I’m a professional marksman, and I’ve had the chance to get my hands on two popular pistols: the SIG P238 Vs Glock 42.
I’ll be sharing my field experience with these two guns, comparing their features, performance, and handling.
To help you figure out which one might be the best fit for your needs. So, let’s dive in and see how these two stack up.
| Feature | SIG P238 | Glock 42 |
| Caliber | .380 Auto | .380 Auto |
| Capacity | 6 or 7 rounds | 6+1 rounds |
| Sights | Siglite night sights | Standard Glock sights |
| Overall Length | 5.5 inches | 5.94 inches |
| Barrel Length | 2.7 inches | 3.25 inches |
| Height | 3.9 inches | 4.13 inches |
| Weight (Unloaded) | 15.2 ounces | 12.17 ounces |
SIG P238
The SIG P238 is a compact, semi-automatic pistol known for its reliability and precision. It’s a popular choice for concealed carry.
Specs
- Capacity: 7+1 rounds
- Caliber: .380 Auto
- Sights: Siglite night sights
- Overall Length: 5.5 inches
- Barrel Length: 2.7 inches
- Height: 3.9 inches
- Weight: 15.2 ounces
Glock 42
The Glock 42 is a lightweight, ultra-compact pistol that has gained a reputation for its ease of use and effective performance, especially for smaller hands.
Specs
- Capacity: 6+1 rounds
- Caliber: .380 Auto
- Sights: Standard Glock sights
- Overall Length: 5.94 inches
- Barrel Length: 3.25 inches
- Height: About 4.13 inches
- Weight (Unloaded): Around 12.17 ounces
- Weight (Loaded): 15.87 ounces
Features Comparison: SIG P238 vs Glock 42
1. Sight Visibility
SIG P238
The SIG P238 boasts Siglite night sights, offering excellent visibility in low-light conditions. These sights significantly enhanced my targeting at the range, especially in dimmer settings.
Their clarity and brightness provided a distinct advantage, allowing more accurate shots in challenging light scenarios.
Glock 42
The Glock 42 comes with standard Glock sights, which are functional but less impressive in low light. In daylight, they performed adequately, but as the evening progressed, their limitations became apparent.
The contrast and visibility weren’t as pronounced as I would have liked for precise targeting.
Winner
In the category of sight visibility, the SIG P238 clearly outshines the Glock 42,
particularly in low-light conditions.
The Siglite night sights on the P238 provide a superior sight picture, enhancing accuracy and shooter confidence, especially in dimmer environments. This makes the P238 a more versatile option for varying lighting conditions compared to the Glock 42.
2. Recoil and Handling
SIG P238
The SIG P238’s metal frame contributes to its snappier recoil. During rapid-fire tests, this increased recoil was noticeable and slightly affected my shot grouping.
However, its compact design fits comfortably in hand, offering a steady grip. This balance between size and recoil management is notable, especially for a metal-framed pistol.
Glock 42
The Glock 42, with its polymer frame, presents significantly less felt recoil. Its smoother handling was evident when firing sequences of shots.
This reduced recoil aids in maintaining better control and consistency, particularly in rapid-fire situations. For those sensitive to recoil or newer shooters, this can be a crucial factor in choosing a pistol.
Winner
When considering recoil and handling, the Glock 42 takes the lead over the SIG P238. Its lower recoil and steadier handling provide a more comfortable and controlled shooting experience.
This advantage is particularly valuable in situations requiring quick follow-up shots or for those who prioritize ease of handling. The Glock 42’s design caters well to a broader range of shooters, making it a more accessible choice in this aspect.
3. Ease of Maintenance
SIG P238
Maintaining the SIG P238 can be more challenging compared to other firearms. Disassembly and cleaning require a bit more effort and attention to detail. During my maintenance routine, I found it slightly more time-consuming, which might not be ideal for those who prefer quick and straightforward upkeep.
However, this doesn’t detract significantly from its overall performance but is a consideration for regular users.
Glock 42
The Glock 42 excels in ease of maintenance. Its design allows for quick disassembly, making cleaning and routine care simpler and more efficient.
This was particularly noticeable during my range sessions, where I could easily and swiftly maintain the firearm. For those who value minimal downtime and straightforward maintenance, the Glock 42 stands out as a practical choice.
Winner
In terms of maintenance ease, the Glock 42 is the definite winner. Its user-friendly design for quick disassembly and cleaning makes it a more appealing option for those who prioritize ease of upkeep.
This feature is especially beneficial for regular shooters or those new to firearm maintenance. The Glock 42’s simplicity in this regard gives it an edge over the SIG P238, making it a more convenient choice for routine care and maintenance.
4. Trigger Quality
SIG P238
The SIG P238 features a single-action trigger, known for its crispness and minimal take-up. During my field tests, this resulted in a more intuitive and responsive shooting experience. The trigger pull is light and consistent, which significantly contributed to my accuracy, especially in rapid-fire scenarios.
The quality of the trigger in the SIG P238 is a standout feature, providing a level of control and precision that’s appreciable in a compact firearm.
Glock 42
The Glock 42 features the brand’s typical Safe Action trigger system. It offers a consistent pull but with a slightly heavier and longer travel compared to the SIG P238.
In my tests, this meant a bit more effort in managing shots, especially when aiming for speed and precision simultaneously. The trigger is reliable and predictable, but it doesn’t quite offer the same level of refinement or responsiveness as seen in the SIG P238.
Winner
In terms of trigger quality, the SIG P238 excels compared to the Glock 42. Its single-action trigger provides a smoother, more responsive shooting experience.
This makes a noticeable difference in scenarios where rapid and precise shooting is required. The P238’s trigger enhances the overall shooting experience by offering a level of finesse and control that the Glock 42’s Safe Action trigger system doesn’t quite match.
Pros & Cons of SIG P238
Pros
- Siglite night sights for better low-light visibility.
- Crisp single-action trigger.
- Comfortable for pocket carry.
- Sig promotion offering free magazines.
- Compatible with Colt Mustang magazines.
Cons
- Heavier compared to similar models.
Pros & Cons of Glock 42
Pros
- Lower felt recoil, easier to handle.
- Easy to take down and clean.
- Consistent Safe Action trigger system.
- Lightweight and comfortable for various hand sizes.
Cons
- Larger size can be a problem for pocket carry.
Similarities Between SIG P238 & Glock 42
- Both are chambered in .380 Auto.
- Designed for concealed carry.
- Semi-automatic operation.
- Popular choices for personal defense.
- Both have a solid reputation for reliability.
Differences Between SIG P238 & Glock 42
- SIG P238 has a single-action trigger, and Glock 42 has a Safe Action trigger.
- SIG P238 offers Siglite night sights, and Glock 42 has standard Glock sights.
- Glock 42 has lower felt recoil and is easier to handle.
- SIG P238 has manual safety, Glock 42 does not.
- Glock 42 is larger and less suitable for pocket carry.
- SIG P238 compatible with Colt Mustang magazines; no similar feature in Glock 42.
- Price difference, with SIG P238 generally being more expensive.
Final Verdict
After extensively testing both the SIG P238 and the Glock 42, it’s time to draw a conclusion. Each pistol has its strengths, tailored to different preferences and needs.
However, based on most of the comparisons, one gun slightly edges out as my personal choice: the Glock 42.
Why the Glock 42? Its combination of ease of handling, lower recoil, and maintenance simplicity make it an incredibly practical choice, especially for everyday carry. The Glock 42 strikes a balance between performance, convenience, and reliability, making it my go-to choice in this comparison.
FAQ’s
What is the effective range of the Glock 42?
The effective range of the Glock 42 is typically around 10 to 30 feet for self-defense, but it can accurately hit targets over 100 feet in skilled hands.
How many rounds can a SIG P238 hold?
The SIG P238 can hold either a 6- or 7-round single-column detachable box magazine, depending on the magazine choice.
Is Sig P238 safe to carry?
The Sig P238, with its reliable performance and manual safety, is considered safe for carry, especially with proper training and proficiency in using its safety features.
Why is the Glock 42 so small?
The Glock 42 is designed to be small and highly portable, ideal for concealed carry, due to the smaller .380 ACP round it uses.
