I’m here to dive deep into a hot topic in the firearm community: the face-off between the Glock 43 Vs Springfield XD-S.
As a professional shooter, I’ve tested both guns in the field, putting them through their paces. We’re not just talking specs here; we’re talking real-world, hands-on experience to see which stands out as the winner.
So, let’s get down to it and see how these two stack up!
| Specification | Glock 43 | Springfield XD-S |
| Caliber | 9x19mm | 9x19mm |
| Magazine Capacity | Standard: 6 rounds | Flush: 7+1 rounds, Extended: 9+1 rounds |
| Barrel Length | 3.41 inches | 3.3 inches |
| Weight (With Empty Magazine) | 17.99 oz | 23 oz |
| Overall Length | 6.26 inches | 6.3 inches |
| Height (Including Magazine) | 4.25 inches | 4.4 inches |
| Overall Width | 1.06 inches | 0.9 inches |
Overview of Glock 43
The Glock 43 is a compact powerhouse, a true workhorse in the concealed carry world. Known for its reliability and efficiency, it’s a go-to for many gun enthusiasts.
Specs
- Caliber: 9x19mm
- System: Safe Action®
- Magazine Capacity Standard: 6 rounds
- Barrel Length: 3.41 inches
- Weight (With empty magazine): 17.99 oz
- Trigger Pull: Approximately 5.4 lbs (24 N)
- Overall Length: 6.26 inches
- Slide Length: 6.06 inches
- Overall Width: 1.06 inches
- Slide Width: 0.87 inch
- Height (including Magazine): 4.25 inches
Overview of Springfield XD-S
The Springfield XD-S brings its A-game as a top contender in the concealed carry market. It’s a firearm that marries form and function beautifully.
Specs
- Caliber: 9x19mm
- Length: 6.3 inches
- Height: 4.4 inches
- Width: 0.9 inches
- Barrel Length: 3.3 inches
- Weight (With empty magazine): 23 oz
- Finish Options: Black or Flat Dark Earth frame; Slides in black (Melonite®) or stainless
- Capacity: 7+1 (flush magazine), 9+1 (extended magazine)
Features Comparison: Glock 43 VS Springfield XD-S
1. Size and Weight
Glock 43
The Glock 43 is renowned for its compactness and lightweight design. Weighing just 17.99 oz with an empty magazine, it’s incredibly easy to handle, especially for concealed carry.
Its overall length of 6.26 inches and height of 4.25 inches makes it very discreet and comfortable to carry around. During my field tests, I found its lightweight nature made it super convenient for long hours of carrying without any discomfort.
Springfield XD-S
On the other hand, the Springfield XD-S weighs a bit more at 23 oz with an empty magazine. This extra weight, although only a quarter of a pound more than the Glock 43, is noticeable during extended periods of carry.
Its dimensions are also slightly larger, with a length of 6.3 inches and a height of 4.4 inches. In the field, this added weight did offer a bit more stability during shooting, which some may find beneficial.
Winner
The Glock 43 edges out the Springfield XD-S for sheer portability and ease of concealment. Its lighter frame and slightly smaller size make it more convenient for everyday carry, especially for those who prioritize discretion and comfort.
However, the Springfield XD-S’s added weight could be a plus for those who prefer a more substantial feel during shooting, but overall, for size and weight, the Glock 43 takes the lead, compared to the Springfield XD-S.
2. Sights
Glock 43
The Glock 43 comes with basic plastic sights, which are quite standard. While functional, these sights are often replaced by users. In my field tests, I found them adequate for basic shooting, but the lack of advanced features like fiber optics or night visibility was noticeable, especially in low-light conditions.
Springfield XD-S
Springfield XD-S steps up the game with a red or green fiber optic front sight paired with a two-dot rear sight.
This setup provided a clearer and more precise aiming point during my tests. The fiber optics significantly differ in varied lighting conditions, offering better visibility and quicker target acquisition.
Winner
Without a doubt, the Springfield XD-S wins in the sights department. Including fiber optic sights as standard is a significant advantage, offering better visibility and accuracy, especially under challenging lighting conditions.
While the Glock 43’s sights are functional, they don’t match the enhanced capabilities of the Springfield XD-S’s sights, especially when you consider the improved experience right out of the box.
3. Trigger
Glock 43
The Glock 43 features a trigger with a shorter reset but a more abrupt break, weighing around 5.4 lbs. I noticed the reset advantage during testing, allowing for quicker follow-up shots.
However, the abruptness of the trigger break required some getting used to, which might concern less experienced shooters.
Springfield XD-S
The Springfield XD-S has a trigger with a cleaner and more precise break at approximately 6.1 lbs, but with a slightly longer reset.
In my field tests, the trigger felt smoother and more consistent, which was particularly noticeable during precision shooting.
Winner
The Springfield XD-S comes out ahead in this category. The cleaner and more consistent trigger break contributes significantly to shooting accuracy and overall comfort, especially during extended sessions.
While the Glock 43’s shorter reset is commendable, the smoother trigger action of the Springfield XD-S offers a better shooting experience, especially when precision is key. The difference is subtle but significant, making the Springfield XD-S the preferred choice in this aspect, compared to the Glock 43.
4. Grip and Ergonomics
Glock 43
The grip on the Glock 43 is quite basic in texture, which can be a bit of a letdown when handling the gun in conditions where your hands might be wet.
However, it’s not all bad news. The simplicity of the grip design allows for easy customization. In my own testing, I found that applying aftermarket solutions like Talon Grips significantly improved the handling experience.
Springfield XD-S
The Springfield XD-S boasts a more aggressive grip texture right out of the box. This provides a secure and comfortable hold, especially in rapid fire or under stressful conditions.
Additionally, the XD-S features an interchangeable back strap, which can be a game-changer for shooters with different hand sizes. In my tests, the grip felt more secure and less likely to slip, even with sweaty hands.
Winner
The Springfield XD-S takes the win in this category. Its superior texture and customizable back strap offer a better out-of-the-box experience, especially when grip and control are paramount.
The Glock 43, while still a solid choice, requires additional investments to reach the same level of comfort and control, especially compared to the Springfield XD-S.
Pros & Cons of Glock 43
Pros
- Lightweight and compact, ideal for concealed carry.
- Simple design allows for easy customization of the grip.
- Shorter trigger reset for quicker follow-up shots.
Cons
- Basic grip texture requires aftermarket improvements for better handling.
Pros & Cons of Springfield XD-S
Pros
- Comes with superior fiber optic front sight for better accuracy.
- More aggressive grip texture and interchangeable back strap for enhanced ergonomics.
- Higher magazine capacity (7+1 flush, 9+1 extended) compared to the Glock 43.
Cons
- The trigger, while clean and precise, has a slightly longer reset.
5 Most Common Glock 43 Problems
Similarities Between Glock 43 & Springfield XD-S
- Both are chambered in 9x19mm caliber.
- Similar overall size, making them both suitable for concealed carry.
- Both models are popular choices for personal defense firearms.
- Each offers two magazine options, including a variant with a pinky extension.
- Both have customizable features, like sights and grips, to enhance usability.
- Require similar maintenance and handling practices.
Differences Between Glock 43 & Springfield XD-S
- Glock 43 is lighter by about 4.5 ounces compared to the Springfield XD-S.
- Springfield XD-S has a higher magazine capacity compared to the Glock 43.
- Glock 43 has a more abrupt trigger break; Springfield XD-S’s trigger is cleaner.
- Springfield XD-S features a back strap safety, absent in Glock 43.
- Different standard sights: Glock 43 with plastic sights, Springfield XD-S with fiber optics.
- Glock 43 has a polymer magazine, while Springfield XD-S uses metal magazines.
- The grip texture and ergonomics vary significantly between the two models.
- Different finishes available for each model, offering aesthetic choices.
Final Verdict
After thoroughly testing and comparing the Glock 43 and Springfield XD-S, it’s time for the final verdict. Both firearms have proven their mettle in various aspects, from ergonomics to performance.
The Springfield XD-S, however, stands out with its higher magazine capacity, superior sights, and more ergonomic grip. Choosing between these two is tough, but based on overall performance and feature set, my preference leans towards the Springfield XD-S. Its balance of functionality, enhanced shooting experience, and robust build quality give it a slight edge over the Glock 43.
FAQ’s
Is XD9 better than Glock?
Yes, for concealability, the Springfield XD9 is likely better than the Glock 19, offering a more compact size that’s easier to carry discreetly.
Is the Springfield XD a Glock clone?
No, the Springfield XD is not a Glock clone. While it has some Glock-inspired elements, it possesses unique features that distinguish it from Glock models.
What gun is similar to Glock 43?
The Sig P938 is similar to the Glock 43, with both being super compact 9mm firearms. The Glock 43 is slightly longer but lighter due to its polymer construction.
Where are Springfield XDS made?
The Springfield Armory XD series, including the XD-S, is manufactured by HS Produkt in Karlovac, Croatia.
Is Springfield XD reliable?
Yes, the Springfield XD is highly reliable. It’s well-built, accurate, and has clear, easy-to-use sights, making it a favored choice for many shooters.
