I’m a professional shooter, and today, I’m diving into a comparison between the SIG P227 Vs SIG P220.
As someone who spends a lot of time on the range, I’ve had the chance to put these two impressive firearms through their paces.
In this article, I aim to give you an honest, hands-on comparison.
| Feature | SIG P227 | SIG P220 |
| Caliber | .45 ACP | .45 ACP |
| Magazine Capacity (Standard/Extended) | 10/14 rounds | 8/10 rounds |
| Barrel Length | 4.4 inches | 4.4 inches |
| Overall Length | 7.7 inches | 7.7 inches |
| Height | 5.5 inches | 5.5 inches |
| Width | 1.5 inches | 1.5 inches |
| Weight (Unloaded) | 32.0 oz | 30.4 oz |
Overview of Sig P227
The SIG P227, a relatively new player in the SIG lineup, boasts a blend of power and capacity.
Specs
- Caliber: .45 ACP
- Magazine Capacity: 10 rounds standard, 14 rounds (extended)
- Barrel Length: 4.4 inches
- Overall Length: 7.7 inches
- Height: 5.5 inches
- Width: 1.5 inches
- Weight: 32.0 oz (with unloaded magazine)
Overview of SIG P220
The SIG P220 is a classic, known for its reliability and craftsmanship.
Specs
- Caliber: .45 ACP
- Magazine Capacity: 8 rounds standard, option for 10 rounds (extended)
- Barrel Length: 4.4 inches
- Overall Length: 7.7 inches
- Height: 5.5 inches
- Width: 1.5 inches
- Weight: 30.4 oz
Features Comparison: SIG P227 Vs SIG P220
1. Grip and Handling
SIG P227
The SIG P227 stands out with its grip texture and ergonomic design, particularly for those with larger hands. The semi-staggered magazine leads to a slightly thicker grip, offering a more substantial feel.
During extensive testing, I found this design provided a robust and secure grip. The aggressive texture ensures a firm hold without discomfort, crucial in varied shooting conditions. This design enhances control, especially important when handling the powerful .45 ACP rounds.
SIG P220
In contrast, the SIG P220 features a slimmer profile reminiscent of the classic 1911 style. This sleek design is particularly beneficial for shooters with smaller hands or those who favor a traditional grip.
During testing, the slimmer profile of the P220 facilitated an easier and more natural trigger reach. This feature is a significant advantage in scenarios requiring rapid and precise shooting, where ease of trigger access and comfort are paramount.
Winner
Choosing a winner for grip and handling is tough, but the P227 slightly edges out, especially for those who value a more substantial grip. Its wider grip, compared to the P220, ensures a more comfortable and controlled handling during prolonged use, making it the preferred choice in this aspect.
2. Trigger and Shooting Experience
SIG P227
Both the P227 and P220 are equipped with a double-action/single-action trigger system. In my field tests with the P227, the trigger’s performance was consistent and smooth.
The transition from the initial heavy double-action pull to the subsequent lighter single-action was seamless and intuitive. This feature significantly contributed to a pleasurable and efficient shooting experience, making rapid firing sequences more manageable and precise.
SIG P220
The P220’s trigger shares similar characteristics with the P227 in terms of pull weight and responsiveness. However, the slimmer grip profile of the P220 alters the trigger reach slightly. This became increasingly evident in fast-paced shooting drills.
The P220’s trigger ergonomics seemed to offer a slight edge, providing a quicker and more comfortable trigger engagement, which is crucial in high-stress or competitive shooting environments.
Winner
Comparing the two, the SIG P220 emerges as the winner in trigger and shooting experience. Its slightly superior trigger ergonomics, especially for those with smaller hands or who prefer a closer trigger reach, give it an advantage in scenarios that demand rapid and precise shooting.
3. Aesthetics and Design
SIG P227
The SIG P227 boasts a modern, tactical appearance with its full-size frame and contemporary grip design.
The aesthetics are particularly appealing for those seeking a firearm with a modern touch. Design elements like the checkering on the front strap and the trigger guard not only enhance the visual appeal but also contribute functionally to the grip’s effectiveness.
This updated look, combined with practical design improvements, makes the P227 stand out in both appearance and usability.
SIG P220
The SIG P220, especially the older models, embodies a classic and traditional firearm design. Its aesthetics are likely to appeal more to traditionalists and those who value the heritage and time-honored appearance of classic firearms.
The simplicity of its design translates into a sleek and uncluttered appearance, giving it a unique and distinguished charm that resonates with many shooters.
Winner
When it comes to aesthetics and design, the SIG P227 is the clear winner when compared to the P220. Its modern design elements, which provide both a tactical advantage and functional improvements in grip and handling, are particularly appealing to those who prefer a contemporary look in their firearms.
4. Ergonomics and Control
SIG P227
The P227’s slightly wider grip, compared to the P220, offers an enhanced ergonomic experience, particularly for those with larger hands.
This design provides a more secure hold and better control, especially when firing multiple rounds. During my field tests, I found this extra width made a noticeable difference in handling stability.
SIG P220
The P220, on the other hand, with its slimmer profile, offers a different ergonomic advantage. It feels more like a traditional, streamlined handgun, making it easier to handle for shooters with smaller hands or those accustomed to single-stack pistols. Its ergonomics are well-suited for precise, controlled shooting.
Winner
The winner for ergonomics and control, compared to the other gun, is the SIG P227. Its wider grip provides better control and a more comfortable hold during extended shooting sessions, making it ideal for those who prioritize stability and comfort.
Pros & Cons: SIG P227
Pros
- Enhanced grip texture for better control.
- Slightly wider grip suited for larger hands.
- Offers a semi-staggered magazine for a balance between capacity and grip size.
Cons
- Slightly heavier than the P220.
Pros & Cons: SIG P220
Pros
- Slimmer profile ideal for smaller hands and traditional preferences.
- Lighter in weight, offering easier maneuverability.
- Classic, timeless design appealing to traditionalists.
Cons
- Some may find the grip too narrow for optimal control.
Similarities Between SIG P227 & SIG P220
- Both chambered in .45 ACP.
- Identical barrel length of 4.4 inches.
- Same overall length of 7.7 inches.
- Equal height of 5.5 inches.
- Identical width of 1.5 inches.
- Both feature double action/single action trigger systems.
- Similar aesthetics, maintaining SIG Sauer’s design language.
Differences Between SIG P227 & SIG P220
- P227 has a semi-staggered magazine, offering higher capacity.
- P220 uses a single-stack magazine, resulting in a slimmer grip.
- P227 is slightly heavier (32.0 oz) compared to P220 (30.4 oz).
- Grip texture and ergonomics vary, with P227 having a more modern design.
- P227 may offer more contemporary features in newer models compared to older P220s.
Final Verdict
After extensive testing and comparison of the SIG P227 and SIG P220, my final verdict leans towards the SIG P227. This choice isn’t just about a specific feature or a technical spec; it’s about how the firearm feels and performs as a whole.
The P227 strikes an impressive balance between modern design and functionality, making it a versatile choice for a variety of shooters. Its ergonomic advantages, coupled with a contemporary aesthetic, align well with the needs of today’s shooters who demand both performance and style.
While the P220 is a formidable firearm in its own right, the P227 emerges as my personal choice for its blend of comfort, control, and modern features.
FAQ’s
What is the difference between Sig P220 and P226?
The primary difference is in caliber and magazine capacity. The P226 typically comes in 9mm with a higher magazine capacity, while the P220 is a .45 ACP with a smaller capacity.
What’s the difference between the Sig Sauer P220 and P227?
The key difference is in the magazine capacity. The P227 uses a double-stack magazine, increasing the capacity to 10+1 rounds compared to the P220’s 8+1 rounds in a single-stack format.
Why is the SIG P220 so expensive?
The SIG P220’s higher price is due to its production in high-wage countries and its construction, featuring steel and aluminum, which are more expensive than the polymer used in many other pistols.
Is Sig P220 accurate?
Yes, the Sig P220 is renowned for its accuracy, often delivering exceptional precision at 25 yards with the right ammunition.
Does the SIG P227 have a safety?
The SIG P227 does not have an external manual safety but features Sig Sauer’s Four-Point safety system, including a decocking lever and automatic firing-pin safety block.
