I’ve had my hands on a lot of guns. But today, we’re zeroing in on two legends: the Glock 34 Vs 1911. I’ve put these firearms through their paces in the field and am excited to share my insights.
We’re not just talking about specs here; it’s about real-world performance, how they handle, and what they bring to the table. So, let’s dive in and see how these two stack up against each other!
| Feature | Glock 34 | M1911 |
| Caliber | 9x19mm | .45 ACP |
| Magazine Capacity | 17 rounds (up to 33) | 7 rounds |
| Barrel Length | 5.31 inches | 5.0 inches |
| Weight (Empty) | 25.93 oz | 2.37 lbs |
| Overall Length | 8.82 inches | 8.62 inches |
| Width | 1.30 inches | 0.91 inches |
Overview of Glock 34
The Glock 34, a top choice for competitive shooters, is renowned for its accuracy and extended barrel.
Specs
- Caliber: 9x19mm
- Magazine Capacity: Standard 17 rounds (Options include 19, 24, 31, 33, 10)
- Barrel Length: 5.31 inches
- Weight With Empty Magazine: 25.93 oz
- Trigger Pull: 24 N
- Overall Length: 8.82 inches
- Slide Length: 8.15 inches
- Overall Width: 1.30 inches
- Slide Width: 1.0 inch
- Height (Including Magazine): 5.47 inches
Overview of Glock 1911
The M1911, a classic American pistol, is known for its reliability and .45 ACP stopping power.
Specs
- Caliber: .45 ACP (11.43 x 23 mm)
- Weight (Empty): 2.37 lbs
- Weight (Loaded): 2.49 lbs
- Overall Length: 8.62 inches
- Barrel Length: 5.0 inches
- Muzzle Velocity: 830 fps
- Magazine Capacity: 7 rounds
- Sighting Range: 54.68 yards
- Effective Fire Range: 54.68 yards
Features Comparison: Glock 34 vs 1911
1. Size and Concealability
Glock 34
The Glock 34, with its 5.31-inch barrel and 8.82-inch overall length, seems daunting for concealment. But in practice, its 1.30-inch width isn’t significantly more than the 1911.
During my tests, despite its longer slide, the Glock 34 tucked away more smoothly than anticipated. Its flat top and streamlined design contribute to a less bulky appearance and feel, challenging the myth of its cumbersome nature.
1911
The 1911, traditionally admired for its sleek design, measures approximately 0.91 inches in width. This slimmer build naturally lends itself to easier concealment.
However, its external hammer sometimes complicates quickdraws. My field tests confirmed that its shorter length aids in concealment, but this advantage can be offset by the snagging potential of the hammer, especially under stress.
Winner
Comparing both, the 1911 slightly wins in terms of size and concealability. Its slender frame makes it a more comfortable choice for everyday carry, particularly under light clothing.
However, the Glock 34’s deceptive size belies its actual ease of concealment, making it a close second. The decision here hinges on personal preference and carrying conditions.
2. Magazine Capacity and Weight
Glock 34
The Glock 34 stands out with its higher magazine capacity, starting at 17 rounds with options extending to 33. Even when loaded, it remains surprisingly light, balancing well in hand. In my field tests, using 21-round magazines didn’t significantly increase the weight, coming in at around 2 pounds, 14 ounces.
This high capacity and manageable weight balance makes the Glock 34 a formidable contender for those prioritizing firepower and ease of handling.
1911
The 1911, with a standard 7-round magazine, falls behind in capacity. However, its weight, even when loaded, is comparable to the Glock 34, hovering around 2 pounds, 15 ounces.
This similarity in weight, despite the lower capacity, is noteworthy. During my tests, the 1911’s heft felt reassuring, but the limited rounds meant more frequent reloads. For those valuing a classic feel with a simpler magazine, the 1911 holds its own, but it can’t match the Glock 34 in firepower.
Winner
The Glock 34 wins in this category. Its high magazine capacity, coupled with a weight comparable to the 1911, offers a significant advantage.
The ability to carry more rounds without a notable increase in weight is a crucial factor for many shooters. The 1911, while maintaining a classic appeal and comparable weight, doesn’t offer the same level of firepower. For scenarios demanding more rounds and less frequent reloading, the Glock 34 is a clear choice.
3. Handling
Glock 34
The Glock 34’s ergonomic design caters to a comfortable and secure grip, enhancing handling and accuracy. The longer barrel provided better stability and sight alignment during my field tests, contributing to more accurate shots.
Its polymer frame reduces weight, making it easier to handle for extended periods. Although heavier than the 1911, the trigger pull offers a consistent and predictable experience, which is crucial for precision shooting.
1911
The 1911 is renowned for its comfortable grip and excellent balance. Compared to the Glock 34, its heavier trigger pull might be a downside for some, but it offers a level of control that experienced shooters appreciate.
In my testing, the 1911 felt more natural in hand, possibly due to its historical design pedigree. The steel frame adds weight but also stability, which some shooters might prefer for its steadying effect on aim.
Winner
This category is a tight race, but the 1911 edges out slightly ahead. Its classic design and balance offer a level of comfort and control that is hard to beat.
The Glock 34, while also ergonomic and stable, can feel a bit unwieldy due to its longer barrel and lighter frame. In terms of handling, the
Pros & Cons of Glock 34
Pros
- High magazine capacity with various options up to 33 rounds.
- A longer barrel length (5.31 inches) aids in accuracy.
- Lighter weight with an empty magazine (25.93 oz) for easier handling.
- Versatile for competitive shooting due to its design and specs.
Cons
- Larger size can challenge concealment under certain conditions.
Pros & Cons of 1911
Pros
- Classic, time-tested design with historical significance.
- Slimmer profile (approx. 0.91 inches) for easier concealment.
- Known for its reliability and .45 ACP stopping power.
- Favored for its balance and ergonomic grip.
Cons
- Heavier weight compared to some modern pistols.
- External hammer can snag during quick draws.
Similarities between Glock 34 & 1911
- Both are widely recognized and used in various shooting disciplines.
- Renowned for their durability and reliability.
- Employed by both civilian shooters and professionals.
- Possess iconic status in the world of firearms.
Differences between Glock 34 & 1911
- Glock 34 uses 9x19mm caliber, while the 1911 uses .45 ACP.
- Glock 34 offers a higher standard magazine capacity.
- 1911 is slimmer in width compared to Glock 34.
- Glock 34 is lighter with an empty magazine.
- Glock 34’s design is more modern and utilizes polymer materials.
- Barrel length of Glock 34 is greater than that of the 1911.
- 1911’s design includes an external hammer, absent in Glock 34.
Final Verdict
After extensive testing and comparison, it’s clear that both the Glock 34 and the M1911 have their unique strengths and cater to different preferences. While the Glock 34 impresses with its modern design, high magazine capacity, and versatility, especially in competitive shooting, the M1911 holds its ground with its timeless design, slim profile, and historical significance.
In my experience, the Glock 34 emerges as the more adaptable choice for a variety of situations, largely due to its higher capacity and ergonomic advantages. Its modern design and flexibility make it a formidable choice for both competitive shooting and everyday carry.
FAQ’s
Is the 1911 the perfect pistol?
No, the 1911 isn’t the perfect pistol for everyone. Its external safety requires more training, and in a striker-fired world, it may not suit all shooters.
Why Glock 34 for competition?
The Glock 34 was developed for competition to achieve the greatest accuracy, thanks to its extended barrel, longer slide, and elongated distance between sights.
Is a 1911 a bad carry gun?
No, the 1911 isn’t a bad carry gun. It’s mechanically safe and effective, depending on the shooter’s skill. If a shooter finds they handle 1911 pistols well, it can be a good choice for them.
Is 1911 good for self defense?
Yes, the 1911 can be a good choice for home defense. Its ergonomics, trigger, and balance offer features that are hard to match, making it a considerable option for defending one’s home.
