I’ve tested two popular guns in the field: the SIG P238 Vs Springfield 911.
This article will dive deep into each model, looking at its specs and performance to see which one comes out on top. I’m here to share my experience and help you determine which might be your next favorite.
| Feature | SIG P238 | Springfield 911 |
| Weight | 15.2 oz | 12.6 oz |
| Barrel Length | 2.7 inches | 2.7 inches |
| Overall Length | 5.5 inches | 5.5 inches |
| Caliber | .380 ACP | .380 ACP |
| Magazine Capacity | 6+1, 7+1 | 6+1, 7+1 |
| Sights | SIG NITE sights | Pro-Glo Tritium/Luminescent Night Sights |
Overview of SIG P238
The SIG P238 is a compact gem. It’s a small-scale version of the classic 1911, but don’t let its size fool you; this little guy packs a punch!
Specs
- Capacity: 7+1 rounds
- Caliber: .380 Auto
- Sights: Siglite
- Overall Length: 5.5 inches
- Barrel Length: 2.7 inches
- Height: 3.9 inches
- Weight: 15.2 ounces
Overview of Springfield 911
Springfield 911 is a name that evokes a sense of reliability. Like the SIG, it’s a mini 1911 but with its own unique flair.
Specs
- Chambering: .380 ACP
- Barrel: 2.7 inches, 416R Stainless Steel
- Weight: 12.6 ounces (unloaded)
- Overall Length: 5.5 inches
- Sights: Pro-Glo Tritium/Luminescent Night Sights
- Grips: G10
- Action: Single action
- Finish: Stainless
- Capacity: 6+1, 7+1 with extended magazine
Features Comparison: SIG P238 vs Springfield 911
1. Ergonomics and Handling
SIG P238
The P238 feels great in hand. The grip, though short, is enhanced by the option of a pinky extension on the 7-round mag. The Hogue wrap-around grips on many models are a real comfort plus. It’s easy to operate even for those with larger hands, like mine.
The manual safety is intuitive and well-placed, making operating a breeze.
Springfield 911
Springfield’s 911 follows closely with its ergonomic design. The built-in ambidextrous safety is a standout feature. The G10 grips are thin yet provide a solid hold.
However, the safety, though well-designed, might feel a tad small for some users. It’s very much a personal preference thing.
Winner
Comparing the two, the SIG P238 edges out slightly. Its ergonomic design feels a bit more refined, especially the safety mechanism.
The Springfield 911 is not far behind, but for those who appreciate a more substantial safety lever, the P238 takes the cake.
2. Sights and Accuracy
SIG P238
The SIG P238 comes equipped with SIG NITE sights. These full-sized sights are a treat, especially in low-light conditions.
They’re easy to align, offering a clear sight picture that aids in accuracy, even at longer distances for such a small pistol.
Springfield 911
The Springfield 911 doesn’t lag with its Pro-Glo Tritium/Luminescent Night Sights. The brightly colored inserts are a great addition for daytime use.
The sight picture is clear, and aligning them is just as easy as with the P238.
Winner
In the sights and accuracy department, the Springfield 911 gets a slight edge thanks to its day/night versatility.
The bright inserts in the 911’s sights make it a tad more user-friendly in various lighting conditions compared to the P238.
3. Concealability and Carry Comfort
SIG P238
The SIG P238, with its compact design, is a dream to conceal. It fits neatly into most holsters and is comfortable for all-day carry.
Its slightly heavier weight compared to the 911 isn’t much of a deterrent in terms of carry comfort.
Springfield 911
The 911’s lighter frame makes it an excellent choice for those who prioritize weight in their concealed carry.
It’s thin, lightweight, and with its sleek design, it’s barely noticeable when carried.
Winner
For concealability and carry comfort, it’s a close call, but the Springfield 911 takes the lead. Its lighter weight gives it a slight advantage for those who carry it all day and are sensitive to the extra ounces.
The SIG P238, though slightly heavier, is still a fantastic option, but for ultimate ease of carry, the 911 edges out.
4. Trigger Quality
SIG P238
The trigger on the SIG P238 is a standout feature. It’s a metal single-action trigger that offers a smooth, crisp pull with minimal grit.
The break is clean, and the reset is quick, allowing for rapid follow-up shots. This quality contributes significantly to the gun’s overall accuracy and shooting experience, especially for a pocket-sized pistol.
Springfield 911
Springfield’s 911 also features a single-action trigger but with a distinct G10 material. While it provides a clean and crisp pull, the feel of the polymer material might not be as smooth as the metal on the P238.
It’s still an excellent trigger, but the difference in materials is noticeable.
Winner
When it comes to trigger quality, the SIG P238 edges out slightly. The metal trigger provides a more refined feel compared to the polymer G10 trigger of the 911.
Both are excellent, but the P238’s trigger feels a tad more polished and comfortable to use.
5. Finish and Aesthetic Appeal
SIG P238
The SIG P238 boasts an impressive array of finish options. From classic black and stainless to more exotic choices like FDE, OD Green, and chrome, the P238 offers something for every taste.
The finishes are evenly applied and contribute to the gun’s overall handsome appearance.
Springfield 911
The Springfield 911, while not as varied in finish options as the P238 still offers a sleek and appealing look. Available in all-black or a stainless and black finish, the 911 exudes a modern and professional aesthetic.
The finish is durable and maintains its appearance even with regular use.
Winner
In terms of finish and aesthetic appeal, the SIG P238 takes the lead. Its wider range of finish options allows for more personalization, making it appealing to a broader range of users who value both function and form in their firearm.
Pros & Cons of SIG P238
Pros
- Excellent ergonomics with a comfortable grip.
- Wide variety of finishes for personalization.
- Reliable performance with minimal malfunctions.
- Superior trigger quality – smooth and crisp.
- Slightly heavier, aiding in stability when shooting.
Cons
- Heavier than Springfield 911 could be a con for some users.
Pros & Cons of Springfield 911
Pros
- Lighter weight, making it easier to carry.
- Ambidextrous safety feature.
- Innovative Pro-Glo Tritium/Luminescent Night Sights.
- Sleek and modern aesthetic.
- G10 grip material offering a solid hold.
Cons
- G10 trigger might not feel as smooth as SIG’s metal trigger.
Similarities Between SIG P238 & Springfield 911
- Both are chambered in .380 ACP.
- Similar overall length: 5.5 inches.
- Barrel length is identical at 2.7 inches.
- Designed based on the 1911 platform.
- Single Action Only (SAO) guns.
- Both offer models with night sights.
- Similar magazine capacity options (6+1, 7+1).
- Comparable in height, just under 4 inches.
- Marketed primarily for concealed carry.
Differences Between SIG P238 & Springfield 911
- SIG P238 is slightly heavier (15.2 oz) compared to Springfield 911 (12.6 oz).
- SIG P238 offers a wider variety of finishes.
- Springfield 911 uses G10 for its trigger, SIG P238 utilizes metal.
- Springfield 911 sights have brightly colored plastic inserts for daytime use.
- SIG P238’s metal frame is different from the 911’s aluminum frame.
- SIG P238 has a more established reputation and a wider accessory market.
Final Verdict
After thoroughly testing both the SIG P238 and the Springfield 911, it’s time to conclude which of these exceptional firearms takes the crown. It’s a tough call, as both guns exhibit remarkable qualities in their respective domains.
However, my choice for the winner is the SIG P238. Why the SIG P238? This decision comes down to a blend of reliability, superior ergonomics, and a more refined shooting experience.
In summary, for those looking for a compact, reliable, and aesthetically pleasing firearm with top-notch ergonomics and shooting comfort, the SIG P238 emerges as my top choice.
FAQ’s
What is the difference between Sig and Springfield 911?
The SIG P238 is slightly heavier and offers more finish options than the Springfield 911. The 911 has a standard ambidextrous safety and a G10 trigger, while the P238 has a metal trigger and varying safety designs.
Is SIG Sauer P238 good for self-defense?
Yes, the SIG Sauer P238 is suitable for self-defense, featuring a single-action mechanism that requires a cocked hammer and safety engagement, necessitating training for effective use in emergencies.
Is the Sig Sauer P238 a good gun to conceal carry?
Absolutely, the SIG Sauer P238 is excellent for concealed carry due to its compact size, reliable performance, and comfortable ergonomics.
Is a SIG P238 a 1911?
The SIG P238 is modeled after the M1911, particularly the Colt Mustang, with a similar design but in a smaller, .380 ACP caliber format.
How accurate is the SIG P238?
The SIG P238 is highly accurate for an ultra-compact gun, outperforming many larger pistols, partly due to its high-quality sights.
