I’m a professional shooter, and I’ve had the unique opportunity to test out two popular firearms in the field: the SIG P365XL Vs SIG P365.
I aim to figure out which stands out as the winner in real-world scenarios. I’ll share my firsthand experience in this article, breaking down each gun’s specs and performance.
| Feature | SIG P365XL | SIG P365 |
| Barrel Length | 3.7 inches | 3.1 inches |
| Overall Length | 6.6 inches | 5.8 inches |
| Overall Height | 4.8 inches | 4.3 inches |
| Weight | 20.7 ounces (with empty magazine) | 17.8 ounces (with empty magazine) |
| Capacity | 12+1 rounds in 9mm | 10+1 (standard), 12 with ext. mag |
SIG P365XL
The SIG P365XL, a versatile and compact firearm, offers an impressive blend of power and
size.
Specs
- Capacity: 12+1 rounds in 9mm
- Barrel Length: 3.7 inches
- Overall Width: 1.1 inches
- Overall Length: 6.6 inches
- Overall Height: 4.8 inches
- Sights: Optic-ready, comes with iron night sights
- Weight: 20.7 ounces (with empty magazine)
SIG P365
The SIG P365, known for its ultra-compact design, is a top choice for concealed carry enthusiasts.
Specs
- Caliber: 9mm
- Length: 5.8 inches
- Height: 4.3 inches (with flush magazine)
- Width: 1 inch
- Barrel Length: 3.1 inches
- Trigger Pull: Approximately 6 lbs
- Sights: XRAY3 Day/Night Sights (3-dot)
- Weight: 17.8 ounces (with empty magazine)
- Slide Material: Stainless Steel with Nitron finish
- Capacity: 10+1 (standard), 12 rounds with extended magazine
Features Comparison: SIG P365XL VS SIG P365
1. Ergonomics and Grip
SIG P365XL
The P365XL stands out with its ergonomically designed longer grip. This design suits shooters with larger hands, offering a more natural and comfortable hold.
The extended grip ensures better control, particularly during rapid firing sequences. The grip’s texture is thoughtfully crafted to be grippy, aiding in a secure grip without being overly aggressive, thus preventing discomfort during prolonged use.
SIG P365
In contrast, the P365’s shorter grip is tailored for smaller hands or those prioritizing maximum concealability. While excellent for discreet carry, this design choice may pose a challenge in managing recoil for individuals with larger hands.
Despite its compact size, the grip maintains a solid and comfortable hold, thanks to the consistent texture similar to that of the P365XL.
Winner
The SIG P365XL wins in ergonomics, catering to a broader range of hand sizes and offering superior control and comfort.
Its longer grip is a significant advantage for extended shooting sessions, providing a more secure and balanced feel than the more compact P365.
2. Concealability
SIG P365XL
While the P365XL is compact, its slightly larger size compared to the P365 can be a bit more challenging to conceal, particularly for individuals with smaller body frames.
Its extended barrel and grip length require thoughtful clothing choices to ensure effective concealment. Despite these considerations, the P365XL remains a viable option for concealed carry, blending compactness with enhanced capacity.
SIG P365
The P365 excels in concealability thanks to its ultra-compact design. Ideal for concealed carry, it fits comfortably in various holster styles and integrates seamlessly into different clothing options.
Winner
The SIG P365 emerges as the superior choice for concealability. Its smaller frame and shorter grip provide a distinct advantage in being easier to conceal for everyday carry.
The P365’s design is especially beneficial for those seeking a highly concealable firearm without compromising performance.
3. Slide Operation
SIG P365XL
The slide operation on the P365XL is impressively smooth, making it easy for shooters to rack the slide efficiently. The added length on the slide enhances the overall grip and increases safety and ease of operation.
The well-placed and effective serrations contribute to a secure grip, even under adverse conditions such as wet weather, ensuring reliable performance.
SIG P365
Although smaller, the SIG P365’s slide is engineered to offer ease of operation. The serrations on the slide are strategically placed to provide adequate grip, although the shorter length may require more precise handling, particularly for those with larger hands.
Despite its compact size, the slide operates smoothly and reliably, maintaining the high standards set by the SIG series.
Winner
In terms of slide operation, the SIG P365XL takes a slight lead. Its longer slide offers additional gripping surface, which can be a significant advantage in stressful situations or for shooters with larger hands.
This feature enhances the overall safety and usability of the P365XL, making it a preferable choice compared to the more compact slide of the P365.
4. Trigger Performance
SIG P365XL
The P365XL’s trigger offers a smooth, consistent pull with a clean break, enhancing shooting accuracy and control.
Its flat trigger shoe is comfortable, providing a modern feel and facilitating an easy trigger pull. This design aids in precise shooting, especially during rapid fire situations, ensuring a better overall shooting experience.
SIG P365
The P365 features a slightly curved trigger shoe, which may appeal to traditionalists. The trigger pull is similar to the P365XL, offering a consistent and smooth action.
However, the curved design might affect the perception of the pull, slightly altering the shooting experience compared to its XL counterpart.
Winner
The SIG P365XL edges out slightly in trigger performance. Its flat trigger shoe provides a more contemporary feel and potentially better control, especially for those accustomed to modern firearm designs, compared to the more traditional curved trigger of the P365.
Pros & Cons of SIG P365XL
Pros
- Longer grip for better control
- Optic-ready design
- Smooth trigger pull
- Good balance and weight
Cons
- Heavier than the P365
Pros & Cons of SIG P365
Pros
- Excellent concealability due to compact size
- Lighter weight
- Good trigger performance
- Versatile for various carrying methods
Cons
- Limited capacity compared to P365XL
Similarities Between SIG P365XL & SIG P365
- Both chambered in 9mm
- Stainless Steel, Nitron finished slides
- Feature XRAY3 Day/Night Sights
- Offered with and without thumb safety
- Compatible magazine body designs
- Equipped with serrations for better slide grip
Differences Between SIG P365XL & SIG P365
- P365XL has a longer barrel (3.7” vs 3.1”)
- P365XL is taller and longer overall
- P365 is lighter in weight (17.8oz vs 20.7oz)
- P365 has a shorter grip for better concealability
- P365XL offers two extra rounds in capacity
- P365XL is optic-ready, unlike the P365
Final Verdict
After thorough testing and consideration, I’ve reached a conclusion in the SIG P365XL vs SIG P365 debate. While both guns exhibit remarkable qualities, one has edged out as my preferred choice: the SIG P365XL.
This decision isn’t based on a single overwhelming feature but on how its overall attributes align with what I value most in a firearm; a balance of comfort, control, and versatility.
The SIG P365XL offers a seamless blend of these elements, making it a more adaptable option for various shooting scenarios.
FAQ’s
What is the difference between a SIG P365 and a SIG P365XL?
The main difference is in grip length; the SIG P365XL has a longer grip by just under a half-inch, providing two extra rounds with a flush fit magazine.
Is SIG P365 better than Glock 43?
The SIG P365 has a slightly better trigger feel compared to the Glock 43, offering a bit more accuracy and precision, but the choice depends on personal preference and shooting style.
Why is the P365 considered the best?
The Sig P365 is praised for its excellent balance of capacity, manageability, and modularity, making it a highly versatile and reliable choice for concealed carry.
What size is the P365 XL?
The P365 XL features a barrel length of 3.7 inches, an overall length of 6.6 inches, a width of 1.1 inches, and a height of 4.8 inches.
Should I get P365X or P365XL?
The choice between P365X and P365XL depends on your preference for sight radius and concealability; the P365XL offers a longer barrel and sight radius, while the P365X is more compact.
