust build, reliable in various conditions.
- Well-balanced for a compact firearm, good for larger hands.
Cons
- Heavier and bulkier, making it less ideal for very discreet carry.
- .40 S&W ammo can be more expensive and has more recoil.
- Might be too large for shooters with smaller hands.
Pros & Cons of SIG P365
Pros
- Extremely compact, excellent for concealed carry.
- Impressive magazine capacity (10+1) for its size.
- Lighter and more comfortable for all-day carry.
- Lower recoil with 9x19mm caliber, easier for rapid follow-up shots.
- Good ergonomics for a micro-compact.
Cons
- Less suitable for long-range accuracy.
- Smaller size might be less comfortable for shooters with larger hands.
- 9mm may lack the stopping power of larger calibers like .40 S&W.
Similarities between Glock 23 & SIG P365
- Both are popular choices for concealed carry.
- Each offers a double-stack magazine design.
- Both have polymer frames, contributing to lighter weight.
- Each model is renowned for reliability and durability.
- Both have a reputation for ease of use and maintenance.
- Suitable for a variety of holsters and accessories.
Differences between Glock 23 & SIG P365
- Glock 23 uses .40 S&W caliber, while SIG P365 uses 9x19mm.
- Glock 23 has a higher standard magazine capacity (13 vs 10+1).
- Glock 23 is larger and heavier than the micro-compact SIG P365.
- Barrel length: Glock 23 (4.02 inches) vs SIG P365 (3.1 inches).
- Glock 23 offers better long-range accuracy.
- SIG P365 excels in concealability due to its smaller size.
- Weight difference: Glock 23 is heavier than SIG P365.
- Glock 23 is better suited for larger hands, SIG P365 for smaller hands.
- SIG P365 is often preferred for extremely discreet carry.
- Price points can vary between the two, with the Glock 23 generally being more expensive.
- Recoil: Glock 23 has more recoil due to .40 caliber, compared to SIG P365’s 9mm.
Final Verdict
After extensive testing and comparing the Glock 23 and the SIG P365, it’s clear that each gun has its unique strengths tailored to different needs.
Ultimately, my choice leans towards the SIG P365. Its exceptional balance of size, capacity, and performance makes it an ideal everyday carry weapon, especially in scenarios where discretion and comfort are key.
While the Glock 23 is undoubtedly a powerful and reliable firearm, the SIG P365’s innovations in the micro-compact category make it a groundbreaking choice for modern concealed carry needs.
FAQ’s
Which is better Glock or Sig P365?
Both have their merits. The Glock offers more firepower and is suitable for a variety of uses, while the SIG P365 excels in concealability and ease of handling, making it a top choice for self-defense and concealed carry.
Is a P365 good for self-defense?
Yes, the SIG P365 is excellent for self-defense. Its compact size, combined with a substantial magazine capacity, makes it a versatile and effective option for concealed carry.
Why is SIG more expensive than Glock?
SIG Sauer’s models often include metal-frame and hammer-fired designs, which are costlier to manufacture. Glocks, primarily polymer-frame and striker-fired, are less expensive to produce.
How accurate is Sig P365?
The SIG P365 offers very good practical accuracy, particularly impressive for its size. Its well-designed trigger and sights contribute to its ease of shooting.
How long will a P365 last?
The SIG P365 has demonstrated remarkable durability, with some tests showing low failure rates even after firing over 100,000 rounds, indicating its longevity even with extensive use.
