I’m diving into a comparison between the Taurus PT22 Vs Phoenix Arms 22.
My goal is to put these two side by side, run them through their paces, and see which one emerges as the top pick.
This comparison is aimed at giving you a clear picture of what each gun has to offer. So, let’s get into it and find out which one of these .22 caliber pistols stands out as the winner.
| Feature | Taurus PT22 | Phoenix Arms 22 |
| Caliber | .22 LR | .22 LR |
| Capacity | 8+1 | 10+1 |
| Weight | 12.3 oz | 20 oz |
| Length | 5.2 inches | 6.5 inches |
| Height | 4.3 inches | 4.7 inches |
| Width | 1.14 inches | 1.5 inches |
| Barrel Length | 2.8 inches | 3 inches |
Overview of Taurus PT22
The Taurus PT22 is a compact, semi-automatic pistol that’s known for its user-friendly design and reliability.
Specs
- Caliber: .22 LR
- Capacity: 8+1 rounds
- Weight: 12.3 oz
- Length: 5.2 inches
- Height: 4.3 inches
- Width: 1.14 inches
- Barrel Length: 2.8 inches
Overview of Phoenix Arms 22
The Phoenix Arms 22 stands out as a budget-friendly, yet robust .22 LR handgun, perfect for both new shooters and veterans alike.
Specs
- Caliber: 22 LR
- Capacity: 10+1
- Weight: 20oz
- Length: 6.5 inches
- Height: 4.7 inches
- Width: 1.5 inches
- Barrel Length: 3 inches
Features Comparison of Taurus PT22 vs Phoenix Arms 22
1. Trigger Mechanism
Taurus PT22
The Taurus PT22’s trigger mechanism is distinct for its double-action-only setup, which, while ensuring consistent pull force, also makes it notably heavier compared to many pistols in its class.
This heavy pull can be a significant drawback for shooters with less grip strength or those new to shooting, potentially affecting accuracy and comfort during extended use.
Moreover, the unique combination of this heavy trigger with the PT22’s tip-up barrel design adds an interesting layer to its operation, making it a standout feature that offers a mixed bag of benefits and challenges.
Phoenix Arms 22
Contrasting with the PT22, the Phoenix Arms 22 offers a more nuanced trigger experience through its double-action/single-action (DA/SA) mechanism.
This setup provides a heavier initial pull that transitions into lighter, smoother pulls for subsequent shots, offering a balance of safety and quick follow-up shot capability.
This versatility enhances the shooting experience by allowing for precision and ease of operation, particularly appealing during longer shooting sessions or for those practicing rapid fire sequences.
Winner
In this comparison, the Phoenix Arms 22 surpasses the Taurus PT22, thanks to its DA/SA trigger mechanism.
This feature not only offers a more adaptable shooting experience but also significantly improves comfort and accuracy, making it particularly advantageous for varied shooting scenarios.
2. Safety and Operation
Taurus PT22
The PT22’s operational simplicity is one of its strong suits, largely due to its tip-up barrel feature.
This innovative design allows for easy loading and unloading of the chamber without the need to manipulate the slide, offering an excellent solution for those with limited hand strength or dexterity.
Additionally, this functionality streamlines the process of making the firearm ready to fire or safe, enhancing its appeal to a broader range of users who might find traditional slide operations challenging or cumbersome.
Phoenix Arms 22
The Phoenix Arms 22, however, adopts a more complex approach to safety and operation, featuring dual safety mechanisms.
This dual-system can be perceived as either a meticulous safety enhancement or an unnecessary complication, depending on one’s familiarity and comfort with firearm safety features.
Winner
The Taurus PT22 takes the lead in this category due to its user-friendly tip-up barrel design, which simplifies operation and makes it more accessible, especially for those who may face challenges with traditional slide mechanisms.
3. Reliability and Performance
Taurus PT22
In terms of reliability, the Taurus PT22 presented some challenges during testing, with occurrences of malfunctions that suggest a break-in period may be necessary to achieve optimal performance.
While it generally handles high-quality ammunition well, this necessity for an extended break-in period to reach reliability could be a point of consideration for users looking for out-of-the-box performance.
Phoenix Arms 22
On the flip side, the Phoenix Arms 22 demonstrated exceptional reliability throughout testing, performing flawlessly across a variety of ammunition types.
This consistent operation without the need for a significant break-in period marks it as a highly reliable option for shooters seeking a dependable .22 caliber pistol. Its ability to maintain performance across different shooting conditions and ammo types underscores its superior design and engineering.
Winner
The Phoenix Arms 22 clearly outperforms the Taurus PT22 in reliability and performance.
Its ability to deliver consistent, malfunction-free operation across a broad range of ammunition types without a stringent break-in requirement establishes it as the preferable choice for those prioritizing reliability in their .22 LR firearm selection.
4. Ergonomics and Comfort
Taurus PT22
The Taurus PT22 is designed with ergonomics in mind, featuring a compact and lightweight frame that fits comfortably in the hand. Its slim profile makes it easy to handle, especially for those with smaller hands.
However, its heavy trigger pull can detract from the overall shooting experience, requiring more effort to shoot accurately.
Phoenix Arms 22
The Phoenix Arms 22, while slightly heavier than the Taurus, offers a grip that is surprisingly comfortable and provides a stable shooting platform.
Its weight distribution feels balanced, aiding in control during firing. The double action/single action trigger provides a better shooting experience with a clearer break and lighter pull after the initial shot.
Winner
Phoenix Arms 22 excels in this feature compared to the Taurus PT22. Despite its slightly heavier frame, the Phoenix Arms 22 offers a more comfortable grip and a balanced weight that contributes to a more controlled and enjoyable shooting experience.
Pros & Cons of Taurus PT22
Pros
- Compact and lightweight design.
- Tip-up barrel allows for easy loading and unloading.
Cons
- Heavy trigger pull.
- Some reliability issues without sufficient breaking in.
Pros & Cons of Phoenix Arms 22
Pros
- Reliable performance with different ammo types.
- Comfortable grip and balanced weight.
Cons
- Slightly heavier than some competitors though not much of a difference.
Similarities between Taurus PT22 & Phoenix Arms 22
- Both chambered in .22 LR.
- Semi-automatic operation.
- Targeted towards the budget-friendly market.
- Suitable for casual shooting and plinking.
Differences between Taurus PT22 & Phoenix Arms 22
- Taurus PT22 has a tip-up barrel; Phoenix Arms does not.
- Phoenix Arms has a DA/SA trigger; Taurus PT22 has a heavy DA only.
- Taurus PT22 is lighter and more compact; Phoenix Arms is slightly heavier but offers better ergonomics.
- Phoenix Arms exhibited superior reliability and performance in testing compared to Taurus PT22.
Final Verdict
After putting both the Taurus PT22 and Phoenix Arms 22 through rigorous testing and comparison across various features, it’s clear that one of these .22 LR pistols stands out as the superior choice for me: the Phoenix Arms 22.
This decision doesn’t come lightly, as both pistols have their unique strengths and appeal.
However, the Phoenix Arms 22’s outstanding reliability, enhanced comfort, and more versatile trigger mechanism set it apart as the preferred option.
FAQ’s
Does the Taurus PT22 have a safety?
Yes, the Taurus PT22 is equipped with a small, two-position safety lever at the left rear of the frame.
Can you dry fire a Taurus PT22?
Yes, the Taurus PT22 is designed to be safe for dry firing.
