I’m a professional shooter, and I’ve spent some time in the field rigorously testing two of Glock’s popular models: the Glock 17 and the Glock 43X.
My goal is to figure out which one stands out as the winner in real-world scenarios. Through hands-on experience and a series of tests, I’ve gathered insights to help you understand which of these impressive handguns might be the right choice for you.
So, let’s dive in and see how they stack up!
| Feature | Glock 17 | Glock 43x |
| Caliber | 9x19mm | 9x19mm |
| System | Safe Action® | Safe Action® |
| Magazine Capacity | Standard: 17 (Options up to 33) | Standard: 10 |
| Barrel Length | 4.49 inches | 3.41 inches |
| Weight (With Empty Magazine) | 24.87 oz | 18.70 oz |
| Trigger Pull | 28 N | 24 N |
| Overall Length | 8.03 inches | 6.50 inches |
| Slide Length | 7.32 inches | 6.06 inches |
| Overall Width | 1.26 inches | 1.10 inches |
| Slide Width | 1.0 inch | 0.87 inch |
Glock 17
The Glock 17 has set a high bar in the 9x19mm firearm category, celebrated for its dependable performance and substantial magazine capacity.
Specs
- Caliber: 9x19mm
- Barrel Length: 4.49 inches
- Weight: 24.87 oz
- Trigger Pull: 28 N
- Overall Length: 8.03 inches
- Slide Length: 7.32 inches
- Overall Width: 1.26 inches
- Slide Width: 1.0 inch
Glock 43x
The Glock 43x offers a sleek, compact design, balancing concealability with comfortable handling, making it a favored choice for concealed carry.
Specs
- Caliber: 9x19mm
- Barrel Length: 3.41 inches
- Weight: 18.70 oz
- Trigger Pull: 24 N
- Overall Length: 6.50 inches
- Slide Length: 6.06 inches
- Overall Width: 1.10 inches
- Slide Width: 0.87 inch
Features Comparison of Glock 17 VS Glock 43x
1. Magazine Capacity and Versatility
Glock 17
The Glock 17 stands out with its generous magazine capacity. The standard is 17 rounds, but it offers options up to 33 rounds. In the field, this means fewer reloads and sustained firing capabilities.
During my testing, the higher capacity was a game-changer in scenarios where continuous shooting was crucial. The versatility in magazine options also allows for customization based on the shooting context, whether it’s for sport or self-defense.
Glock 43x
In contrast, the Glock 43x’s magazine capacity is capped at 10 rounds. It’s designed for concealability and ease of carry.
While testing, I noticed this limited capacity meant more frequent reloads, which could be a drawback in situations requiring sustained fire. However, for everyday carry and situations where discretion is vital, the smaller capacity is a fair trade-off for its compactness and lightweight design.
Winner
For sheer firepower and versatility, the Glock 17 takes the lead. Its ability to accommodate a wide range of magazine capacities makes it suitable for diverse shooting situations.
The Glock 43x, while efficient for concealed carry, can’t match the 17 in terms of sustained firing capabilities.
2. Weight and Handling
Glock 17
The Glock 17 is heavier, especially when fully loaded. This added weight, while noticeable,
actually helps stabilize the gun during firing, reducing recoil. During my field tests, I appreciated this stability, especially in rapid-fire scenarios.
However, the weight can be a bit cumbersome for all-day carry, especially for those not used to carrying a full-sized firearm.
Glock 43x
The Glock 43x is significantly lighter, making it much more comfortable for extended periods of carry. Its reduced weight does mean more felt recoil, but in my testing, this wasn’t a major issue for controlled, deliberate shooting.
Its lightweight nature makes it an excellent choice for those needing a firearm for all-day carry without the bulk.
Winner
The Glock 43x shines in terms of weight and handling. Its lightness and ease of carry make it ideal for everyday use, particularly for those who prioritize comfort and discretion. The Glock 17, while offering better stability, might be too bulky for some users.
3. Size and Concealability
Glock 17
The Glock 17’s larger size gives it an advantage in terms of grip and control. During my testing, I found its size to be an asset in providing a secure grip, which is crucial for accuracy and control.
However, its larger frame makes it more challenging to conceal, especially for individuals with a smaller build or those wearing lighter clothing.
Glock 43x
The Glock 43x excels in concealability due to its compact size. Its slim profile and shorter barrel length make it easy to conceal under most clothing.
In my field tests, I found it perfect for discreet carry, with little to no imprinting. Its smaller size does compromise grip space, which might be an issue for shooters with larger hands.
Winner
When it comes to size and concealability, the Glock 43x is the clear winner. Its compact design is ideal for concealed carry and is more comfortable for users who need a discreet, easily concealable firearm.
The Glock 17, while excellent in grip and control, may not be the best choice for those prioritizing concealability.
4. Accuracy and Range Performance
Glock 17
The Glock 17, with its longer barrel length of 4.49 inches, naturally lends itself to better accuracy and range performance. During field tests, I noticed the extended sight line significantly improved my precision on targets at various distances.
The larger frame also helped in stabilizing the gun during rapid firing. This aspect is particularly beneficial for situations where distance shooting and accuracy are paramount, like in competitive shooting or law enforcement scenarios.
Glock 43x
The Glock 43x, with a shorter barrel length of 3.41 inches, presents a slight challenge in terms of long-range accuracy compared to the Glock 17.
However, during my field tests, I was pleasantly surprised by its performance. While it may not match the precision of the Glock 17 at longer ranges, it holds up remarkably well for its size. It’s more than capable for self-defense situations where engagement distances are typically shorter.
Winner
In terms of accuracy and range performance, the Glock 17 is the clear winner. Its longer barrel and sight line give it a distinct advantage in precision shooting, especially at longer distances. The Glock 43x, while commendable for its size, can’t quite match up in this aspect.
5. Ergonomics and Comfort
Glock 17
The Glock 17’s larger frame provides a full grip, which I found to be more comfortable during extended shooting sessions. Its weight and balance felt just right in my hands, offering a stable shooting experience.
The ergonomics of the Glock 17 are designed for ease of use and control, something that became evident during my testing, especially in rapid fire scenarios.
Glock 43x
In contrast, the Glock 43 is designed for ease of carry and concealment, which affects its ergonomics. The smaller frame may not be as comfortable for shooters with larger hands, and I noticed this during my testing.
For those with smaller hands or for those prioritizing concealability, the Glock 43x is remarkably comfortable and easy to handle.
Winner
When it comes to ergonomics and comfort, it’s a close call, but the Glock 17 edges out slightly. Its full-sized frame provides a better grip and overall comfort, particularly for shooters with larger hands or those engaged in prolonged shooting sessions.
The Glock 43x, while excellent for concealed carry and shorter sessions, may not offer the same level of comfort for all users.
Pros & Cons Glock 17
Pros
- High magazine capacity (standard 17, options up to 33 rounds) for extended firing without reloading.
- Longer barrel (4.49 inches) enhances accuracy, especially at longer ranges.
- Larger size provides a full, comfortable grip and better control.
- Weight contributes to stability and reduced recoil during rapid firing.
- Extended sight line improves precision in shooting.
Cons
- Bulkier and heavier, potentially less comfortable for all-day carry.
- Larger size makes it more challenging to conceal.
- May be too large for shooters with smaller hands.
Pros & Cons of Glock 43
Pros
- Compact and lightweight, ideal for concealed carry and comfortable all-day wear.
- Smaller frame is well-suited for individuals with smaller hands.
- Despite its size, it maintains good accuracy for short-range engagements.
- Easier to handle and maneuver in tight spaces.
Cons
- Limited magazine capacity (standard 10 rounds) means more frequent reloads.
- Shorter barrel length (3.41 inches) may affect long-range accuracy.
- Smaller grip might be less comfortable for shooters with larger hands.
Similarities between Glock 17 & Glock 43x
- Both are chambered in the popular 9x19mm caliber.
- Utilize Glock’s Safe Action® System for consistent and safe operation.
- Designed with polymer frames for durability and reduced weight.
- Feature similar aesthetic designs characteristic of Glock firearms.
- Known for their reliability and durability under various conditions.
- Have consistent and manageable trigger pulls for precision shooting.
- Offer good ergonomics that cater to a wide range of shooters.
Differences between Glock 17 & Glock 43x
- Glock 17 has a higher standard magazine capacity (17 vs 10 rounds) compared to the Glock 43x.
- Glock 17 is larger in overall size, making it more challenging to conceal than the Glock 43x.
- Glock 17 has a longer barrel, enhancing its long-range accuracy over the Glock 43x.
- Glock 43x is significantly lighter, especially noticeable when carrying for extended periods.
- Glock 43x’s compact size offers superior concealability and ease of carry.
- Glock 17’s longer line of sight aids in more precise target acquisition.
- The grip size and feel differ considerably, with the Glock 17 offering a fuller grip.
- Glock 17 is more suitable for competitive shooting and law enforcement due to its features.
- Glock 43x is better suited for personal defense and concealed carry scenarios.
Final Verdict
After thorough testing and comparison, it’s clear that both the Glock 17 and the Glock 43x have their unique strengths and ideal applications.
The Glock 17, with its higher capacity and longer barrel, is excellent for situations where firepower and accuracy are crucial. On the other hand, the Glock 43x’s compactness and light weight make it ideal for everyday concealed carry.
For my personal use, the choice ultimately comes down to the context in which I’m using the firearm. For tactical situations or competitive shooting, the Glock 17 is my go-to for its robust performance. However, for everyday carry and personal defense, the Glock 43x’s convenience and concealability make it my top choice.
FAQ’s
What’s the difference between a Glock 17 and a Glock 43?
The Glock 17 has a longer barrel and slide compared to the Glock 43, making it more challenging to conceal but offering better accuracy and capacity.
Is Glock 17 too big for concealed carry?
The Glock 17, being a full-size pistol, can be challenging for concealed carry compared to smaller models, especially for those prioritizing discretion and comfort.
Which is better Glock 19 or 43X?
The choice between Glock 19 and Glock 43X depends on your needs: Glock 43X for a lightweight, slim profile, and Glock 19 for higher capacity and a more robust frame.
Why is the Glock 17 so popular?
The Glock 17 is popular for its reliability, ability to withstand harsh conditions, and perform consistently with minimal jams, making it a trusted choice for many gun owners.
