I’m here to share my hands-on experience with two impressive guns: the SIG P320 X-5 Legion Vs Glock 34.
As a professional shooter, I’ve had the unique opportunity to test these firearms in real-world conditions, analyzing every aspect to determine which truly stands out.
In this article, I will dive into the details of each gun, examining their specs and performance.
| Specification | SIG P320 X-5 Legion | Glock 43 |
| Caliber | 9mm Luger | 9mm Luger |
| Magazine Capacity | 17 rounds | 6 rounds |
| Length | 8.46 inches | 6.26 inches |
| Width | 1.38 inches | 1.06 inches |
| Height | 5.91 inches | 4.25 inches |
| Action | Single Action (SA) | Striker-fired |
| Total Weight (incl. Magazine) | 43.5 ounces | 17.95 ounces |
Overview: SIG P320 X-5 Legion
The SIG P320 X-5 Legion is a powerhouse in competitive shooting, renowned for its precision and reliability.
Specs
- Caliber: 9mm Luger
- Magazine Capacity: 17 rounds
- Length: 8.46 inches
- Width: 1.38 inches
- Height: 5.91 inches
- Slide Material: Steel
- Safety Feature: Trigger-controlled firing pin safety
- Action: Single Action (SA)
- Total Weight (including Magazine): 43.5 ounces
Overview: Glock 43
Compact and reliable, the Glock 43 is a popular choice for concealed carry and personal defense.
Specs
- Caliber: 9mm Luger
- Magazine Capacity: 6 rounds
- Length: 6.26 inches
- Width: 1.06 inches
- Height: 4.25 inches
- Slide Material: Steel
- Safety Feature: Integrated trigger safety
- Action: Striker-fired
- Total Weight (including Magazine): 17.95 ounces
Features Comparison: SIG P320 X-5 Legion VS Glock 43
1. Ergonomics and Handling
SIG P320 X-5 Legion
The SIG P320 X-5 Legion’s substantial heft and ergonomic design stand out. Weighing in at 43.5 ounces with the magazine provides a reassuringly robust grip.
Its substantial weight, paired with a meticulously designed grip, offers a stable and comfortable hold, reducing fatigue during extended shooting sessions.
The trigger-controlled firing pin safety and single-action system deliver a consistent, smooth shooting experience, enhancing control and accuracy. This weight, while substantial, is a significant asset in managing recoil, making the SIG a stable platform for precise, controlled shooting in competitive scenarios.
Glock 43
The Glock 43, in stark contrast, offers a much lighter and more compact experience, weighing just 17.95 ounces with its magazine. This lightweight design makes it exceptionally well-suited for concealed carry and quick, responsive handling.
Its integrated trigger safety and striker-fired action are designed with reliability and ease of use in mind, especially critical in high-pressure scenarios where quick and decisive action is necessary.
The compact size and reduced weight make the Glock 43 an ideal choice for everyday carry, providing comfort without sacrificing performance.
Winner
When comparing the two, the SIG P320 X-5 Legion excels in stability and precision, which is particularly beneficial in the realm of competition shooting.
In contrast, the Glock 43 shines in scenarios that demand quick handling and ease of carry, such as personal defense and concealed carry. The choice between the two boils down to specific needs: the robust and precise SIG for competition and the agile and quick-handling Glock for everyday carry.
2. Weight and Comfort
SIG P320 X-5 Legion
The Legion’s considerable weight is both an advantage and a potential drawback. Its heft provides stability and aids significantly in recoil management, enabling more control and faster follow-up shots, a critical advantage in competitive shooting.
However, this same weight might be cumbersome for some users, particularly over prolonged periods or in situations where mobility is key.
Despite this, the SIG’s design focuses on comfort, with a grip and balance that are thoughtfully tailored to fit the hand snugly, reducing strain and enhancing control during long shooting sessions.
Glock 43
The Glock 43’s standout feature is its lightweight and compact design. Weighing significantly less than the SIG, it offers unparalleled comfort for extended carry, especially for users who prefer discretion and ease of movement.
This comfort does not come at the expense of performance, as the Glock 43 maintains a commendable balance between weight and functionality. The lightweight nature of the Glock 43 makes it a perfect fit for users who require a firearm that is easy to carry throughout the day without causing fatigue or discomfort.
Winner
When considering weight and comfort for extended use, the Glock 43 outperforms the SIG P320 X-5 Legion. Its lightweight and compact design provides unmatched comfort and ease, ideal for all-day carry and rapid maneuverability.
In contrast, the SIG’s heavier build, while offering stability and precision, may be better suited for controlled environments where its weight is an advantage rather than a hindrance.
3. Recoil Management
SIG P320 X-5 Legion
The SIG P320 X-5 Legion’s weight plays a crucial role in its superior recoil management. The additional mass of the firearm effectively absorbs much of the recoil, resulting in a smoother shooting experience with significantly less perceived recoil.
This is especially beneficial in competitive shooting environments where quick, accurate follow-up shots are essential.
The reduced recoil facilitates better control over the firearm, enabling the shooter to maintain focus and precision, which is crucial for hitting targets consistently in rapid succession.
Glock 43
In comparison, the Glock 43, due to its lighter frame, experiences more pronounced recoil. However, this is skillfully mitigated by its ergonomic design and efficient mechanical construction.
The manageable recoil, despite the lighter frame, makes the Glock 43 a viable option for a wide range of shooters, including those with less experience.
The trade-off for its compact and lightweight design is a slightly more noticeable recoil, which is generally considered an acceptable compromise given its advantages in portability and ease of handling.
Winner
In the realm of recoil management, the SIG P320 X-5 Legion stands out as the superior choice compared to the Glock 43. Its heavier frame and thoughtful design significantly reduce felt recoil, offering a more controlled and comfortable shooting experience.
This makes the SIG particularly suitable for situations where rapid, precise follow-up shots are necessary, such as in competitive shooting sports, where every shot counts and control is paramount.
4. Trigger Mechanism
SIG P320 X-5 Legion
The SIG boasts a flat-faced trigger, enhancing the shooter’s feel and control. This design contributes to a more consistent finger placement and a smoother pull, which is crucial for precision shots. The lighter trigger pull aids in maintaining accuracy, especially under rapid-fire conditions.
Glock 43
The Glock 43’s trigger system is designed for reliability and simplicity. It features a standard curved trigger with a firm pull, contributing to its safe handling, especially in high-stress situations. The reset is quick and distinct, allowing for efficient follow-up shots.
Winner
Compared to the Glock 43, the SIG P320 X-5 Legion excels with its trigger mechanism. The flat-faced, lighter trigger allows for more precise control and easier operation, especially in competitive scenarios where accuracy and speed are paramount.
Pros & Cons: SIG P320 X-5 Legion
Pros
- Excellent recoil control.
- Superior accuracy.
- Modular design.
- Comfortable ergonomics.
Cons
- Higher cost.
- Limited concealability.
Pros & Cons: Glock 43
Pros
- Lightweight and compact.
- Ideal for concealed carry.
- Simple and reliable operation.
- More affordable.
Cons
- Higher recoil compared to SIG.
Similarities Between SIG P320 X-5 Legion & Glock 43
- Both are chambered in 9mm Luger.
- Each features a steel slide.
- Both are renowned for their reliability.
- Each has a unique safety mechanism.
- Both are popular among enthusiasts and professionals.
Differences Between SIG P320 X-5 Legion & Glock 43
- SIG is heavier and bulkier compared to the compact Glock.
- SIG has a single-action trigger, while Glock features a striker-fired system.
- SIG offers more customization options.
- Glock is more affordable and has a wider range of aftermarket parts.
- SIG is more focused on competitive shooting, whereas Glock is on concealed carry.
- Glock is more versatile for various applications; SIG excels in precision.
Final Verdict
After extensive testing and analysis of both the SIG P320 X-5 Legion and the Glock 43, I’ve reached a conclusion that is tailored to my preferences and shooting style.
When it comes to choosing a winner, it’s essential to consider the specific needs and scenarios in which the firearm will be used. For me, the SIG P320 X-5 Legion emerges as the standout choice, primarily due to its exceptional performance in competitive shooting environments.
Its precision, superior recoil control, and ergonomic design make it an ideal choice for situations where accuracy and stability are paramount.
FAQ’s
Is Sig P320 better than Glock?
Both the Sig P320 and Glock are excellent firearms, each excelling in different areas. The best choice depends on the shooter’s comfort and intended use.
Why choose Sig over Glock?
Choosing a Sig sauer over a Glock might be preferred for its better recoil handling with higher calibers and modularity, whereas Glock is favored for its lighter weight and concealability.
Why Glock 34 is the best?
The Glock 34 is designed for accuracy with its extended barrel and longer sight distance, making it ideal for target engagement.
Is a Glock 34 good for home defense?
Yes, the Glock 34, with its 9mm caliber, is suitable for home defense and recreational shooting, offering reliable performance and manageable recoil.
