I’m diving into a head-to-head comparison of two popular SIG SAUER models: the SIG P229 Vs SIG P365.
As a professional shooter, I’ve had the opportunity to test both beauties in the field. Let’s face it: choosing the right gun is no small task, especially when each has its own set of strengths.
In this article, I will break down the details of each gun. We’ll look at their specs, handling, and overall performance to see which one comes out on top.
| Specification | SIG P229 | SIG P365XL |
| Caliber | 9mm Luger, .357 SIG, .40 S&W | 9mm Luger |
| Overall Length | 7.1 inches | 6.6 inches |
| Barrel Length | 3.8 inches | 3.7 inches |
| Overall Height | 5.4 inches | 4.8 inches |
| Overall Width | 1.5 inches | 1.1 inches |
| Weight (w/o Magazine) | 27.5 oz. | 20.7 oz. |
| Magazine Capacity | 13 rounds | 12+1 rounds |
Overview of Sig P229
The SIG P229, a true classic in the SIG lineup, is renowned for its reliability and versatility. This model is a top pick for many law enforcement agencies worldwide.
Specs
- Caliber Options: 9mm Luger, .357 SIG, .40 S&W
- Overall Length: 7.1 inches
- Overall Height: 5.4 inches
- Overall Width: 1.5 inches
- Barrel Length: 3.8 inches
- Number of Rifling Grooves: 6
- Sight Radius: 5.7 inches
- Weight without Magazine: 27.5 oz.
- Empty Magazine Weight: 3.0 oz.
- Trigger Pull: Double Action 12 lbs., Single Action 4.5 lbs.
- Accessory Rail: 1913 Picatinny
- Magazine Capacity: 13 rounds
Overview of Sig P365
The SIG P365 perfectly balances a compact and a subcompact firearm. It’s a sleek, modern choice, especially for those looking for a more concealable option.
Specs
- Capacity: 12+1 9mm
- Barrel Length: 3.7 inches
- Overall Width: 1.1 inches
- Overall Length: 6.6 inches
- Overall Height: 4.8 inches
- Sights: Optic-ready with iron night sights
- Weight: 20.7 oz.
Features Comparison: SIG P229 Vs SIG P365
1. Size and Concealability
SIG P229
The P229, with its larger frame (7.1 inches in length and 1.5 inches in width), offers a more substantial grip. This size, though advantageous for handling, poses a challenge for concealment. In my tests, its bulk was noticeable under clothing, making it less ideal for discreet carry.
SIG P365
The P365, measuring 6.6 inches in length and just over 1 inch wide, is a marvel in compact design. When testing for concealability, it easily outperformed the P229. Its slender build made it almost invisible under clothing, offering a more comfortable and discreet carry option.
Winner
In terms of size and concealability, the P365 is the clear winner compared to the P229. Its sleek, compact design offers significant advantages for those seeking a firearm that’s easy to conceal and comfortable to carry throughout the day.
2. Weight and Handling
SIG P229
The P229’s weight (27.5 oz. without the magazine) gives it a solid, reliable feel. During testing, this weight contributed to steadier handling and reduced recoil. However, for all-day carry, this heft can become burdensome, especially when active or on the move.
SIG P365
The P365, at a lighter 20.7 oz., offers a significant advantage in terms of weight. Throughout my testing, this lighter frame made it much more comfortable for extended periods, particularly in situations requiring agility or discreet movement.
Winner
When comparing weight and handling, the P365 stands out compared to the P229. Its lighter frame provides easier handling and greater comfort for long-term carry, making it a better choice for those who need a nimble and less intrusive firearm.
3. Trigger and Shooting Experience
SIG P229
The P229 features a double action/single action trigger, with a pull of 12 lbs./4.5 lbs. respectively. During field tests, this trigger system provided a reliable and consistent shooting experience. The heavier pull in double action ensures intentional firing, a feature I appreciated during tactical drills.
SIG P365
The P365, on the other hand, has a smoother, lighter trigger pull. In my testing, this resulted in quicker and more accurate follow-up shots. The trigger’s responsiveness was particularly noticeable in rapid-fire scenarios, offering a more fluid shooting experience.
Winner
Comparing the trigger and shooting experience, the P365 edges out the P229. Its lighter and smoother trigger offers a more responsive and enjoyable shooting experience, especially in scenarios where speed and accuracy are paramount.
4. Sight Options and Visibility
SIG P229
The P229’s standard sights provide clear and accurate targeting. In my tests, I found the sight picture to be crisp and easy to align, which helped in achieving precision shots.
The 5.7-inch sight radius aids in better sight alignment and accuracy, a feature that’s particularly beneficial for longer-range shooting.
SIG P365
The P365 comes optic-ready with iron night sights, a feature that stands out in low-light conditions. During my testing, these sights proved to be highly effective in dim environments, enhancing target visibility.
The ability to easily add a red dot sight due to its optic-ready design further elevates its versatility.
Winner
When it comes to sight options and visibility, the P365 has an edge over the P229, especially in low-light conditions.
Its night sights and optic-ready design offer greater flexibility and effectiveness in varied lighting scenarios, making it a superior choice for users who prioritize sight versatility and adaptability.
Pros & Cons of Sig P229
Pros
- Solid, reliable feel due to its heavier weight.
- Enhanced stability and reduced recoil, benefiting accuracy.
- Robust accessory rail for diverse customization options.
- Crisp, consistent trigger pull in both double and single action.
- Larger sight radius aiding in precision shooting.
Cons
- Bulkier frame makes concealment more challenging.
Pros & Cons of SIG P365
Pros
- Compact and lightweight, ideal for concealed carry.
- Sleek design makes it comfortable for all-day carry.
- Optic-ready with effective night sights for low-light scenarios.
- Smooth, light trigger pull enhances rapid-fire accuracy.
- Easier to conceal due to its slim profile.
Cons
- Limited sight radius compared to larger models.
Similarities Between SIG P229 & SIG P365
- Both are designed for 9mm Luger caliber.
- Feature iron sights for aiming accuracy.
- Equipped with accessory options for customization.
- Designed with ergonomics in mind for better handling.
- Offered by the renowned manufacturer SIG SAUER.
Differences Between SIG P229 & SIG P365
- P229 is heavier and bulkier compared to P365.
- P365 is more compact and lighter for concealed carry.
- P229 has a longer overall length and barrel than P365.
- P365 is more streamlined in width for sleeker carry.
- P229 has a larger sight radius, aiding in long-range accuracy.
- P365’s design focuses on concealability and lightness.
- Trigger mechanism differs between P229 (SA/DA) and P365.
- P229 is favored for its robustness, P365 for its portability.
Final Verdict
After thoroughly testing and comparing the SIG P229 and P365, the decision on which is the better gun comes down to specific needs and preferences. While each firearm excels in its own right, my choice leans towards the SIG P365.
This preference isn’t about undermining the P229’s robustness and reliability, which are beyond question. Instead, it’s about recognizing the evolving needs of modern shooters who value compactness, ease of carry, and versatility.
The P365’s impressive blend of concealability, lightweight design, and smooth shooting experience makes it a more practical choice for everyday carry, especially in scenarios where discretion and comfort are paramount.
FAQ’s
Is a Sig P229 good for concealed carry?
Yes, the SIG P229 is good for concealed carry, particularly in colder months when heavier clothing can more easily conceal its larger size.
Is the SIG P229 worth the money?
Absolutely, the SIG P229 is worth the money for its reliability and robustness, making it a fine choice for those who don’t mind its bulk.
Is the P365 accurate?
Yes, the P365 is notably accurate, offering impressive performance even for novice shooters with a bit of practice.
Is Sig P365 too big for concealed carry?
No, the Sig P365 is not too big for concealed carry; its thin profile and short grip make it suitable for various carry styles, including AIWB.
