I’ve tested out two popular guns: the Springfield Hellcat Pro Vs S&W Equalizer.
You might be wondering, “Which one is better?” Well, I took them both to the field to find out. In this article, I’ll break down each gun’s features and performance, giving you the lowdown on what sets them apart.
Whether you’re a seasoned shooter or just starting, this comparison will help you make an informed choice.
| Feature | Springfield Hellcat Pro | S&W Equalizer |
| Caliber | 9mm Luger | 9mm Luger |
| Capacity | 11 + 1 | 10+1, 13+1, 15+1 Rounds |
| Barrel Length | 3 inches | 3.675 inches |
| Overall Length | 6 inches | 6.75 inches |
| Height | 4.12 inches | 4.5 inches (10-Rnd), 5.25 inches (15-Rnd) |
| Width | 0.88 inches | 1.04 inches |
| Weight | 18.3 ounces | 22.9 ounces |
Overview of Springfield Hellcat Pro
The Springfield Hellcat Pro is a compact powerhouse renowned for its balance of size and capacity.
Specs
- Caliber: 9mm Luger
- Capacity: 11 + 1
- Barrel Length: 3 inches
- Overall Length: 6 inches
- Height: 4.12 inches
- Width: 0.88 inches
- Weight: 18.3 ounces with flush magazine
- Safeties: Trigger lever, striker-pin block
S&W Equalizer
The S&W Equalizer stands out for its blend of user-friendly features and effective performance.
Specs
- Caliber: 9mm Luger
- Capacity: 10+1, 13+1, 15+1 Rounds
- Barrel Length: 3.675 inches
- Frame Width: 1.04 inches
- Overall Height: 4.5 inches with 10-Round Mag, 5.25 inches with 15-Round Mag
- Overall Length: 6.75 inches
- Barrel Material: Stainless Steel Armornite Finish
- Weight: 22.9 ounces
Features Comparison: Springfield Hellcat Pro vs S&W Equalizer
1. Ease of Racking the Slide
Springfield Hellcat Pro
Racking the Springfield Hellcat Pro slide demands a fair amount of hand strength. During extensive field tests, I noted that its slide, while robust and reliable, requires a firm and steady grip to operate.
This aspect could pose a challenge for shooters with limited hand strength or those with physical conditions that affect grip, like arthritis. It’s solid but definitely calls for more muscle compared to some other models.
S&W Equalizer
The S&W Equalizer, conversely, incorporates their remarkable ‘EZ’ technology in the slide mechanism. This innovation is particularly beneficial for those with restricted hand strength. In my testing, I was impressed by how effortlessly the slide could be operated, requiring minimal effort.
This user-friendly approach, enabling the slide to be racked with minimal force and just two fingers, starkly contrasts with the more demanding Hellcat Pro, offering a significant advantage for users with dexterity challenges.
Winner
In terms of ease of use, particularly for those with limited hand strength, the S&W Equalizer clearly surpasses the Springfield Hellcat Pro.
The EZ technology makes a noticeable difference in usability, making the Equalizer the more accessible choice for a broader range of shooters, particularly those who might struggle with the stiffer, more demanding slide of the Hellcat Pro.
2. Safety Mechanisms
Springfield Hellcat Pro
The Hellcat Pro’s approach to safety is minimalist, eschewing a physical external safety mechanism. This design choice can be seen as a benefit for those who prefer a seamless, uninterrupted shooting experience. In my hands-on tests, I valued the direct and uncomplicated nature of its safety system, which relies solely on internal mechanisms.
This simplicity in design can be advantageous in scenarios where speed and a no-frills approach are critical.
S&W Equalizer
The S&W Equalizer opts for a more traditional safety approach, featuring a back strap safety. This additional safety feature offers an extra layer of security but requires a deliberate grip to activate the trigger.
My field testing showed that this could slightly slow down the firing process, especially in rapid response situations, as it necessitates ensuring the back strap is fully engaged before the gun will fire.
Winner
The preferable safety mechanism depends heavily on individual preference and shooting style. For those who favor a quick, straightforward firing process without additional steps, the Springfield Hellcat Pro takes the edge.
Its lack of an external safety streamlines the shooting process, contrasting with the Equalizer’s back strap safety, which introduces an additional action before firing.
3. Sight Systems
Springfield Hellcat Pro
The Hellcat Pro is equipped with a unique sight system featuring a U-shaped rear notch and a tritium night sight on the front.
This configuration proved advantageous in low-light conditions during my testing. However, it requires a period of adjustment, particularly for shooters accustomed to standard three-dot sights. The tritium front sight enhances visibility in darker environments, an essential feature for various shooting conditions.
S&W Equalizer
In contrast, the Equalizer employs the more conventional three-dot iron sights, known for their intuitiveness and ease of use.
These sights are familiar to most shooters and allow for rapid target acquisition. My field experience with the Equalizer reinforced the comfort and familiarity these sights offer, particularly for those accustomed to this traditional sighting system.
Winner
The decision between these two sighting systems depends largely on the shooter’s needs and experience. The Hellcat Pro’s night sight and unique rear notch offer advantages in specific conditions, particularly low light.
However, for general ease of use and familiarity, the S&W Equalizer’s classic three-dot system is more approachable, making it the preferred choice for shooters who value traditional, straightforward sighting.
4. Grip Comfort and Design
Springfield Hellcat Pro
The grip of the Springfield Hellcat Pro is designed for comfort and ease of hold.
In my field tests, I found the grip texture to be sufficiently grippy without being overly aggressive. It provides a secure feel, especially during rapid firing, without causing discomfort.
S&W Equalizer
The S&W Equalizer’s grip is noticeably more aggressive. This extra texture can be advantageous for a firmer grip, particularly in wet conditions.
However, during extended shooting sessions, I noticed it could be a bit harsh on the hands, which might not suit all shooters.
Winner
For overall comfort and usability, especially over long periods, the Springfield Hellcat Pro outshines the Equalizer. Its balance between grip security and comfort gives it a slight edge, especially for those who might find the Equalizer’s aggressive texture a bit too much.
Pros & Cons: Springfield Hellcat Pro
Pros
- Comfortable grip design.
- Tritium night sight for low-light conditions.
- Reliable and consistent shooting performance.
Cons
- Slide can be difficult to rack for some shooters.
Pros & Cons: S&W Equalizer
Pros
- Easy-to-rack slide with EZ technology.
- Aggressive grip texture for a secure hold.
- Back strap safety for added security.
Cons
- The grip may be too aggressive for some shooters.
Similarities Between Springfield Hellcat Pro & S&W Equalizer
- Both chambered in 9mm Luger.
- Polymer frame construction.
- Optics-ready design.
- Presence of a loaded chamber indicator.
- Rail for attaching accessories like flashlights or lasers.
- Comparable in size and weight.
Differences Between Springfield Hellcat Pro & S&W Equalizer
- Hellcat Pro has a tritium night front sight; Equalizer uses traditional three-dot iron sights.
- Equalizer incorporates easy-to-rack slide technology; Hellcat Pro’s slide requires more strength.
- Hellcat Pro lacks an external safety; Equalizer features a back strap safety.
- Equalizer’s grip texture is more aggressive compared to Hellcat Pro’s.
- Hellcat Pro’s U-shaped rear notch sight is unique compared to Equalizer’s traditional sight.
Final Verdict
After thoroughly testing both the Springfield Hellcat Pro and the S&W Equalizer, it’s clear that each gun has its unique strengths and caters to different preferences.
However, in most of the comparisons, the S&W Equalizer emerged as the winner for me. The Equalizer’s user-friendly features, particularly its ‘EZ’ technology for easy racking and the additional safety mechanism, make it a more accessible and versatile choice.
FAQ’s
Is Springfield Hellcat better than Glock?
Comparing the Springfield Hellcat to the Glock, the Hellcat offers higher standard capacity and more options for magazine capacity, which gives it an advantage in terms of ammunition capacity and versatility.
Which is better, Hellcat or Hellcat Pro?
The Hellcat Pro, with its longer sight radius, generally offers higher accuracy compared to the standard Hellcat. The longer sight radius aids in more precise aim alignment.
Is the S&W Equalizer easy-to-rack?
Yes, the S&W Equalizer features easy-to-rack technology, making it user-friendly and accessible, especially for those with limited hand strength or dexterity.
What ammo is best for S&W Equalizer?
Winchester ammunition, including the FMJ loads and 115-grain Silvertip, has proven to be reliable and accurate in the Equalizer, with consistent feeding and ejection.
What is the difference between S&W Equalizer and Shield?
The main difference lies in the trigger design. The Equalizer has a curved trigger without an integrated safety, while the Shield Plus features a flatter trigger with a wide, integrated safety. The Shield Plus also has a more tactile and audible reset compared to the shorter reset of the Equalizer.
