I will dive into a head-to-head comparison of two popular SIG models: The Sig P238 Vs Sig P365.
As someone who’s spent considerable time testing these guns in various scenarios, I’m here to share my hands-on experience.
I’ll break down each gun’s features, handling, and overall performance.
So, whether you’re a seasoned shooter or just getting started, this article aims to help you understand the details of these two models and maybe even decide which one’s the best fit for you.
| Feature | SIG P238 | SIG P365 |
| Caliber | .380 ACP | 9mm |
| Capacity | 6+1, extendable to 7+1 | 10+1 |
| Trigger Type | SAO (Single Action Only) | Striker-fired |
| Overall Length | 5.5 inches | 5.8 inches |
| Barrel Length | 2.7 inches | 3.1 inches |
| Height | 3.9 inches | 4.3 inches |
| Weight (Unloaded) | 15.2 ounces | 22 ounces |
| Sights | Siglite night sights | X-RAY3 Day/Night Sights |
SIG P238
The SIG P238 is known for its compact design and reliable performance, making it a top pick for concealed carry enthusiasts.
Specs
- Capacity: 6+1, extendable to 7+1 rounds
- Caliber: .380 Auto
- Sights: Siglite night sights
- Overall Length: 5.5 inches
- Barrel Length: 2.7 inches
- Height: 3.9 inches
- Width: 1.1 inches
- Weight: 15.2 ounces (unloaded)
SIG P365
The SIG P365 stands out for its higher capacity and solid build, catering to those who prioritize firepower and durability.
Specs
- Capacity: 10+1 rounds
- Caliber: 9mm
- Barrel: 3.1 inches, carbon steel
- Overall Length: 5.8 inches
- Height: 4.3 inches
- Width: 1.06 inches
- Weight: 22 ounces (with empty magazine)
- Frame: Stainless steel
- Slide: Stainless steel, Nitron finish
- Grip: Polymer module with stipple texture
- Sights: X-RAY3 Day/Night Sights
- Trigger: Standard, 6 pounds
Features Comparison: SIG P238 vs SIG P365
1. Trigger Mechanism
SIG P238 Trigger
The trigger on the SIG P238 truly impressed me with its finesse. As a Single Action Only (SAO) mechanism, it provides a notably clean and crisp break.
During my field tests, each pull felt exceptionally light and smooth, offering precision that enhanced my shooting accuracy. The tactile feedback was consistent, allowing me to easily anticipate the shot.
This level of control is a significant advantage for shooters who value a traditional, predictable trigger experience.
SIG P365 Trigger
In contrast, the SIG P365 features a striker-fired trigger, which brought a different feel to my shooting experience. This system is appreciated for its straightforward, reliable nature.
The trigger pull on the P365 is somewhat heavier than the P238, yet it provides a smooth, consistent action.
During testing, I noticed the lack of ‘creep’ before the break, which some shooters might find advantageous.
The reset is short and distinct, facilitating rapid follow-up shots. This trigger’s design suits those prioritizing a straightforward, consistent trigger pull over the traditional single-action feel.
Winner
Trigger Mechanism Deciding the winner between these two triggers depends largely on personal preference and shooting style.
The SIG P238’s SAO trigger is superb for those who cherish a light, crisp trigger pull, offering precision and control, especially in deliberate shooting scenarios.
However, the SIG P365’s striker-fired trigger excels in providing a consistent, reliable pull that’s ideal for quick, successive shots. Personally, I lean towards the P238 for its refined trigger mechanism.
2. Ergonomics and Handling
SIG P238
Ergonomics The SIG P238 stands out with its exceptional ergonomics. In my hand, it feels like a natural extension of my grip.
Its smaller frame, combined with the well-designed grip contours, provides a comfortable, secure hold, which is especially important for a compact firearm.
During testing, maneuvering the P238 was a breeze, even in rapid-fire scenarios. The ease of handling is a significant plus for shooters who prioritize comfort and control in a compact handgun.
SIG P365
Ergonomics The SIG P365, on the other hand, offers a slightly different ergonomic experience. Its larger capacity results in a slightly larger grip, which might suit shooters with bigger hands.
The grip texture is effective, ensuring the gun stays firmly in hand under various conditions. However, during my field tests, I noticed the weight and dimensions of the P365 demand a bit more adjustment, especially for prolonged shooting sessions.
Winner
Ergonomics and Handling When it comes to ergonomics and handling, the SIG P238 edges out over the P365.
The P238’s design focuses on a compact, comfortable grip that enhances control and stability, making it exceptionally easy to handle, especially for a smaller firearm.
3. Sight System
SIG P238
Sight System The SIG P238 comes equipped with Siglite night sights, which I found to be quite effective during my testing.
The sights are clear and allow for quick target acquisition, even in low-light conditions. The contrast between the sights and targets is sharp, making it easier to focus and align the sights accurately.
The compact size of the P238 doesn’t compromise the effectiveness of these sights, providing a reliable aiming solution that complements the gun’s overall design. In various lighting conditions, these sights maintained their clarity and ease of use, enhancing the shooting experience.
SIG P365
Sight System The SIG P365 sports the X-RAY3 Day/Night Sights, which are a significant step up in terms of visibility and performance.
During my field tests, these sights proved to be highly efficient in both daylight and low-light scenarios. The tritium inserts offer excellent visibility, and the three-dot setup is intuitive and quick to align.
Winner
Sight System Comparing the sight systems, the SIG P365 takes the lead with its X-RAY3 Day/Night Sights.
While the Siglite sights on the P238 are effective and reliable, the X-RAY3 sights on the P365 offer superior visibility and ease of target acquisition, especially in varied lighting conditions.
4. Overall Concealability
SIG P238
Concealability The SIG P238 excels in concealability, thanks to its compact dimensions. When I carried it, its smaller frame and lighter weight made it almost unnoticeable, perfect for deep concealment.
The smooth edges and slim profile ensured there were no noticeable imprints through my clothing. In various carry positions, the P238 remained comfortable and discreet, an essential factor for concealed carry.
The gun’s design also allowed for a quick, unobstructed draw, which is crucial in self-defense situations. Overall, its size and design make it an excellent choice for those prioritizing concealability in a firearm.
SIG P365
Concealability The SIG P365, while slightly larger, still offers impressive concealability. During my tests, I found it to be a bit more noticeable when carried, primarily due to its increased weight and size.
However, it’s still highly manageable for everyday carry. The P365 strikes a balance between increased capacity and maintaining a relatively compact form.
Winner
Overall Concealability Comparing the overall concealability, the SIG P238 takes the lead over the P365. Its smaller size, lighter weight, and sleek design, compared to the P365, make it more conducive to various concealed carry scenarios.
The P238’s profile allows for more discreet carry without compromising ease of access. While the P365 is still a good option for concealed carry, the P238’s design specifically caters to deep concealment needs.
Pros & Cons: SIG P238
Pros
- Compact and lightweight, it is ideal for concealed carry.
- SAO trigger provides a crisp and predictable pull.
- Comfortable ergonomics, especially for smaller hands.
- Easy to handle and maneuver.
- Excellent concealability with minimal imprinting.
Cons
- SAO trigger require manual cocking, which may not suit all users.
Pros & Cons: SIG P365
Pros
- Higher capacity than many compact pistols.
- Striker-fired trigger offers consistent pull.
- Good balance between size and firepower.
- X-RAY3 sights enhance target acquisition.
- Robust build quality suitable for everyday carry.
Cons
- Striker-fired system may not appeal to traditionalists.
Similarities Between SIG P238 & SIG P365
- Both are designed for concealed carry.
- Stainless steel construction ensures durability.
- Both models offer night sight options.
- Each has a polymer grip for comfort and control.
- Manufactured by the reputable SIG SAUER brand.
Differences Between SIG P238 & SIG P365
- P238 is SAO, while P365 is striker-fired.
- P238 is chambered in .380 Auto, P365 in 9mm.
- P238 is lighter and smaller than the P365.
- P238 has a traditional manual safety, P365 does not.
- P365 offers a higher standard capacity than the P238.
- P365’s trigger pull is heavier compared to P238’s.
- P238’s ergonomics are more suited for smaller hands.
- P365 has X-RAY3 sights, compared to P238’s Siglite.
Final Verdict
As a shooter who has thoroughly tested both the SIG P238 and the SIG P365, I’ve come to a conclusion about these two remarkable firearms. Each gun has its unique strengths, tailored to different user needs and preferences.
After comparing their features, ergonomics, sight systems, and overall concealability, I’ve found that one model stands out for me personally, the SIG P238.
It’s the blend of comfort, precision, and specific functionalities that ultimately tips the scales.
FAQ’s
Why is Sig P365 so popular?
The Sig P365 popularity stems from its impressive 10+1 or 12+1 capacity of 9mm in a compact, reliable, and highly shootable package, making it a standout in the carry gun market.
How accurate is the SIG P238?
The Sig P238 is renowned for its accuracy, often outperforming larger guns, thanks largely to its quality sights and well-engineered design.
Is the P365 still the best?
The Sig P365 continues to excel as an all-around concealed-carry pistol, known for its reliability, capacity, manageability, and modularity, maintaining its status as one of the market’s top choices.
Is Sig Sauer P238 double action?
The Sig Sauer P238 is a compact, single-action pistol, specifically designed for a .380 ACP caliber.
