I’ve had the opportunity to test out two remarkable pistols: the Glock 36 Vs Springfield XD-S. Both of these firearms have garnered attention for their unique features and capabilities.
Through rigorous field testing, I’ve gathered insights to help determine which one stands out as the winner. Let’s dive into the specifics of each gun and see how they stack up.
| Feature | Glock 36 | Springfield XD-S |
| Caliber | .45 Auto | .45 Auto |
| Magazine Capacity | 6 rounds | 7+1 rounds |
| Barrel Length | 3.78 inches | 3.3 inches |
| Weight (Empty Magazine) | 22.40 oz | 21.5 oz |
| Overall Length | 6.97 inches | 6.3 inches |
Glock 36
The Glock 36, a compact powerhouse, was introduced by Glock to offer a slimmer alternative for .45 Auto enthusiasts. Known for its reliability and solid construction, it’s been a steadfast choice since its inception.
Specs
- Caliber: .45 Auto
- Magazine Capacity: Standard 6 rounds
- Barrel Length: 3.78 inches
- Weight (Empty Magazine): 22.40 oz
- Trigger Pull: 28 N
- Overall Length: 6.97 inches
- Slide Length: 6.77 inches
- Overall Width: 1.18 inches
- Slide Width: 1.0 inch
- Height (Including Magazine): 4.72 inches
Springfield XD-S
The Springfield XD-S made waves as a highly versatile and compact .45ACP pistol. Its design and functionality cater to those seeking a reliable and easily concealable firearm.
Specs
- Caliber: .45 Auto
- Magazine Capacity: Standard 5 rounds
- Barrel Length: 3.3 inches
- Weight (Empty Magazine): 21.5 oz
- Trigger Pull: 27 N
- Overall Length: 6.3 inches
- Slide Length: 6.2 inches
- Overall Width: 1.0 inches
- Slide Width: 0.9 inch
- Height (Including Magazine): 4.4 inches
Features Comparison: Glock 36 VS Springfield XD-S
1. Ergonomics and Handling
Glock 36
The Glock 36, has a certain charm in its ergonomics. Its blocky handle and upright grip angle, characteristic of the Gen 3 models, provide a unique experience.
During my testing, I found my fingers surprisingly comfortable between the grooves, making the grip secure and the pistol well-balanced. The controls are intuitively placed and function seamlessly.
Springfield XD-S
The Springfield XD-S introduces a different approach to ergonomics. The aggressive checkering on the handle, while providing a secure grip, can be a bit too abrasive for some.
However, its balance is impeccable. The grip safety, a feature akin to the 1911, ensures the gun won’t fire unless held properly. This adds a layer of safety without being intrusive.
Winner
When it comes to ergonomics, the Glock 36 and Springfield XD-S offer different experiences. The Glock 36’s handle may not be universally loved, but it provides a surprisingly comfortable and secure grip.
The Springfield XD-S, with its aggressive checkering, can be less comfortable but offers excellent balance and an added safety feature.
Compared to the Glock 36, the XD-S’s grip safety is a notable addition, but the overall winner for ergonomics and handling is the Glock 36 for its unexpectedly comfortable grip and excellent balance.
2. Trigger Mechanism and Shooting Experience
Glock 36
The Glock 36 has a consistent trigger pull that Glock enthusiasts have come to appreciate. The trigger mechanism is straightforward and reliable.
During field tests, the trigger provided a predictable and crisp break with each shot, enhancing the shooting experience.
Springfield XD-S
Springfield’s XD-S offers a distinct trigger experience. It has a clear and tactile reset, which is particularly useful for rapid follow-up shots.
During my tests, the trigger felt smooth and contributed to the accurate shooting performance of the XD-S.
Winner
Both pistols excel in their trigger mechanisms, each providing a distinct shooting experience. Compared to the Springfield XD-S, the Glock 36’s trigger is more traditional and might appeal to Glock fans.
However, the XD-S, with its tactile reset and smooth operation, takes the lead in this category, offering a slightly better shooting experience overall.
3. Concealability and Capacity
Glock 36
The Glock 36, designed as a more compact version of the G30, offers decent concealability without sacrificing firepower. Its 6-round standard magazine capacity is adequate for a .45 Auto pistol of its size.
In my testing, it proved to be reasonably concealable while still feeling substantial in hand.
Springfield XD-S
The XD-S shines in the concealability department. Its slim profile and shorter barrel make it an excellent choice for concealed carry.
Additionally, the 7+1 capacity flush magazine is a step up in this class, offering more rounds than the Glock 36 in a similarly compact package.
Winner
In the realm of concealability and capacity, the Springfield XD-S takes the lead. Compared to the Glock 36, it offers a more compact frame and a higher standard magazine capacity, making it a superior choice for concealed carry without compromising on firepower.
4. Durability and Reliability
Glock 36
Glock is synonymous with durability. The Glock 36, with its robust build and proven track record, stands up to this reputation. In my field tests, the Glock 36 handled various ammunition types without a hitch.
It’s not just about surviving the elements; this pistol maintains its performance even after hundreds of rounds, showing minimal wear. That’s Glock for you; tough as nails and always reliable.
See 5 Most Common problems of Glock 36.
Springfield XD-S
The Springfield XD-S, while a newer entrant compared to the Glock 36, has shown remarkable durability in my testing. It handled different environments and conditions with ease.
However, the initial recall after its release does put a question mark on its reliability. After the upgrade, though, my XD-S performed flawlessly, even with different ammo types, but it’s that initial hiccup that sticks in your mind.
Winner
In the battle of durability and reliability, the Glock 36 edges out the Springfield XD-S. While the XD-S has proven itself post-recall, the Glock 36’s longer history of unwavering reliability gives it the upper hand in this category.
Compared to the Springfield XD-S, the Glock 36 offers a bit more peace of mind in terms of long-term durability and consistent performance, making it the winner here.
Pros & Cons of Glock 36
Pros
- Renowned Glock reliability and durability.
- Comfortable grip for many shooters, despite blocky design.
- Excellent fit and finish; well-made construction.
- Standard magazine capacity of 6 rounds is adequate for its size.
- Good balance and handling characteristics.
Cons
- Heavier weight compared to the Springfield XD-S.
Pros & Cons of Springfield XD-S
Pros
- Compact and highly concealable.
- Higher standard magazine capacity (7+1) than Glock 36.
- Aggressive checkering provides a firm grip.
- Additional safety feature with the grip safety.
- Good balance and easy handling.
Cons
- Slightly smaller sights can be challenging for quick target acquisition.
Similarities between Glock 36 & Springfield XD-S
- Both are single-stack pistols designed for .45 Auto caliber.
- Similar in overall size, making them both suitable for concealed carry.
- Steel and polymer construction for durability and lighter weight.
- Neither model is particularly flashy; more functional in design.
- Both pistols require the trigger to be pulled for field stripping.
Differences between Glock 36 & Springfield XD-S
- Glock 36 is known for its Glockian blocky design; XD-S has more aggressive checkering.
- Glock 36 has a 6-round magazine capacity, whereas XD-S has a 7+1 capacity.
- XD-S features a grip safety, which the Glock 36 lacks.
- XD-S had a recall issue, whereas Glock 36 is known for its consistent reliability.
- XD-S offers a slightly more premium look with its stainless slide and finish options.
- Glock 36 is generally considered to have a more universal grip feel compared to XD-S.
Final Verdict
After thorough testing and analysis of both the Glock 36 and the Springfield XD-S, my conclusion leans towards one clear winner.
While both pistols have their strengths and cater to different needs, the overall performance and reliability of the Glock 36 make it stand out. Its balance between ergonomics, durability, and handling gives it an edge, especially for those who value a consistent and reliable shooting experience.
The Springfield XD-S has its merits, particularly in concealability and capacity, but the Glock 36’s well-rounded attributes make it my preferred choice. It’s the kind of firearm that doesn’t just perform well on paper but also feels right in the hand and reliable in the field.
FAQ’s
What does XD-S stand for in Springfield pistols?
In Springfield pistols, “XD-S” stands for “eXtreme Duty Single-stack.” Introduced in 2012, the XD-S is a slim and compact version of the XD line, designed for full-power cartridge shooting.
What Glock model is the same size as the Glock 36?
The Glock model that is the same size as the Glock 36 is the Glock 30. Both have the same barrel length and overall length, with the G36 being thinner and lighter.
Which Springfield XD is best for concealed carry?
The Springfield XD 4” Service Model 9mm is considered excellent for civilian concealed carry, offering a good balance between size and shootability.
What is the difference between Springfield XD-S and XD-E?
The Springfield XD-S is smaller and more concealable than the XD-E, with a 7+1 capacity compared to the XD-E’s 8+1. However, the XD-S is less shootable with harder recoil control.
Does a Glock 36 have a safety?
The Glock 36, like all Glock pistols, has a safe action design, including a trigger safety, firing pin block safety, and drop safety, ensuring secure and safe operation.
