I’ve tested and compared two popular firearms: the Glock 36 Vs S&W Shield 45. My hands-on experience in the field has given me insights into how these guns perform in real-world scenarios.
Let’s dive into a detailed comparison, breaking down their specifications and handling characteristics.
| Feature | Glock 36 | S&W Shield 45 |
| Caliber | .45 Auto | .45 ACP |
| Magazine Capacity | 6 rounds | 6+1 / 7+1 rounds |
| Barrel Length | 3.78 inches | 3.3 inches |
| Weight (Empty Magazine) | 22.40 oz | 22.7 oz |
| Overall Length | 6.97 inches | 6.45 inches |
| Width | 1.18 inches | .99 inches |
| Height (Including Magazine) | 4.72 inches | 4.88 inches |
| Trigger Pull | 28 N | ~5.5 lb |
Overview of Glock 36
The Glock 36 stands as a compact yet powerful option for those who prefer the reliability and design of Glock, especially in a .45 Auto caliber.
Specs
- Caliber: .45 Auto
- Magazine Capacity: Standard 6 rounds
- Barrel Length: 3.78 inches
- Weight (Empty Magazine): 22.40 oz
- Trigger Pull: 28 N
- Overall Length: 6.97 inches
- Slide Length: 6.77 inches
- Overall Width: 1.18 inches
- Slide Width: 1.0 inch
- Height (Including Magazine): 4.72 inches
Overview of S&W Shield 45
The S&W Shield 45 is a single-stack, slim, compact firearm designed for concealed carry with the substantial firepower of a .45 ACP.
Specs
- Caliber: .45 ACP
- Length: 6.45”
- Height: 4.88” with flush magazine
- Width: .99”
- Barrel: 3.3” (stainless steel Armornite™ finish)
- Trigger: ~5.5 lb.
- Sights: 3-Dot steel
- Safety: RH-side thumb safety
- Weight: 22.7 oz. w/empty magazine
- Capacity: 6+1 and 7+1 (extended magazine)
Features Comparison: Glock 36 Vs S&W Shield 45
1. Concealability
Glock 36
The Glock 36, with its slim 1.18-inch width and a height of 4.72 inches, offers great concealability. It’s pretty impressive for a .45 caliber.
The shorter barrel at 3.78 inches makes it easier to carry without much printing, especially for inside-the-waistband (IWB) carry. It is tucked away nicely under a jacket or a loose shirt during field tests.
S&W Shield 45
The S&W Shield 45 is slim and compact, with a width of just .99 inches and a slightly shorter overall length.
This makes it an ideal choice for those who prioritize maximum concealability. In practice, it’s barely noticeable when carried IWB or even in an ankle holster, making it an excellent choice for deep concealment.
Winner
Compared to the Glock 36, the S&W Shield 45 takes the lead in concealability. Its slimmer profile and compact dimensions make it easier to conceal without compromising grip and control.
2. Comfort & Controllability
Glock 36
The Glock 36’s wider grip provides a solid purchase, which is a big deal when handling the .45 Auto. It’s surprisingly comfortable to hold and shoot, with a balanced weight that helps manage recoil.
It felt secure and steady in hand during testing, even after multiple rounds.
S&W Shield 45
The Shield 45, with its aggressive grip texture, offers excellent control, especially for a compact firearm. Its slim frame, however, may not suit everyone, especially those with larger hands.
It was snappy but manageable in field tests, and the grip texture helped maintain a firm grip.
Winner
While the S&W Shield 45 has an impressive grip texture, the Glock 36 outshines it in overall comfort and controllability.
The larger grip area of the Glock 36, compared to the Shield, makes it more comfortable to hold and shoot, especially for extended periods.
3. Accuracy and Shooting Experience
Glock 36
The Glock 36, with its consistent trigger pull and stable grip, provides commendable accuracy. Its barrel length strikes a good balance between maneuverability and precision.
During testing, hitting targets at various distances was straightforward and reliable.
S&W Shield 45
The Shield 45’s shorter barrel and compact size might suggest a compromise in accuracy, but it holds its own. The trigger is crisp with a decent reset.
In practice, it performed admirably at close to medium ranges, which is what it’s designed for.
Winner
In terms of accuracy and shooting experience, the Glock 36 and S&W Shield 45 are neck and neck. However, the Glock 36 edges ahead slightly, thanks to its slightly longer barrel and stable shooting platform.
It’s just a bit more versatile in various shooting scenarios compared to the Shield 45.
4. Handling
Glock 36
The Glock 36’s handling is quite impressive for a .45 caliber firearm. It fits naturally in the hand, and the grip, though wider, is comfortable, providing a firm hold during firing.
During my field tests, the ergonomics of the Glock 36 made it easy to handle, especially during rapid fire sessions. Its balanced weight distribution adds to the ease of handling, making it a solid choice for shooters who value a steady grip and intuitive use.
S&W Shield 45
The S&W Shield 45, with its slimmer frame, offers a different ergonomic experience. The grip texture is aggressive, ensuring a secure hold even in intense shooting scenarios.
Its lighter and thinner profile might be more appealing to shooters with smaller hands or those who prioritize ease of carrying over grip size. In my testing, the Shield 45 was easy to maneuver and quick to aim, especially in scenarios simulating defensive shooting.
Winner
Comparing the two, the Glock 36 wins in terms of overall handling and ergonomics, especially for shooters who prefer a larger grip and a more substantial feel in the hand.
Its ergonomic design makes it more comfortable for extended shooting sessions. The S&W Shield 45, while excellent in its own right, caters more to those who prioritize compactness and may sacrifice some ergonomic benefits as a result.
Pros & Cons of Glock 36
Pros
- Reliable performance under various conditions.
- Comfortable grip and handling, suitable for extended use.
- Balanced weight aids in recoil management.
- Solid construction and durability.
Cons
- Slightly larger size may affect concealability compared to the Shield 45.
Pros & Cons of S&W Shield 45
Pros
- Extremely concealable due to slim design.
- Aggressive grip texture ensures firm hold.
- Lighter frame makes it easy to carry.
- Good ergonomics for quick aiming and shooting.
Cons
- Some shooters may find the recoil snappy.
Similarities between Glock 36 & S&W Shield 45
- Both chambered in .45 caliber.
- Similar magazine capacity with standard options.
- Both designed for personal defense and concealed carry.
- Equipped with standard 3-dot sighting systems.
- Comparable trigger pull characteristics.
Differences between Glock 36 & S&W Shield 45
- Glock 36 has a wider overall width compared to the Shield 45.
- Shield 45 is slimmer, enhancing its concealability.
- Glock 36 has a slightly longer barrel and overall length.
- Shield 45 offers a lighter frame for easier carry.
- Glock 36 is designed with a more traditional Glock ergonomics.
- Shield 45 has a more aggressive grip texture.
- Glock 36 typically perceived as more suitable for extended shooting sessions.
- Shield 45’s slim design targets users needing maximum concealment.
Final Verdict
After rigorously testing both the Glock 36 and the S&W Shield 45, I’ve come to a conclusion that may surprise some.
While both guns have their merits and cater to different preferences, the Glock 36 emerges as the winner in most of my comparisons. Its combination of comfort, controllability, and shooting accuracy gives it a slight edge.
The Glock 36 offers a balanced experience for both novice and experienced shooters, making it my top choice. It strikes the right balance between power, ergonomics, and versatility, which are essential qualities I look for in a firearm.
FAQs
What’s the difference between Smith and Wesson M&P and M&P Shield?
The main difference is the M2.0 model’s additional front slide serrations and a slightly tuned trigger group. Otherwise, they share many similarities.
How many rounds does M&P Shield 45 hold?
The M&P Shield 45 has a capacity of 6+1 or 7+1 rounds, combining compact size with effective firepower.
Is M&P Shield better than Glock?
The Glock 19 offers easier handling with less recoil compared to the M&P Shield, which is smaller and has more noticeable recoil.
Can Glock 36 take double stack?
No, the Glock 36 is designed for single-stack magazines, limiting its capacity to 6 rounds plus one in the chamber.
