I’m diving into a head-to-head comparison of two remarkable guns: the Springfield XD-S and its upgraded sibling, the Springfield XD-S MOD.2.
I aim to determine which one emerges as the champion in the field. I’ve tested these firearms extensively, analyzing every aspect to see which stands out.
| Feature | Springfield XD-S | Springfield XD-S MOD.2 |
| Caliber | 9x19mm | 9x19mm |
| Length | 6.3 inches | 6.3 inches |
| Height | 4.4 inches | 4.4 inches |
| Width | 0.9 inches | 0.9 inches |
| Barrel Length | 3.3 inches | 3.3 inches |
| Weight (empty mag) | 23 oz. | 23 oz. |
| Capacity (flush mag) | 7+1 rounds | 7+1 rounds |
| Capacity (ext. mag) | 9+1 rounds | 9+1 rounds |
Overview of Springfield XD-S
The Springfield XD-S is a compact powerhouse known for its reliability and ease of concealment. A popular choice for self-defense, it’s a firearm that packs a punch.
Specs
- Caliber: 9x19mm
- Length: 6.3 inches
- Height: 4.4 inches
- Width: 0.9 inches
- Barrel: 3.3 inches
- Weight: 23oz. (with empty magazine)
- Capacity: 7+1 (flush magazine) / 9+1 (extended magazine)
Overview of Springfield XD-S MOD.2
The Springfield XD-S MOD.2 is a refined version of its predecessor. It maintains the core features while introducing enhancements that elevate the shooting experience.
Specs
- Caliber: 9x19mm
- Length: 6.3 inches
- Height: 4.4 inches
- Width: 0.9 inches
- Barrel: 3.3 inches
- Weight: 23oz. (with empty magazine)
- Capacity: 7+1 (flush magazine) / 9+1 (extended magazine)
Features Comparison: Springfield XD-S vs. Springfield XD-S MOD.2
1. Grip Texture and Comfort
Springfield XD-S
The classic XD-S boasts a unique grenade-type grip pattern. It’s impressive in providing a secure hold, particularly in sweaty conditions.
But, as I’ve found during extensive field tests, if you’re firing for a prolonged period, this aggressive texture can feel uncomfortable, almost abrasive.
This aspect is crucial for shooters who spend long hours at the range or in situations requiring extended firearm use.
Springfield XD-S MOD.2
Now, the MOD.2 is a game changer in this department. The updated grip texture is both aesthetically pleasing and ergonomically superior. It feels smoother and more refined in the hand. During my rigorous testing; we’re talking hundreds of rounds here, the MOD.2 remained comfortable throughout.
The grip’s design seems to strike the perfect balance between maintaining a firm hold and ensuring user comfort, a vital feature for any shooter prioritizing extended use or those with more sensitive hands.
Winner
The XD-S MOD.2 wins hands down. Its grip texture is a significant upgrade over the original, providing enhanced comfort without compromising on the secure hold. Especially for extended use, it’s a clear improvement over the XD-S.
2. Grip Safety Design
Springfield XD-S
The original XD-S comes equipped with a functional grip safety, but it’s been a topic of debate among many shooters. The primary concern has been its size; is it too small to be reliably deactivated, especially in a rushed situation? In my own experience, while I didn’t face any issues, I could see why this might be a worry, particularly under stress or for those with different hand sizes.
Springfield XD-S MOD.2
The MOD.2 addresses these concerns head-on. The grip safety has been enlarged, a thoughtful design choice that enhances confidence and reliability.
During my tests, this tweak consistently provided a more secure and confident grip, ensuring the safety is reliably deactivated every time. This upgrade is crucial for anyone who relies on their firearm in high-pressure scenarios, where every second and every detail matters.
Winner
The XD-S MOD.2 edges out its predecessor in this category. The improved grip safety design boosts both reliability and user confidence, particularly in high-stress situations, making it a vital enhancement over the original XD-S.
3. Ergonomics and Handling
Springfield XD-S
The Springfield XD-S is recognized for its compact and efficient design, which contributes to its practical ergonomics. Holding this pistol, you feel a sense of balance and fit that’s quite impressive, especially considering its size.
However, it’s important to note that its distinct grenade-type grip pattern, while effective for a secure hold, might not be everyone’s cup of tea. Over long periods of use, I’ve noticed this texture can become somewhat abrasive, potentially causing discomfort.
Springfield XD-S MOD.2
The MOD.2 version of the Springfield XD-S takes a leap forward in terms of ergonomics. This model maintains the familiarity of the original’s handling but brings a noticeable improvement with its updated grip texture.
The new texture strikes a perfect balance; it’s less aggressive than the original yet still provides a firm, secure grip. This improvement is a significant factor in enhancing the overall handling of the firearm.
Winner
In the category of ergonomics and handling, the Springfield XD-S MOD.2 stands out as the clear winner. Its refined grip texture and improved ergonomics offer a more comfortable and user-friendly experience, especially when compared to the original XD-S.
For shooters who value prolonged comfort without sacrificing a secure grip, the MOD.2 emerges as the superior choice.
4. Overall Shooting Experience
Springfield XD-S
The XD-S has always been a reliable performer. Its accuracy and dependability are notable, with consistent, solid performance at the range.
As a tool for personal defense and concealed carry, it stands strong. Its handling and recoil management make it a steady and dependable option for a variety of shooters, whether at the range or in self-defense scenarios.
Springfield XD-S MOD.2
The MOD.2, in my extensive testing, builds on the strengths of the original while adding subtle yet impactful improvements. The enhancements in grip and safety don’t just add to comfort; they contribute to a more confident and controlled shooting experience.
Each shot feels more assured, and the overall experience is more intuitive. For those who value incremental but significant improvements in their shooting experience, the MOD.2 presents a compelling case.
Winner
It’s a tight race, but the Springfield XD-S MOD.2 takes the lead. Its incremental improvements in comfort and safety features make for a more polished and enjoyable shooting experience, tipping the scales in its favor compared to the original XD-S.
Pros & Cons: Springfield XD-S
Pros
- Highly reliable.
- Compact and easy to conceal.
- Satisfactory accuracy and performance.
Cons
- Grip texture can be uncomfortable over time.
Pros & Cons: Springfield XD-S MOD.2
Pros
- Improved grip texture for better comfort.
- Enhanced ergonomics.
- Retains the reliability and accuracy of the original.
Cons
- Slightly higher cost than the original.
Similarities Between Springfield XD-S Vs Springfield XD-S Mod 2
- Both have a caliber of 9x19mm.
- Identical dimensions: 6.3″ length, 4.4″ height, 0.9″ width.
- Same barrel length of 3.3″.
- Weight of 23oz with an empty magazine.
- Both models offer a discreet and compact design suitable for concealed carry.
Differences Between Springfield XD-S Vs Springfield XD-S Mod 2
- The MOD.2 features an improved grip texture for better comfort.
- Enhanced grip safety in the MOD.2 for more reliable use.
- MOD.2 has a more refined aesthetic with subtle design changes.
- The original XD-S has a more aggressive grenade-type grip pattern.
- Slight differences in price points, with the MOD.2 typically being more expensive.
Final Verdict
After extensive testing and comparisons, I’ve reached a definitive conclusion. In this duel of Springfield’s notable firearms, the Springfield XD-S MOD.2 emerges as the clear winner for me. While both guns exhibit remarkable qualities, the MOD.2’s subtle yet significant enhancements give it an edge.
These improvements, particularly in grip texture, ergonomics, and safety features, translate into a more refined shooting experience.
FAQ’s
Are XD-S and XD-S Mod 2 magazines the same?
Yes, the 7-round magazines from the original XD-S 45 can fit in the XD-S Mod. 2, with the removal of the plastic magazine sleeve.
Is XD-S Mod 2 discontinued?
Yes, the XD-S Mod. 2 3.3″ Single Stack Handgun with Tritium Sight has been discontinued by Springfield Armory.
Is Springfield XD-S Mod 2 a good gun?
Yes, the Springfield XD-S Mod. 2 is an excellent gun, particularly for defensive carry, owing to its reliability, enhanced features, and compact design.
