Let’s dive into a side-by-side comparison of two remarkable handguns: the SIG P225 Vs SIG P228.
As a professional shooter, I’ve had the pleasure of testing both these guns in the field. Now, it’s time to share what I’ve learned about these two and see which one might come out on top.
| Feature | SIG P225 | SIG P228 |
| Type | Semi-auto, double action, locked breech | Semi-auto, double action, locked breech |
| Caliber | 9mm Parabellum | 9mm Parabellum |
| Barrel Length | 3.6 inches | 3.9 inches |
| Overall Length | 6.9 inches | 7.1 inches |
| Weight | 30.5 ounces | 32.0 ounces |
| Sights | SIGLITE night sights or contrast sights | SIGLITE night sights or contrast sights |
| Finish | Nitron and hard-coat anodizing | Nitron and hard-coat anodizing |
| Magazine Capacity | 8+1 rounds | 15 rounds |
Overview of SIG P225
The SIG P225 is a classic, compact semi-auto that’s been a reliable choice for shooters for years.
Specs
- Type: Semi-auto, double action, locked breech
- Caliber: 9mm Parabellum
- Barrel Length: 3.6 inches
- Overall Length: 6.9 inches
- Weight: 30.5 ounces
- Sights: SIGLITE night sights or contrast sights
- Finish: Nitron and hard-coat anodizing
- Capacity: 8+1 rounds
Overview of SIG P228
The SIG P228, or the M11-A1, is a robust and reliable choice, particularly favored in military and law enforcement circles.
Specs
- Caliber: 9mm
- Length: 7.1 inches
- Height: 5.4 inches
- Width: 1.5 inches
- Weight: 32.0 ounces (with magazine)
- Barrel Length: 3.9 inches
- Trigger Pull: Double action 10 lbs, single action 4.4 lbs
- Magazine Capacity: 15 rounds
Features Comparison: SIG P225 VS SIG P228
1. Handling and Ergonomics
SIG P225
The P225, with its sleek and compact design, feels just right in the hand. The single-stack design makes it thinner and more comfortable for smaller hands.
In the field, this translates to better maneuverability and ease of use. It’s smooth to operate, even in high-stress scenarios, making it a reliable choice for quick, accurate shooting.
SIG P228
On the flip side, the P228, with its slightly larger frame, provides a more substantial grip. This can be a big plus for shooters with larger hands.
It feels more robust and sturdy, which some may find gives them more control, especially during rapid fire. The double-stack design, while making it a bit bulkier, also lends a certain balance that’s hard to overlook.
Winner
Compared to the P225, the P228 edges out slightly in terms of handling and ergonomics for a broader range of users.
Its more substantial feel provides a sense of control and stability, especially in extended shooting sessions. However, for those specifically looking for a sleeker, more compact feel, the P225 holds its ground.
2. Durability and Maintenance
SIG P225
The P225 is known for its robust build and reliability. It withstands regular use with ease, showing minimal wear and tear.
Maintenance is straightforward, but it’s important to note that it’s a bit less forgiving when shot dirty compared to the P228. Keeping it clean ensures optimal performance.
SIG P228
In contrast, the P228 demonstrates a remarkable tolerance for being shot in less-than-clean conditions.
This feature can be invaluable in field scenarios where meticulous cleaning isn’t always feasible. It’s built to endure, with a reputation for maintaining performance even under challenging conditions.
Winner
When it comes to durability and ease of maintenance, the P228 takes the lead compared to the P225. Its ability to perform reliably even when not pristinely clean gives it an edge, especially for users who might find themselves in situations where thorough, regular cleaning isn’t always possible.
3. Accuracy and Performance
SIG P225
The P225 is a standout in terms of accuracy. Its compact design and smooth trigger action contribute to a precise shooting experience.
Many users, myself included, find that it shoots better than expected, consistently hitting targets with impressive accuracy.
SIG P228
The P228, while also highly accurate, offers a different shooting experience. Its slightly larger size and heavier build can help stabilize the hand during shooting, which can be a significant factor in maintaining accuracy during rapid firing sequences.
Winner
Compared to the P228, the P225 narrowly wins in the accuracy department. Its design seems to naturally facilitate a more precise shot, especially for those who prioritize a nimble and responsive firearm.
The P228, though close behind, is better suited for those who value a more substantial feel to aid in their shooting steadiness.
4. Recoil Management
SIG P225
The P225, with its lighter frame and single-stack design, handles recoil impressively. In my testing, I found that its recoil was manageable and didn’t significantly affect follow-up shots.
This makes it particularly suitable for shooters who might be more sensitive to recoil or those who value a smoother shooting experience.
SIG P228
The P228, in comparison, has a slightly heavier frame due to its double-stack magazine. This extra weight actually helps in absorbing some of the recoil, making the shooting experience steadier.
During field tests, the P228 demonstrated a remarkable ability to maintain stability, even during rapid firing sequences.
Winner
When it comes to managing recoil, the P228 slightly outperforms the P225, especially in
scenarios involving rapid firing.
The extra weight of the P228 helps in absorbing recoil, offering a more stable shooting experience. However, for those preferring a lighter firearm with still respectable recoil management, the P225 is a strong contender.
Pros & Cons of Sig P225
Pros
- Compact and lightweight, enhancing ease of carry.
- It is exceptionally comfortable for shooters with smaller hands.
- Smooth and accurate shooting performance.
- Superior concealability due to its slim profile.
- Simplified maintenance, though cleanliness is key for optimal performance.
Cons
- Potential issues with cycling when using +P ammunition.
Overview of SIG P228
Pros
- It has a more robust and substantial grip, suitable for larger hands.
- Higher ammunition capacity, offering extended use without reloading.
- Better recoil management due to its slightly heavier frame.
- More tolerant of being shot in dirty conditions.
- Less prone to issues when using +P ammo (though not recommended as a steady diet).
Cons
- Might be less comfortable for shooters with smaller hands.
Similarities between SIG P225 & SIG P228
- Both are semi-automatic, double-action handguns with locked breeches.
- Caliber: Both chambered in 9mm Parabellum.
- Renowned for their accuracy and reliability.
- Feature SIGLITE night sights or contrast sights options.
- Finished with Nitron and hard-coat anodizing for durability.
- Renowned for their solid build and quality craftsmanship.
- Both models are popular among both civilians and law enforcement.
Differences Between SIG P225 Vs SIG P228
- P225 is more compact with an overall length of 6.9 inches, compared to P228’s 7.1 inches.
- P225 weighs slightly less at 30.5 oz., while P228 weighs 32.0 oz.
- Barrel length of P225 is 3.6 inches, shorter than P228’s 3.9 inches.
- P225 has a single-stack magazine design, while P228 features a double-stack.
- P225 has a smaller grip size, catering to shooters with smaller hands.
- P225 is more suited for concealed carry due to its slimmer profile.
- P228 has a higher standard magazine capacity of 15 rounds, compared to P225’s 8+1.
- P228 is more forgiving when used in dirty conditions, unlike the P225.
- P225 requires caution with +P ammo, while P228 handles it better.
Final Verdict
As a shooter who has rigorously tested both the SIG P225 and P228, reaching a final verdict isn’t straightforward, as each gun has its unique strengths.
However, considering the overall balance of features, usability in various scenarios, and personal experience in the field, SIG P225 edges out as the more versatile option. This choice isn’t just about the technical specs; it’s about how these guns feel in hand, how they perform under pressure, and their adaptability to different shooting contexts.
FAQ’s
What is the difference between Sig P226 and P228?
The main difference lies in the ammunition: the Sig P226 can fire 9mm, .40 S&W, or .357 SIG, while the P228 is exclusively chambered for 9mm Parabellum.
Is Sig P226 a good carry gun?
Yes, the Sig P225 is an excellent carry gun, known for its reliability, compact size, and accuracy, making it a favored choice among law enforcement and for self-defense.
Is the SIG P228 accurate?
The SIG P228 is highly accurate, capable of confidently hitting targets up to 100 yards, with an effective range of 50 meters.
